What Happens When Two Countries Fight A Cyber War?

Imagine you woke up to discover a massive cyber-attack on your country. All government data has been destroyed, taking out healthcare records, birth certificates, social care records and so much more. The transport system isn’t working, traffic lights are blank, immigration is in chaos and all tax records have disappeared. The internet has been reduced to an error message and daily life as you know it has halted.

This might sound fanciful but don’t be so sure. When countries declare war on one another in future, this sort of disaster might be the opportunity the enemy is looking for.

The internet has brought us many great things but it has made us more vulnerable. Protecting against such futuristic violence is one of the key challenges of the 21st century.

Strategists know that the most fragile part of internet infrastructure is the energy supply.

The starting point in serious cyber warfare may well be to trip the power stations which power the data centres involved with the core routing elements of the network.

Back-up generators and uninterruptible power supplies might offer protection, but they don’t always work and can potentially be hacked.

In any case, backup power is usually designed to shut off after a few hours. That is enough time to correct a normal fault, but cyber-attacks might require backup for days or even weeks.

William Cohen, the former US secretary of defence, recently predicted such a major outage would cause large-scale economic damage and civil unrest throughout a country.

In a war situation, this could be enough to bring about defeat. Janet Napolitano, a former secretary at the US Department of Homeland Security, believes the American system is not well enough protected to avoid this.

Denial of service

An attack on the national grid could involve what is called a distributed denial of service (DDoS) attack.

These use multiple computers to flood a system with information from many sources at the same time. This could make it easier for hackers to neutralise the backup power and tripping the system.

DDoS attacks are also a major threat in their own right. They could overload the main network gateways of a country and cause major outages.

Such attacks are commonplace against the private sector, particularly finance companies. Akamai Technologies, which controls 30% of internet traffic, recently said these are the most worrying kind of attack and becoming ever more sophisticated.

Akamai recently monitored a sustained attack against a media outlet of 363 gigabits per second (Gbps) – a scale which few companies, let alone a nation, could cope with for long.

Networks specialist Verisign reports a shocking 111% increase in DDoS attacks per year, almost half of them over 10 Gbps in scale – much more powerful than previously. The top sources are Vietnam, Brazil and Columbia.

Scale of attacks

Most DDoS attacks swamp an internal network with traffic via the DNS and NTP servers that provide most core services within the network.

Without DNS the internet wouldn’t work, but it is weak from a security point of view.

Specialists have been trying to come up with a solution, but building security into these servers to recognise DDoS attacks appears to mean re-engineering the entire internet.

How to react

If a country’s grid were taken down by an attack for any length of time, the ensuing chaos would potentially be enough to win a war outright.

If instead its online infrastructure were substantially compromised by a DDoS attack, the response would probably go like this:

Phase one: Takeover of network: the country’s security operations centre would need to take control of internet traffic to stop its citizens from crashing the internal infrastructure. We possibly saw this in the failed Turkish coup a few weeks ago, where YouTube and social media went completely offline inside the country.

Phase two: Analysis of attack: security analysts would be trying to figure out how to cope with the attack without affecting the internal operation of the network.

Phase three: Observation and large-scale control: the authorities would be faced with countless alerts about system crashes and problems. The challenge would be to ensure only key alerts reached the analysts trying to overcome the problems before the infrastructure collapsed. A key focus would be ensuring military, transport, energy, health and law enforcement systems were given the highest priority, along with financial systems.

Phase four: Observation and fine control: by this stage there would be some stability and the attention could turn to lesser but important alerts regarding things like financial and commercial interests.

Phase five: Coping and restoring: this would be about restoring normality and trying to recover damaged systems. The challenge would be to reach this phase as quickly as possible with the least sustained damage.

State of play

If even the security-heavy US is concerned about its grid, the same is likely to be true of most countries. I suspect many countries are not well drilled to cope with sustained DDoS, especially given the fundamental weaknesses in DNS servers.

Small countries are particularly at risk because they often depend on infrastructure that reaches a central point in a larger country nearby.

The UK, it should be said, is probably better placed than some countries to survive cyber warfare.

It enjoys an independent grid and GCHQ and the National Crime Agency have helped to encourage some of the best private sector security operations centres in the world.

Many countries could probably learn a great deal from it. Estonia, whose infrastructure was disabled for several days in 2007 following a cyber-attack, is now looking at moving copies of government data to the UK for protection.

Given the current level of international tension and the potential damage from a major cyber-attack, this is an area that all countries need to take very seriously.

Better to do it now rather than waiting until one country pays the price. For better and worse, the world has never been so connected.

Bill Buchanan, Head, The Cyber Academy, Edinburgh Napier University

This article was originally published on The Conversation.

Ein News: http://bit.ly/2aXkBAy

« Interpol Catches The Leader Of $60m Cybercrime Gang
Red Team: IBM Cyber Security Service Revealed »

Infosecurity Europe
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

IT Governance

IT Governance

IT Governance is a leading global provider of information security solutions. Download our free guide and find out how ISO 27001 can help protect your organisation's information.

North Infosec Testing (North IT)

North Infosec Testing (North IT)

North IT (North Infosec Testing) are an award-winning provider of web, software, and application penetration testing.

CYRIN

CYRIN

CYRIN® Cyber Range. Real Tools, Real Attacks, Real Scenarios. See why leading educational institutions and companies in the U.S. have begun to adopt the CYRIN® system.

Syxsense

Syxsense

Syxsense brings together endpoint management and security for greater efficiency and collaboration between IT management and security teams.

Directory of Cyber Security Suppliers

Directory of Cyber Security Suppliers

Our Supplier Directory lists 7,000+ specialist cyber security service providers in 128 countries worldwide. IS YOUR ORGANISATION LISTED?

CloudInsure

CloudInsure

CloudInsure is a Cloud Insurance platform designed to specifically address emerging liabilities within the Cloud environment.

Logscape

Logscape

Logscape provides a big data analytical tool for log file analysis and operational analytics.

SQNetworks

SQNetworks

SQNetworks provides a full range of cybersecurity consultancy, services and solutions.

Elliptic

Elliptic

Elliptic solve the crucial problem of identity in cryptocurrencies, with the sole purpose of combating suspicious and criminal activity.

Gospel Technology

Gospel Technology

Gospel presents a totally new way of accessing and controlling data which is enterprise grade scalable, highly resilient, and secure.

Data Protection People

Data Protection People

Data Protection People are specialists in Data Privacy, Governance, and Information Security.

ISMS Accreditation Center (ISMS-AC)

ISMS Accreditation Center (ISMS-AC)

ISMS-AC is the national accreditation body for Japan. The directory of members provides details of organisations offering certification services for ISO 27001.

US-Africa Cybersecurity Group (USAFCG)

US-Africa Cybersecurity Group (USAFCG)

USAFCG provides cybersecurity consulting services and delivers training programs for capacity building in Africa.

NJVC

NJVC

NJVC delivers IT automation, optimization and security to empower mission-enabling IT for customers with secure requirements.

PreEmptive Solutions

PreEmptive Solutions

PreEmptive Protection hit the sweet spot between cost, convenience and functionality by helping you protect and secure your apps in a smarter way.

Xscale Accelerator

Xscale Accelerator

Xscale's vision is to create world-class startups out of India by transforming sales and providing access to global markets.

Mr Backup (MRB)

Mr Backup (MRB)

MRB offers Data Protection as a Service for businesses looking to reduce the time, cost and complexity of securing your company data.

Morpheus Enterprises

Morpheus Enterprises

Morpheus Enterprises offer managed security solutions designed to keep your web applications secure and your business running smoothly.

QuantumCTek

QuantumCTek

QuantumCTek is a Chinese pioneer and leader in commercialized quantum information technology (QIT).

Troye Computer Systems

Troye Computer Systems

Troye provide a complete range of digital workspace solutions that empower people to do their very best work in a safe and secure manner anywhere, anytime, using any device.

Incode

Incode

Incode is the leading provider of world-class identity solutions that is reinventing the way humans authenticate and verify their identities online.