What Does Brexit Mean For Britain's Spies?

As the UK negotiates its future relationship with the EU, two former intelligence chiefs have warned that Britain's security expertise should not become a "bargaining chip".

When terror attacks hit Paris in late 2015, British intelligence scrambled to find out what it could about the attackers, at the UK's spy agency, GCHQ, a team worked on tracing their communications while MI5 looked for connections to the UK.

It was all a sign that modern threats, whether terrorism, cyber-attacks or Russian subversion, rarely respect borders.

The Paris attacks showed that those responsible crossed borders with greater ease than information which might stop them. That led some to argue for closer co-operation, while others cited it as evidence of the need instead for stronger national border controls.

"Europe is going to be our security backyard forever," Sir John Sawers, a former head of MI6, told the BBC.
"And we need to be able to work very closely with our European partners in order to maximise our own security.

"And their security benefits our security. The more secure France is, the fewer dangerous people are likely to cross from Calais to Dover."

On one level, Brexit does little to threaten these key intelligence and security relationships. This is because in almost all cases the intelligence flows bilaterally, country to country, rather than through Brussels.

Former GCHQ head Robert Hannigan said: "As an institution, the EU's role is extremely limited. "It doesn't really get involved in any sharing of operational intelligence. The real co-operation on operations, counter-terrorism or cyber or hostile states, goes on bilaterally and always has." GCHQ, for instance, would have a liaison in Paris who could ensure information relevant to the protection of France would be shared quickly.

'Need our help'
Officials in Europe and the UK are also aware that intelligence and security is a relative British strength and other countries will not want to be cut off from Britain's contribution.  "The thing that is driving the quality of those relationships currently is the darkness of the threat and the common concern about it," Andrew Parker, the current head of MI5, told the Intelligence and Security Committee last year, with his comments included in its annual report.

"Half of Europe is scared of terrorism and the other half is scared of Russia and both halves want us to help them… That will not change with Brexit," he said. 

The only significant EU intelligence sharing body is INTCEN, which shares analysis of the threats with policymakers.
Some European intelligence officers say that even though Britain is an intelligence powerhouse, there are areas, such as North Africa, where other European services may have better insights.

Because Britain is a net giver rather than receiver of intelligence, particularly in MI5's counter-terrorism experience and GCHQ's extensive collection of communications and cyber activity, there was discussion in government early last year about using what some called the "security surplus" as a bargaining chip in negotiations.

'Bargaining Chip'
But the former intelligence officers caution against playing the security card. "The Brexit negotiation is not a zero-sum game," argues Sir John, who was chief of MI6 until 2014. "Security co-operation can help create an atmosphere in which the EU-27 and the UK can see that it is in everyone's interests to maintain a climate of co-operation.

"If either side try to use it as a bargaining chip or a point of leverage it's likely to be negative on both sides," he says.

Theresa May's letter to Donald Tusk, president of the European Council, setting out her stall on Britain's position surprised some within the intelligence community with its language, and the three serving British intelligence chiefs together expressed concerns, according to one official.

Mr Hannigan, who left GCHQ before the letter, also cautions against playing the security card in upcoming trade negotiations. "I've never thought this was realistic or indeed ethically sound," he told the BBC.

"I mean how could you possibly think of withholding material that might stop a terrorist attack in exchange for fish quotas or something. It's absurd."

The Data Question
But there is one issue that does worry British spies about Brexit, and that is data. The ability to move data across borders is vital, such as information on suspects moving from one country to another. This is even more of an issue for policing and border forces, but their work overlaps with the counter-terrorist work of security services who also increasingly share data on cyber threats. Any impediment to this flow would be a real issue, former and current officials say.

"It would be a very serious problem," says Sir John, adding: "The intelligence these days is based very heavily on having access to data."

Sharing and retaining data requires meeting EU safeguards on privacy. "We have been an active player in that within Europe and now European rules will be made without us and we will be outside the immediate legal framework. "But that is something that the British government is going to have to address very early on - how we continue to retain data."

ECJ 'Burden'
The EU rules have also been shaped by legal challenges at the European Court of Justice (ECJ). Mr Hannigan, who had to deal with the legal challenges as head of GCHQ, said it would not be as simple as being freed from the burden of the court.
He said it was a "bit naive" to think being free from the ECJ would "solve all our problems".

"It will solve our problems if we only wanted data to flow within the UK and never to leave its borders," he says, adding: "But that would mean cutting ourselves off from the modern world.

"That means what the EU regards as adequate regulation of privacy [and] protection of privacy is incredibly important to us and it does effectively give the ECJ a say in what we do."

The US has had to negotiate a deal with the EU and this has proved a difficult and lengthy process. But a UK deal will be vital not just for national security but the economy as a whole. "The UK equivalent - which we will now need to negotiate - will be very difficult," says Mr Hannigan. "And we will have to take some time to do it. But it's vital to the economy broadly."

BBC

You Might Also Read:

What Does Brexit Mean For British Data Privacy?:

UK Deal With EU On Post-Brexit Data Sharing:

MI5 In The Clear Over Terror Attacks:

 

« Hackers Strike Winter Olympics
Nation State Hacking Is On Trend In 2018 »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

DigitalStakeout

DigitalStakeout

DigitalStakeout enables cyber security professionals to reduce cyber risk to their organization with proactive security solutions, providing immediate improvement in security posture and ROI.

BackupVault

BackupVault

BackupVault is a leading provider of automatic cloud backup and critical data protection against ransomware, insider attacks and hackers for businesses and organisations worldwide.

Authentic8

Authentic8

Authentic8 transforms how organizations secure and control the use of the web with Silo, its patented cloud browser.

CYRIN

CYRIN

CYRIN® Cyber Range. Real Tools, Real Attacks, Real Scenarios. See why leading educational institutions and companies in the U.S. have begun to adopt the CYRIN® system.

Clayden Law

Clayden Law

Clayden Law advise global businesses that buy and sell technology products and services. We are experts in information technology, data privacy and cybersecurity law.

Gigasoft

Gigasoft

Gigasoft provide secure online data backup & cloud backup services for the education sector and businesses.

Cyber Security Academy - University of Southampton

Cyber Security Academy - University of Southampton

An industry/University partnership established to advance cyber security through world class research, teaching excellence, industrial expertise and training capacity.

JLT Specialty

JLT Specialty

JLT Specialty is a leading specialist insurance broker. Services offered include Cyber Risks insurance.

ISACA Conferences

ISACA Conferences

ISACA is dedicated to offering the most dynamic and inclusive conferences to keep you abreast of the latest advances in IT and Information Security.

Haltdos

Haltdos

Haltdos is an AI driven website protection service that secures websites against today's cyber threats.

Cyber Security Specialists

Cyber Security Specialists

Cyber Security Specialists Limited provide Security services across a wide range of markets, from multi-national Corporate Organisations and Government Agencies, through to smaller Businesses.

CultureAI

CultureAI

CultureAI deliver intelligent cyber security awareness education and tools that build resilient security cultures where employees help defend.

Eskive

Eskive

Eskive is a Brazilian cyber security awareness and education platform that empowers users and strengthens their company in the face of cyber threats.

Cingo Solutions

Cingo Solutions

Cingo Solutions is a Managed Detection & Response company providing specialized data security services.

Y-PARC

Y-PARC

Y-PARC is a center of excellence for cybersecurity, precision industries and medtech, fostering innovation and development and support for startups.

Darkbeam

Darkbeam

Darkbeam provides a unified solution to protect against security, brand and compliance risks across your digital infrastructure.

HashDit

HashDit

HashDit products and services focus on helping build a safe ecosystem for both protocol users and smart contract developers on BNB Chain.

NASK

NASK

NASK is a National Research Institute under the supervision of the Chancellery of the Prime Minister of Poland. Our key activities involve ensuring security online.

Intelequia

Intelequia

Intelequia SOC is the Security Operations Center your company needs. 24x7 monitoring, protection and automated response to cyber threats.

UltraViolet Cyber

UltraViolet Cyber

UltraViolet is an industry leading tech-enabled managed security services company.

Amiosec

Amiosec

Amiosec is a British cyber innovation business specialising in delivering simple-to-use solutions to the complex problems of the modern world.