We Need Social Media With A Heart

On average, we check our smartphones 200 times a day, for emails, alerts, tweets or text messages. That’s before using any one of our phone’s multiple applications. It is a degree of connectivity to one another, and the world beyond that is unparalleled. And it’s difficult to imagine life without it. To be so connected is to have access to instant knowledge, instant exchange, instant laughter and anger.

The darker side is where this connectivity is taking understanding and the very structure of the way we think. It’s not obvious that the good outweighs the bad. Instantaneity is the new god, instantaneity of presence, of communication and response. I know one highly paid CEO who will reply promptly to an email, although he must receive hundreds in any single hour.

On one level it is admirable – the access and responsiveness is extraordinary. But on another, it is worrying. What possible depth of thought can be associated with such fast replies? All there can be is the re-telling of stock positions and relying on gut reactions. There can’t be challenge, debate and argument because these are time-consuming; at the very least, it will distract you from answering the bombardment of emails arriving every few minutes.

Tim Berners-Lee, inventor of the world wide web in 1989, went out of his way recently, at the Sundance launch of the film ForEveryone.net, to deplore the negativity and bullying of much social media, with Twitter particularly in his sights. In a fast world without much thought, retweets in particular, he argued, have become a driver of anger. Apparently, we are 10 times likelier to retweet an item that makes us angry than one that makes us happy. Thus the character of much social media is bullying, misogynist and negativity.

Berners-Lee called for a reinvention of social media; he wanted platforms that were both open and configured better to express “constructive criticism and harmony”. The Internet should be a force for good. Martha Lane Fox, tireless campaigner for better use of the net, reinforced his cry: we need social media with heart.

In a fast world without much thought, retweets in particular have become a driver of anger

It’s hard not to agree with both of them, but equally hard to imagine what such a constructive social media network with heart would look like. Above all, it would have to be much slower.

In his bestselling book Thinking, Fast and Slow, Nobel prize-winner Daniel Kahneman argued that the human mind is configured according to two basic systems. As we emerged as thinking primates, we had to rely on fast, instinctive, emotional reflex thinking, especially to handle danger; instincts were a way of staying alive. This he calls System 1 thinking. It may often make mistakes, be irrational and rely on the subconscious, but it allows for fast decision-making, vital for survival.

System 2 thinking is slower and more deliberative. You marshal evidence, you exercise judgment, you discuss with others and you try to arrive at conclusions that will hold up. It is time-consuming, intellectual and hard. It would obviously be better if more decisions were subject to System 2 treatment, but in the hurly-burly of life it is just not possible.

We fall back on System 1, with all its inherent cognitive biases, to get through the day. We are over-optimistic, over-emotional, too readily influenced by the way a recent event has framed our thinking, too anxious to avert risk rather than seize opportunity for no other reason than this is where fast, intuitive System 1 thinking takes us. We simply have to rely on the intuitive to manage all the impulses hitting us.

With a smartphone in your hand, System 1 thinking becomes the dominant mode of thought. Nobody can handle the volume of data in 2016 without relying on ifeelings to come up with instantaneous responses, often triggered by how you see others reacting. There is less scope for deliberation and discussion – the pressure is to make a snap judgment and move on. I love this film, this article is deplorable/fantastic or politician X is a welcome breath of fresh air/duplicitous bastard.

One of the reasons there is so much misogyny on the web is that criticising a woman’s looks and style is the default mode for too many men. There is no logical link between disapproving of the opinions of a woman and of her appearance, but System 1 thinking does not care.

Tim Berners-Lee and Martha Lane Fox are right: the Internet is the greatest device for opening up the world ever devised. It is democratising and enabling. But that assumes its users draw on it to aid System 2 thinking. Plainly, there are times when we use it to inform key decisions – to find out about an illness, to research a holiday, to track a scientific breakthrough. But in the main the web is for skating and browsing. We drift round YouTube or Facebook to be diverted by the idiosyncratic or unusual; it’s compulsive because of its endless capacity to divert us into a System 1 world of trivia and intuition.

Maybe Berners-Lee’s call will be heeded and someone will come up with a heart-based social media network, in which one of the basic protocols will be time to think, but it seems improbable and its success uncertain. For the moment, we are stuck with what we have – social and wider public conversations that are more emotional and more angry than we are in reality.

Both main political parties have been pulled away from the political centre in part by the volume of social media-based anger that fuels an extreme position. Corbynistas on the left and Eurosceptics on the right quickly find a social media resonance: fulminating about the useless, anti-democratic EU or the inadequacies of Tony Blair and his wars doesn’t require much thought and triggers an intuitive response. But at the same time, there is an understanding that the fast and emotional is not necessarily the right basis for good governance; for that, System 2 thinking is necessary.

UK PM Cameron has built his success on riding on the emotions of social media while presenting himself, whatever his faults, as the serious System 2 thinker that we know is needed. It’s a political – and communications – lesson worth pondering. Social media is changing the rules. Paradoxically, it is teaching us that we need more time to think – and space in which to be serious.

Guardian: http://bit.ly/1L6TwEI

« Snowden Leaks Spill Over Into The Courts
Hacker Passes Through FBI Cyber Security With Just One Call »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

Alvacomm

Alvacomm

Alvacomm offers holistic VIP cybersecurity services, providing comprehensive protection against cyber threats. Our solutions include risk assessment, threat detection, incident response.

BackupVault

BackupVault

BackupVault is a leading provider of automatic cloud backup and critical data protection against ransomware, insider attacks and hackers for businesses and organisations worldwide.

XYPRO Technology

XYPRO Technology

XYPRO is the market leader in HPE Non-Stop Security, Risk Management and Compliance.

The PC Support Group

The PC Support Group

A partnership with The PC Support Group delivers improved productivity, reduced costs and protects your business through exceptional IT, telecoms and cybersecurity services.

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

Xcitium

Xcitium

Xcitium (formerly Comodo) is and industry leading provider of state-of-the-art endpoint protection solutions. Our Zero threat platform isolates and removes all ransomware & malware infectictions.

PrimaTech

PrimaTech

PrimaTech provide process safety, cyber and process security, and risk management consulting, training and software for the process industries.

Nohau

Nohau

Nohau provide services for safe and secure embedded software development.

OneSpan

OneSpan

OneSpan (formerly Vasco Data Security) is a global leader in digital identity security, transaction security and business productivity.

Clayden Law

Clayden Law

Clayden Law advise global businesses that buy and sell technology products and services. We are experts in information technology, data privacy and cybersecurity law.

totemo

totemo

Totemo offers solutions for the secure exchange of business information.

Kingsley Napley

Kingsley Napley

Cyber crime is an area of growing legal complexity. Our team of cyber crime lawyers have vast experience of the law in this area.

Noventiq

Noventiq

Noventiq (the brandname of Softline Holding plc) is a leading global solutions and services provider in digital transformation and cybersecurity.

Predatech

Predatech

A cyber security consultancy offering a range of services, including CREST accredited penetration testing, vulnerability assessments and certifications incl. Cyber Essentials & Cyber Essentials Plus.

Trianz

Trianz

Trianz Cybersecurity Services are Powered by One of the World’s Largest Databases on Digital Transformation. We Understand Evolving Risks, Technologies and Best Practices.

SpiderOak

SpiderOak

SpiderOak's portfolio of Secure Communication & Collaboration products ensure the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of your most sensitive data in any environment.

BigBear.ai

BigBear.ai

BigBear.ai delivers high-end analytics capabilities across the data and digital spectrum to deliver information superiority and decision support.

FTCYBER

FTCYBER

FTCYBER offers the latest technology and data recovery services to identify and extract data from computers and other digital devices.

Legit Security

Legit Security

Legit Security's mission is to secure every organization's software factory by protecting the pipelines, infrastructure, code and people for faster and more secure software releases.

GeoComply

GeoComply

GeoComply provides fraud prevention and cybersecurity solutions that detect location fraud and help verify a user's true digital identity.

Spirit Technology Solutions

Spirit Technology Solutions

Spirit Technology Solutions is a modern workplace services provider committed to delivering solutions that embody our core principles of security, sustainability, and scalability.