UK Schools & Teaching Computer Science

A revolution is under way in the teaching of computer science in schools in England, but it risks leaving girls and pupils from poorer backgrounds and ethnic minorities behind.

That's the conclusion of academics who've studied data about the move from ICT as a national curriculum subject to computer science.

Four years ago, amid general disquiet that ICT was teaching children little more than how Microsoft Office worked, the government took the subject off the national curriculum. The idea was that instead schools should move to offering more rigorous courses in computer science - children would learn to code rather than how to do PowerPoint.

But academics at Roehampton University, who compile an annual study of computing education, have some worrying news. First, just 28% of schools entered pupils for the GCSE in computing in 2015. At A-level, only 24% entered pupils for the qualification.

Then there's the evidence that girls just aren't being persuaded to take an interest, 16% of GCSE computing entrants in 2015 were female and the figure for the A-level was just 8.5%. The qualification is relatively new and more schools - and more girls, took it in 2016 - but female participation was still only 20% for the GCSE and 10% for the A-level.

It looks as though the few that did take the exams were very focused - girls got higher grades than boys in both the GCSE and the A-level.

Unsurprising

Carrie-Ann Philbin, a former computing teacher who works to engage children in coding at the , describes these figures as "disappointing but not surprising". She points out that we are at an early stage in developing computing education and things should improve.

But she also thinks that the way computing is often sold as if its only purpose is to turn out a generation of programmers is a problem. "This only alienates teenage girls who already have a negative idea of what it is to be a 'computer geek'."

It also appears that poorer children and those from ethnic minorities are less likely to be getting the computing education the government says is vital if the UK is to have the skills it needs to compete in the digital era.

Pupils on free school meals made up just 19% of GCSE entrants, when they are 27% of the population, and just 3.6% of students were black when they make up 4.7% of that age group.

But wasn't the picture roughly similar for the old discredited ICT course? Well, no. While it is gradually being phased out, more pupils are still taking the ICT GCSE than computing, and the entrants are far more representative of the wider population. Forty-one per cent of GCSE entrants were female, and the exam had higher numbers of entries from children from low income and ethnic minority backgrounds.

Split Emerging

"Computing and ICT had really quite different groups of students taking them," says Miles Berry from Roehampton. "ICT was much closer to the average in terms of gender, low income, ethnicity and prior attainment in math’s."

His colleague Peter Kemp says diversity in the kind of children getting computing education is important. "We need to make sure that computer science becomes a subject at least as inclusive as the old ICT qualification. If the current disparities in access go unaddressed we risk wasting the opportunity to transform the tech industry into a more equal profession."

They both worry that schools are looking at this new subject with some skepticism and deciding that there are other priorities when budgets are tight. In schools that are offering the new A-level in computing, class sizes tend to be small, raising the prospect, says the Roehampton report, that their economic viability will be questioned under new sixth form funding arrangements.

And while many teachers supported the move towards a more rigorous form of computing education, some who warned about the danger of throwing out the baby with the bathwater now feel vindicated.

Difficult

Drew Buddie, an ICT teacher who also acts as an examiner for the computer science GCSE, says the new exam is just too hard for many children, and is proving very stressful for teachers too. The result, he fears, is that "whole cohorts of students are now completely switched off doing ANY computer-related GCSE." He says the content of the new course is so different that many ICT teachers just do not have the knowledge to teach it, and he fears that computer science could become a niche subject, taught in only a few schools.

The Department for Education (DfE) is looking on the bright side. "The number of girls studying computer science has nearly doubled since last year and we want to see more follow their example," a spokesperson said.

The DfE went on to say that "mastering Stem skills would ensure our future workforce has the skills to drive the future productivity and economy of this country".

What it doesn't say is that computer science can be creative and fun. Perhaps those words need to be inserted into the curriculum, otherwise many pupils and teachers may decide that computing is just too hard to bother with.

BBC:                 UK National Cyber Security College Locates To Bletchley Park:

« Yahoo’s Latest Billion Breach!
Germany Wants To Order Social Media To Police Hate Speech »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

Alvacomm

Alvacomm

Alvacomm offers holistic VIP cybersecurity services, providing comprehensive protection against cyber threats. Our solutions include risk assessment, threat detection, incident response.

FT Cyber Resilience Summit: Europe

FT Cyber Resilience Summit: Europe

27 November 2024 | In-Person & Digital | 22 Bishopsgate, London. Business leaders, Innovators & Experts address evolving cybersecurity risks.

Perimeter 81 / How to Select the Right ZTNA Solution

Perimeter 81 / How to Select the Right ZTNA Solution

Gartner insights into How to Select the Right ZTNA offering. Download this FREE report for a limited time only.

Jooble

Jooble

Jooble is a job search aggregator operating in 71 countries worldwide. We simplify the job search process by displaying active job ads from major job boards and career sites across the internet.

CSI Consulting Services

CSI Consulting Services

Get Advice From The Experts: * Training * Penetration Testing * Data Governance * GDPR Compliance. Connecting you to the best in the business.

Redcentric

Redcentric

Redcentric is a leading UK IT managed services provider. We deliver managed IT, cloud computing, data backup, information security services and managed networks.

AML Solutions

AML Solutions

AML Solutions offer a full range of Anti-Money Laundering and Countering the Financing of Terrorism (AML/CFT) services.

Tukan IT

Tukan IT

Tukan IT provides a data classification and protection solution.

HudsonCyber

HudsonCyber

HudsonCyber, part of HudsonAnalytix, provides leading cyber risk management services for the global maritime transportation industry.

Arm

Arm

Arm delivers a complete IoT solution, from providing the IP for the chip to delivering the cloud services to securely manage the deployment of products throughout their lifecycle.

Key Cyber Solutions

Key Cyber Solutions

Key Cyber is an IT consulting firm that specializes in agile software development services, program management and infrastructure services, cyber security and cloud and managed services.

HardSecure

HardSecure

Hardsecure supports organizations to face security threats through the adoption of cybersecurity capabilities that guarantee 360º monitoring, visibility, mitigation, and blocking.

CloudSEK

CloudSEK

CloudSEK has set its sights on building the world’s fastest and most reliable AI technology, that identifies and resolves digital threats.

Veridium

Veridium

Veridium is a leader in single step - multi factor biometric authentication, designed to safeguard enterprises’ most critical assets.

ClubCISO

ClubCISO

ClubCISO is a community of peers, working together to help shape the future of the information security profession by facilitating independent discussion on data security and cyber resilience.

GoTo

GoTo

At GoTo we help people and businesses to connect and collaborate simply and securely – from anywhere. We’re the trusted partner for companies of all sizes.

Silent Push

Silent Push

Silent Push maps all internet-facing infrastructure with searchable, advanced attributes, generating early indicators of potential threats that are tailored to your environment.

ABM Technology Group

ABM Technology Group

ABM Technology Group (formerly True IT) provide business information technology services, solutions, and consulting for small to mid-sized organizations.

Axians

Axians

Axians supports its customers in their digital transformation journey. We offer ICT solutions and services in areas including Enterprise Networks and Cybersecurity.

MyTurn Career LLC

MyTurn Career LLC

Looking for a rewarding career in cybersecurity? Explore a wide range of cybersecurity jobs and opportunities in this rapidly evolving field.

ETI-NET

ETI-NET

ETI-NET is the worldwide leader in managing critical data for industries that never stop.