UK Investigatory Powers Bill Will Cost £1bn To Implement

The British Home Office has been told its plans in the snooper’s charter to retain web-browsing history of all British citizens for 12 months would cost in excess of £1bn.

The £1bn estimate for the cost of requiring phone and Internet companies to retain everyone’s Internet connection records and store them for 12 months is based on a similar scheme in Denmark, which was recently dropped on grounds of cost.

The Don’t Spy on Us coalition, which includes the Open Rights Group and Privacy International, says that the £1bn price tag for the new powers for the police and security services to access everyone’s web browsing history compares with the initial official Home Office estimate of only £174m over 10 years.

The British Internet industry has already made clear that it regards the £174m figure as an underestimate. The president of BT Security has told MPs that the allocated amount would only cover BT’s costs, and Virgin Media has said its costs will be “in the tens of millions”. The Home Office is reconsidering its initial cost estimate.

The Danish government recently shelved similar proposals to monitor the web browsing habits of Danish citizens after accountancy giant Ernst & Young, confirmed it would cost 1bn Danish kroner (£105m) to implement. This estimate only covered the equipment investment and did not include annual operating costs.

Don’t Spy on Us says that as Britain’s population, at 64 million, is more than 11 times that of Denmark’s 5.6 million, the cost of a similar internet record system in Britain would be more than £1bn. It estimates that this bill, which is to be paid in full by the Home Office, is equivalent to the cost of employing 3,000 more full-time police officers.

Eric King, director of Don’t Spy on Us, speaking to the Guardian newspaper said: “The government is trying to force internet service providers to collect all of our internet connection records, but refuses to listen when they express concerns about the cost and feasibility of their proposals. As in Denmark, the government should commission an independent cost analysis to clarify the true cost of collecting Internet connection records.”

The demand for an independent cost assessment has also been backed by the Liberal Democrats. The party’s home affairs spokesman, Alistair Carmichael, said: “Splurging £1.2bn on hoovering up everyone’s data all of the time sounds like a huge waste of money – and might not even work. It would be far better to divert these resources to following up on leads and ensuring there are enough police on our streets.”  

The Home Office has indicated it is re-assessing the cost implications of retaining internet connection records, which is an important proposal in its investigatory powers bill, known as the snooper’s charter.

A Home Office spokesperson said: “There are a number of fundamental differences between our bill and the Danish model, and the independent joint committee of parliament acknowledged this. It is absolutely incorrect to suggest we are implementing the Danish model.

“We have worked closely with communications service providers (CSPs) to carefully estimate the cost of implementing a system to retain internet connection records. And we will continue to work with CSPs to refine that cost as the bill progresses,” they said.

“We are determined to implement the legislation in a way that will deliver the maximum operational benefit for the police and law enforcement agencies. Our proposals provide a comprehensive and comprehensible framework for investigatory powers, with robust safeguards and world-leading oversight.”

GovUK      Guardian:         ITPro

 

« The Next Decade Will Be About The Industrial Internet
Donald Trump Has A Plan for CyberWar »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

BackupVault

BackupVault

BackupVault is a leading provider of automatic cloud backup and critical data protection against ransomware, insider attacks and hackers for businesses and organisations worldwide.

DigitalStakeout

DigitalStakeout

DigitalStakeout enables cyber security professionals to reduce cyber risk to their organization with proactive security solutions, providing immediate improvement in security posture and ROI.

Authentic8

Authentic8

Authentic8 transforms how organizations secure and control the use of the web with Silo, its patented cloud browser.

Practice Labs

Practice Labs

Practice Labs is an IT competency hub, where live-lab environments give access to real equipment for hands-on practice of essential cybersecurity skills.

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

Cyber 360

Cyber 360

Cyber 360 is a Cybersecurity contract and fulltime placement firm dedicated to identifying and hiring Cybersecurity professionals.

NXP Semiconductors

NXP Semiconductors

NXP is a world leader in secure connectivity solutions for embedded applications and the Internet of Things.

Northwave

Northwave

Northwave offers an Intelligent combination of cyber security services to protect your information.

Anglo African

Anglo African

Anglo African is an information technology firm providing end-to-end solutions to different industries, from IT Infrastructure to DataCom as well as Cloud & InfoSec services.

Risk Ident

Risk Ident

RISK IDENT specializes in supporting enterprises in identifying and preventing criminal activity like payment fraud, account takeovers and identity theft.

Penacity

Penacity

Penacity, LLC provides strategic consulting technology services and Information Security Services to commercial and government organizations.

Quantea

Quantea

Our multi-patented solutions - QP Series Network Analytics Accelerator appliance and PureInsight Analytics Software Suite allows you to capture, analyze, store, replay, network traffic data.

GuardRails

GuardRails

GuardRails provides continuous security feedback that empowers developers to find, fix, and prevent vulnerabilities.

Cyentia Institute

Cyentia Institute

The Cyentia Institute is a research & data science firm with a mission to advance knowledge in the cybersecurity industry.

Ukrainian Academy of Cyber Security (UACS)

Ukrainian Academy of Cyber Security (UACS)

UACS is a professional non-profit public organization established to promote the development of an extensive network and ecosystem of education and training in the field of cyber security.

Pivot Technology School

Pivot Technology School

Pivot Tech offers Data Analytics, Software Development and Cyber Security training in boot camp style cohorts.

PhishFirewall

PhishFirewall

PhishFirewall is an advanced AI-driven CyberSecurity Awareness Education, Threat Emulation, and Human Security Analytics Platform.

Vaultree

Vaultree

We believe in an encrypted tomorrow. Vaultree technology enables a foundational change in how we communicate with each other: Safely!

Clearvision

Clearvision

As an Atlassian Platinum Solution Partner, Clearvision works with teams in the UK and US, providing solutions for the Atlassian stack, Git and open source tooling.

Siren

Siren

Siren provides the leading Investigative Intelligence Platform to some of the world’s leading Law Enforcement, National Security and Cyber threat investigators.

Mondoo

Mondoo

Mondoo is a powerful security, compliance, and asset inventory tool that helps businesses identify vulnerabilities, track lost assets, and ensure policy compliance across their entire infrastructure.