Will Germany's New Social Media Law Kill Free Speech?

In October a new law comes into force in Germany that will impose huge fines on social networks if they don't delete illegal content including hate speech. It's touched off a huge debate over freedom of expression and has attracted an unusual collection of opponents.

The law, called Netzwerkdurchsetzungsgesetz, or  NetzDG for short obliges the biggest social networks, those with more than two million German users, to take down "blatantly illegal" hate speech within 24 hours of it being reported.

For material that's less obviously violating the law, networks such as Facebook and Instagram will have seven days to consider and, if appropriate, delete posts. Failure to meet these deadlines could lead to fines of up to €50m.

Critics argue the short timeframes coupled with the potentially large fines will lead social networks to be overly cautious and delete huge amounts of content - even things that are perfectly legal. But the law's supporters, and the German government, argue that it will force social media companies to proactively deal with online incitement and hate speech.

What counts as 'illegal hate speech' in Germany?

The law doesn't actually change what's considered hate speech in Germany. No new offences are created. The law simply cites sections of the German Criminal Code which details illegal speech online. The categories range from "forming terrorist organisations", to the much vaguer "defamation of religions, religious and ideological associations."

In addition, German law restricts some types of speech that are allowed in many other countries. For instance, the use of Nazi symbols is banned, as are the symbols and flags of some extremist groups.

An earlier draft of the NetzDG bill barred "defamation of the President of the Federation", but the clause was removed after criticism. The law has also been criticised for containing no legal mechanism for people whose posts are wrongly deleted to appeal to get them reinstated.

So who is worried?

Opposition has come from a wide range of groups and politicians on both the left and right, and Facebook has also made its disagreement with the law clear.

The United Nations has also weighed in. David Kaye, the UN's Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Expression, has written to the German government to warn about the potential consequences of the law.

"With these 24 hour and seven day deadlines - if you are a company you are going to want avoid fines and bad public branding of your platform," he says. "If there is a complaint about a post you are just going to take it down. What is in it for you to leave it up? I think the result is likely to be greater censorship."

The group Reporters without Borders says the German law has already inspired a "draconian" new online media law in Russia.

But there are voices in Germany who are in favour of the law and who argue that making social networks more responsible for hate speech and illegal content on their platforms is a good thing.
 
Anas Modamani is a refugee from Syria who now lives in Berlin. In August 2015 he was catapulted to notoriety for taking a selfie with Angela Merkel while she was visiting a migrant shelter.

But the picture would come back to haunt him, as it was used to accuse him of attacks in Brussels and Berlin. His famous photograph was cropped and pasted into wanted posters and false news reports.

"When I read the fake news on the internet, I really cried, it was really bad in my life, it was all untrue," Modamani says.

He decided to take Facebook to court for not doing enough to stop the lies being shared about him, but in March 2017 he lost the case. The court ruled Facebook had taken enough measures to attempt to block defamatory images of him for users in Germany.

Because of his experiences, Modamani is a supporter of NetzDG.

"I think the law is a good idea because people will be a little bit afraid, they can't just write what they want," he says. "I don't mind if other comments get deleted along with the bad ones."

Modamani's lawyer, Chan-Jo Jun, is also optimistic about the new law, and plans to use it immediately after it comes into effect.

On the other side of the legal debate is attorney Joachim Steinhoefel. While Chan-Jo Jun has taken Facebook to court to get them to remove posts, Steinhoefel has threatened the company with legal action to get a post reinstated.

In May, photojournalist Markus Hibbeler wrote a Facebook post about Islam and freedom of expression. Translated from German, the post read in part: "We shouldn't shield Muslims, and certainly not Islam, which has never been through an enlightenment or reformation, from criticism and constantly protect them."

His post was deleted by Facebook and his account was suspended for seven days. Hibbeler, with Steinhoefel's help, threatened to sue Facebook if the post wasn't put back up within a week and his account reinstated. They succeeded, and Facebook reinstated the post and apologised.

It's cases like Hibbeler's, Steinhoefel says, that show how NetzDG threatens freedom of expression. He says he doesn't trust Facebook to decide what posts are legal and illegal and thinks the most likely outcome will be a mass deletion of legal posts that Facebook doesn't want to take any risks with, out of an abundance of caution.

Opposition from social media companies

A Facebook spokesperson admitted to the BBC that they can't rule out the possibility of legal content being deleted.

"The law is not the right way to fight hate speech online," the spokesperson says. "It provides an incentive to delete content that is not clearly illegal and would have the effect of transferring responsibility for complex legal decisions from public authorities to private companies.

"Several legal experts have assessed the draft law as being against the German constitution and non-compliant with EU law. Facebook is committed to working in partnership with governments and civil society on solutions that would have made this law unnecessary."

The BBC also learnt that although the company will soon have another 500 content moderators based in Essen, in western Germany, Facebook has not hired any new staff in response to the law.

"We are still evaluating what the law really means for us," the spokesperson says.

Ein News

You Might Also Read: 

UK 'biggest audience' In EU For Jihadist Web Content:

Bashing Facebook Is Not The Answer To Curbing Russian Influence Operations:

 

« Wanted: A New Microchip For The AI Era
Using Big Data To Improve Customer Experience & Results »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

MIRACL

MIRACL

MIRACL provides the world’s only single step Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) which can replace passwords on 100% of mobiles, desktops or even Smart TVs.

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

Authentic8

Authentic8

Authentic8 transforms how organizations secure and control the use of the web with Silo, its patented cloud browser.

LockLizard

LockLizard

Locklizard provides PDF DRM software that protects PDF documents from unauthorized access and misuse. Share and sell documents securely - prevent document leakage, sharing and piracy.

Practice Labs

Practice Labs

Practice Labs is an IT competency hub, where live-lab environments give access to real equipment for hands-on practice of essential cybersecurity skills.

Cyber Security Recruiters

Cyber Security Recruiters

Cyber Security Recruiters is a niche recruiting firm who finds impact players for our clients in the Information Security Space.

Bechtel

Bechtel

Bechtel’s Industrial Control Systems Cyber Security Laboratory focuses on protecting large-scale industrial and infrastructure systems that support critical infrastructure.

Georgia Cyber Center

Georgia Cyber Center

Georgia Cyber Center is dedicated to training the next generation of professionals through education and real-world practice while also supporting innovation in new technologies for online defenses.

Cybersecurity Innovation Hub

Cybersecurity Innovation Hub

The main objective of the Hub is to bring cybersecurity and other advanced technologies closer to companies and as a result help to increase their performance as Industry 4.0.

CERT-PH

CERT-PH

CERT-PH is the National Computer Emergency Response Team and the highest body for cybersecurity related activities in the Philippines.

101 Blockchains

101 Blockchains

101 Blockchains is a professional and trusted provider of enterprise blockchain research and training.

Cobalt Iron

Cobalt Iron

Cobalt Iron is a global leader in SaaS-based enterprise backup and data protection technology.

Crypto International

Crypto International

Crypto International offers comprehensive services for the operation of our customers’ IT and communication infrastructure, with a focus on cybersecurity and encryption solutions.

Activu

Activu

Activu makes any information visible, collaborative, and proactive for people tasked with monitoring critical operations including network security.

Centre for Cyber Security Research and Innovation (CSRI) - Deakin University

Centre for Cyber Security Research and Innovation (CSRI) - Deakin University

CSRI solves the cyber security threats of tomorrow, today. We work with industry and government leaders on innovative research that has real-world impact.

IBM Security

IBM Security

IBM manufactures and markets computer hardware, middleware and software, and offers hosting and consulting services in areas ranging from mainframe computers to nanotechnology.

Willyama Services

Willyama Services

Willyama Services is a certified Information Technology and Cybersecurity professional services business providing services to government and private sector clients.

63 Moons Technologies (63MT)

63 Moons Technologies (63MT)

63 Moons Technologies is a world leader in providing next-generation technology ventures, innovations, platforms, and solutions.

Mindgard

Mindgard

The Mindgard Security Copilot platform secures your Artificial Intelligence, GenAI and LLMs.

IS4IT Kritis

IS4IT Kritis

IS4IT is your partner for the successful planning, introduction and implementation of company-specific information security concepts.

VeriBOM

VeriBOM

VeriBOM is a SaaS security and compliance platform that helps protect you and your customers through automation, documentation, and transparency for every software application you build or run.