US Changes Policy On International Cyber Regime

The US delegate now says a UN cybersecurity group should pause hashing out new rules for online behavior and instead try to get governments to adhere to the ones we have.

A United Nations cybersecurity experts group meeting recently in Geneva should focus on encouraging UN member states to adopt existing cyber rules of the road and confidence-building measures rather than developing new ones, the US delegate said.

That’s a significant shift from a 2015 series of Group of Governmental Experts, or GGE, meeting, during which the US pushed vigorously for a set of peacetime cyber norms, including that nations should not attack each other’s critical infrastructure such as energy plants and electrical grids.

During a round of GGE meetings in 2013, the experts group concluded the international laws that govern armed conflict should apply in cyber-space just as they do on land or at sea.

“We don’t need a continual norms machine ramping out a lot of norms,” State Department Deputy Coordinator for Cyber Issues Michele Markoff told an audience at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

“What we need to do is consolidate what we’ve done and get states to implement,” she said, “both in the internalisation of the norms but also in the operationalization of [confidence-building measures] which will help the norms.”

Confidence-building measures include nations sharing information about transnational cyber threats and about national cyber-security strategies.

The experts group, which is composed of diplomats from 25 nations including Russia and China, has functioned something like an advisory committee on international cyber-security. Principles endorsed by the group remain voluntary and nonbinding for UN member states but generally form a line of accepted behavior that nations don’t want to be seen openly crossing.

Other peacetime cyber “norms” endorsed by the 2015 experts’ group include commitments that nations should not attack each other’s cyber emergency responders and should assist other nations in investigating cyber-attacks launched from their territory.

The US has often faced resistance in the expert’s group from Russian and Chinese delegates who are concerned the US wants to leverage cyber norms to ensure its own hegemony in cyber-space.

Markoff expressed optimism that the US and Russia can cooperate on some international cyber priorities despite tension created by non-cyber conflicts such as the Russian occupation of Crimea.

That work may be aided by the Trump administration’s efforts to repair relations with its former Cold War adversary, she said.

“Despite the decline in US-Russian relations over the last several years, US-Russia cyber relations have been, in fact, a bright spot. I say that with all sincerity,” she said, listing several international forums in which the nations have reached agreement on cyber issues. “As a long-time arms controller … I find that talking to [Russian officials] is much better than not talking to them.”

Markoff added while the U.S. and Russia can be “fellow travelers on a road which is designed to prevent conflict from escalating into open warfare,” the two will often have different broader goals.

Markoff did not address the Russian government-backed hacking of Democratic political organisations during the 2016 election, which US intelligence officials say was designed to aid the electoral chances of President Donald Trump.  

That influence operation did not specifically violate any of the cyber norms endorsed by the 2015 GGE because the US government did not, at that point, consider electoral systems critical infrastructure.

However, the Obama administration repeatedly described the Russian electoral meddling as outside larger bounds of appropriate state behavior and President Barack Obama termed the meddling an “unusual and extraordinary threat to the national security, foreign policy, and economy of the United States” when imposing additional sanctions on Russia.

The US Homeland Security Department added electoral systems to its list of critical infrastructure categories during the final weeks of the Obama administration, despite protests from some state-level officials. The Trump administration has done nothing so far to reverse that decision.

A Russia-linked attack on Ukraine’s power grid last year also did not violate the GGE norm prohibiting critical infrastructure attacks, Markoff said, because the norms apply only in peacetime and the US considers Russia and Ukraine to be in a state of open conflict.

“You can say Russia violated a whole lot of other things, I mean, killing people, but they are not violating this norm,” Markoff said.

DefenseOne

No US Cyber Peace Agreement with China:        Cyber War and Peace:

 

« Teaching Kids Cyber Skills
Tech Companies Oppose Trump’s Travel Ban »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

BackupVault

BackupVault

BackupVault is a leading provider of automatic cloud backup and critical data protection against ransomware, insider attacks and hackers for businesses and organisations worldwide.

LockLizard

LockLizard

Locklizard provides PDF DRM software that protects PDF documents from unauthorized access and misuse. Share and sell documents securely - prevent document leakage, sharing and piracy.

CSI Consulting Services

CSI Consulting Services

Get Advice From The Experts: * Training * Penetration Testing * Data Governance * GDPR Compliance. Connecting you to the best in the business.

Authentic8

Authentic8

Authentic8 transforms how organizations secure and control the use of the web with Silo, its patented cloud browser.

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

Brookings Institution

Brookings Institution

The Brookings Institution is a nonprofit public policy organization. Cyber security is covered within the various study areas.

Watchcom Security Group

Watchcom Security Group

Watchcom is one of Norway's foremost suppliers of information security consultancy services.

Graphus

Graphus

Graphus provides a simple, powerful, automated solution that eliminates 99% of social engineering and spear phishing attacks against G Suite business Gmail users.

Cyber Affairs

Cyber Affairs

Cyber Affairs is the first Italian press agency entirely dedicated to cyber security.

Sectigo

Sectigo

Sectigo is a leading cybersecurity provider of digital identity solutions, including TLS / SSL certificates, DevOps, IoT, and enterprise-grade PKI management, as well as multi-layered web security.

IoTsploit

IoTsploit

IoTsploit provides 20/20 visibility of network connections, protecting critical infrastructure assets from IoT vulnerabilities.

aDolus Technology

aDolus Technology

aDolus delivers a robust solution for safeguarding against counterfeit or malicious software and firmware in mission-critical systems.

Critical Start

Critical Start

Critical Start provides Managed Detection and Response services, endpoint security, threat intelligence, penetration testing, risk assessments, and incident response.

Britive

Britive

The Britive Platform is a cloud-native security solution built for the most demanding cloud-forward enterprises.

LibraSoft

LibraSoft

Librasoft creates solutions to protect information from external and internal threats.

Commonwealth Cyber Initiative (CCI)

Commonwealth Cyber Initiative (CCI)

The Commonwealth Cyber Initiative is establishing Virginia as a global center of excellence at the intersection of security, autonomous systems, and data.

Opus Security

Opus Security

Opus dramatically reduces cloud security risks by enabling teams to define, orchestrate, automate and measure remediation processes across the entire distributed organization.

Guardz

Guardz

Guardz helps small and growing businesses to go from zero or low cyber protection to having comprehensive security – in the quickest and most straightforward way.

CyberMaxx

CyberMaxx

At CyberMaxx, our approach to cybersecurity provides end-to-end coverage for our customers – we use offense to fuel defense.

SecureDNE

SecureDNE

SecureDNE are a leading provider of cutting-edge Fractional CISO, Managed Cybersecurity Services, and Cybersecurity Engineering Solutions.

SECTA5

SECTA5

SECTA5 is a cybersecurity company building a next-generation Continuous Threat and Exposure Management platform, leveraging the expertise of offensively trained cyber defenders.