UK Investigatory Powers Bill Will Cost £1bn To Implement

The British Home Office has been told its plans in the snooper’s charter to retain web-browsing history of all British citizens for 12 months would cost in excess of £1bn.

The £1bn estimate for the cost of requiring phone and Internet companies to retain everyone’s Internet connection records and store them for 12 months is based on a similar scheme in Denmark, which was recently dropped on grounds of cost.

The Don’t Spy on Us coalition, which includes the Open Rights Group and Privacy International, says that the £1bn price tag for the new powers for the police and security services to access everyone’s web browsing history compares with the initial official Home Office estimate of only £174m over 10 years.

The British Internet industry has already made clear that it regards the £174m figure as an underestimate. The president of BT Security has told MPs that the allocated amount would only cover BT’s costs, and Virgin Media has said its costs will be “in the tens of millions”. The Home Office is reconsidering its initial cost estimate.

The Danish government recently shelved similar proposals to monitor the web browsing habits of Danish citizens after accountancy giant Ernst & Young, confirmed it would cost 1bn Danish kroner (£105m) to implement. This estimate only covered the equipment investment and did not include annual operating costs.

Don’t Spy on Us says that as Britain’s population, at 64 million, is more than 11 times that of Denmark’s 5.6 million, the cost of a similar internet record system in Britain would be more than £1bn. It estimates that this bill, which is to be paid in full by the Home Office, is equivalent to the cost of employing 3,000 more full-time police officers.

Eric King, director of Don’t Spy on Us, speaking to the Guardian newspaper said: “The government is trying to force internet service providers to collect all of our internet connection records, but refuses to listen when they express concerns about the cost and feasibility of their proposals. As in Denmark, the government should commission an independent cost analysis to clarify the true cost of collecting Internet connection records.”

The demand for an independent cost assessment has also been backed by the Liberal Democrats. The party’s home affairs spokesman, Alistair Carmichael, said: “Splurging £1.2bn on hoovering up everyone’s data all of the time sounds like a huge waste of money – and might not even work. It would be far better to divert these resources to following up on leads and ensuring there are enough police on our streets.”  

The Home Office has indicated it is re-assessing the cost implications of retaining internet connection records, which is an important proposal in its investigatory powers bill, known as the snooper’s charter.

A Home Office spokesperson said: “There are a number of fundamental differences between our bill and the Danish model, and the independent joint committee of parliament acknowledged this. It is absolutely incorrect to suggest we are implementing the Danish model.

“We have worked closely with communications service providers (CSPs) to carefully estimate the cost of implementing a system to retain internet connection records. And we will continue to work with CSPs to refine that cost as the bill progresses,” they said.

“We are determined to implement the legislation in a way that will deliver the maximum operational benefit for the police and law enforcement agencies. Our proposals provide a comprehensive and comprehensible framework for investigatory powers, with robust safeguards and world-leading oversight.”

GovUK      Guardian:         ITPro

 

« The Next Decade Will Be About The Industrial Internet
Donald Trump Has A Plan for CyberWar »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

Resecurity, Inc.

Resecurity, Inc.

Resecurity is a cybersecurity company that delivers a unified platform for endpoint protection, risk management, and cyber threat intelligence.

Syxsense

Syxsense

Syxsense brings together endpoint management and security for greater efficiency and collaboration between IT management and security teams.

ON-DEMAND WEBINAR: What Is A Next-Generation Firewall (and why does it matter)?

ON-DEMAND WEBINAR: What Is A Next-Generation Firewall (and why does it matter)?

Watch this webinar to hear security experts from Amazon Web Services (AWS) and SANS break down the myths and realities of what an NGFW is, how to use one, and what it can do for your security posture.

BackupVault

BackupVault

BackupVault is a leading provider of automatic cloud backup and critical data protection against ransomware, insider attacks and hackers for businesses and organisations worldwide.

CSI Consulting Services

CSI Consulting Services

Get Advice From The Experts: * Training * Penetration Testing * Data Governance * GDPR Compliance. Connecting you to the best in the business.

Executive Women's Forum (EWF)

Executive Women's Forum (EWF)

The Executive Women's Forum is the largest member organization serving emerging leaders and influential female executives in the Information Security, Risk Management and Privacy industries.

Cortado Mobile Solutions

Cortado Mobile Solutions

Cortado Mobile Solutions creates enterprise mobility and file sharing solutions for companies, teams and freelancers.

Carbonite

Carbonite

Carbonite offers all the tools necessary for protecting data from the most common forms of data loss, including ransomware, accidental deletions, hardware failures and natural disasters.

US Secret Service

US Secret Service

The US Secret Service has a pivotal role in securing the nation’s critical infrastructures, specifically in the areas of cyber, banking and finance.

Blockchain R&D Hub

Blockchain R&D Hub

Blockchain R&D Hub's mission is to serve the needs of blockchain ecosystem as the center of excellence for technology research and development.

GV

GV

GV provides venture capital funding to bold new companies in the fields of life science, healthcare, artificial intelligence, robotics, transportation, cyber security and agriculture.

Bessemer Venture Partners (BVP)

Bessemer Venture Partners (BVP)

Bessemer Venture Partners was born from innovations that literally forged modern building and manufacturing. Today, our team of investors works with people who want to create revolutions of their own.

BrandProtections.Online

BrandProtections.Online

BrandProtections.online offer end-to-end customer support solutions to help protect against threats which may affect your brand online.

Cyemptive Technologies

Cyemptive Technologies

Cyemptive's CyberSlice technology preempts and remove threats before they take hold, in seconds, compared to other’s hours, days, weeks and even months.

International Cybersecurity Forum (FIC)

International Cybersecurity Forum (FIC)

The International Cybersecurity Forum (FIC) has established itself as the benchmark event in Europe in terms of digital security and trust.

ThreatReady Resources

ThreatReady Resources

ThreatReady reduces an organization’s risk by delivering cyber security awareness training based on the latest, state-of-the-art learning science to effectively drive long-term cyber-safe behavior.

QuSecure

QuSecure

QuSecure provides a software-driven security architecture that overlays your current infrastructure and provides next-generation security to protect your entire network from quantum threats.

Framatome

Framatome

Framatome Cybersecurity portfolio is directly inspired by its unique experience in nuclear safety for critical information systems and electrical systems design.

TIM Enterprise

TIM Enterprise

TIM Enterprise offers innovative, sustainable and secure 360-degree digital solutions to companies and public administrations.

IS4IT Kritis

IS4IT Kritis

IS4IT is your partner for the successful planning, introduction and implementation of company-specific information security concepts.

Emantra

Emantra

Emantra specialises in the enablement of Secure Cloud services through it’s comprehensive Sovereign Cloud Hosting, Secure Access Service Edge, and managed services.