Twitter, Free Speech & Disinformation

Elon Musk's deal to buy Twitter comes with a promise to reduce censorship on the platform, raising questions about what his approach will mean for the "digital town square".

In response, various human rights groups have been quick to express concerns that a lack of moderation could lead to a rise in hate speech. Many Twitter users are also asking whether this means accounts suspended by the company - like that of ex-President Donald Trump - will be allowed back.

Indeed, it might turn out that Twitter's change of ownership means that  the social media platform will do even less to moderate extremism, fake news and disinformation. 

Twitter is unique. Its short 280 character limit on text and threading  promotes real-time conversations among thousands of people, which make it popular with celebrities, media personalities and politicians alike. Twitter’s ability to shape real-time discourse, as well as the ease with which data, including geotagged data which can be extracted has made it a powerful tool for researchers to analyse a variety of societal phenomena, ranging from public health to politics. 

“Free speech is the bedrock of a functioning democracy, and Twitter is the digital town square where matters vital to the future of humanity are debated,” Musk said in the same Twitter statement announcing the deal. "I also want to make Twitter better than ever by enhancing the product with new features, making the algorithms open source to increase trust, defeating the spam bots, and authenticating all humans. Twitter has tremendous potential, I look forward to working with the company and the community of users to unlock it," he added.

There has been speculation over who and what will be allowed back on Twitter, including whether former US president Donald Trump will return to the platform. Australian lobby group Digital Rights Watch has expressed concern that while Musk claims the takeover is about free speech, it’s actually about power.

This deal has started a debate in the US about freedom of speech and the role of social media platforms in regulating the flow of information.

“Mr. Musk: free speech is wonderful, hate speech is unacceptable. Disinformation, misinformation and hate speech have NO PLACE on Twitter,” the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), a US civil rights advocacy group, said in a statement. The group warned against permitting Trump back on the platform or allowing Twitter to become a “petri dish” for falsehoods. “Protecting our democracy is of utmost importance, especially as the midterm elections approach. Mr Musk: lives are at risk, and so is American democracy,” it added.

Emerson T. Brooking, a resident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council’s Digital Forensics Lab said “Musk has made no secret of his distaste for Twitter's efforts to curb misinformation and harmful content. Now that he has full control, I expect that many of these policies will be reversed. Many malicious actors are about to be given a new lease on life.” Brooking said Musk seems not to have given much thought to the challenge of foreign interference or “the complexities of terrorist and wartime content moderation. "When he finds himself responsible for such decisions, he will be in for a rude awakening,” he said.

The Electronic Frontier Foundation, a digital rights advocacy group, said in a statement, “Elon Musk’s purchase of Twitter highlights the risks to human rights and personal safety when any single person has complete control over policies affecting almost 400 million users. “And in this case that person has repeatedly demonstrated that they do not understand the realities of platform policy at scale.” 

However, Musk might could also move to limit disinformation on Twitter. One idea is that of verifying the identities of all users, rather than just a few. Musk has also indicated his intention to combat twitter bots, or automated accounts that post rapidly and repeatedly in the guise of people.

There is also some reason to think that Musk’s takeover might actually help more users fight autocratic regimes. Musk recently donated dozens of Starlink terminals to Ukrainians to allow them to continue to post and access the Internet even as Russia attacked communications infrastructure. 

One of the consequences of the Musk's purchase is that it gives him access to the non-public and non-encrypted direct messages between users. This has beeen a controversial issue for Mark Zukerberg's Meta group, where Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram now share their different users' information.

Since being banned from Twitter, extremists have moved other to social media platforms like Telegram where there is less content moderation but also fewer followers. The prospect of regaining access to a mainstream platform that gives them considerably more reach has been welcomed. “I would rather be active on Twitter and dead irl than be banned from Twitter and alive,” white supremacist Nick Fuentes, who was banned from Twitter last year.

To understand Musk’s motivations and what lies next for social media platforms such as Twitter, it’s important to consider the giant and largely invisible online online advertising business involving multiple technologies wielded by ad networks, social media companies and publishers. Advertising is currently by far the the primary revenue source for Twitter. In contrast, Musk’s vision is to generate revenue for Twitter from subscriptions rather than advertising. Without having to worry about attracting and retaining advertisers, Twitter would have less pressure to focus on content moderation. 

Twitter’s own algorithmic bias bounty challenge concluded that there needs to be a community-led approach to building better algorithms. A new approach to the algorithms used to deliver content to users might produce very different results. A creative exercise developed by the MIT Media Lab asks middle schoolers to re-imagine the YouTube platform with ethics in mind.

There is a possibility that Musk to do this with Twitter, although his proposal to make the algorithms used open source and freely available would have an unintended consequence of making the platform much more vulnerable to malicious actors.

Regulators around the world are lining up to enforce rules on social networks and make them to take more responsibility for the content they carry, issuing steep fines for non-compliance on material that incites violence, or is abusive, or classifies as hate speech, among other things. 

It  is far too early to draw conclusions about Twitter's new direction or to predict how Twitter users will collectively respond. One thing is certain - it will produce a very active debate. For  every tweet welcoming Musk's ownership, there is another condemning it. 

DefenseOne:      BBC:   BBC:     AlJazeera:       USAToday:       Guardian:     The Conversation:   

Forbes:    Channel News Asia:      LA Times:   NAACP:    Like War

You Might Also Read: 

The Limits Of Social Media Soft Power:         Facebook Is 'making hate worse':

 

« Digital Experience Monitoring - The Future Of Remote & Hybrid Work
Cyber Security Training Reduces Cyber Attacks »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

Jooble

Jooble

Jooble is a job search aggregator operating in 71 countries worldwide. We simplify the job search process by displaying active job ads from major job boards and career sites across the internet.

Practice Labs

Practice Labs

Practice Labs is an IT competency hub, where live-lab environments give access to real equipment for hands-on practice of essential cybersecurity skills.

Directory of Cyber Security Suppliers

Directory of Cyber Security Suppliers

Our Supplier Directory lists 7,000+ specialist cyber security service providers in 128 countries worldwide. IS YOUR ORGANISATION LISTED?

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

Secusmart

Secusmart

Secusmart provide highly secure and encrypted speech and data communication solutions.

Aeriandi

Aeriandi

Aeriandi is a leading provider of hosted PCI security compliance solutions for call centres, trusted by high street banks and major Telcos.

DNV

DNV

DNV are the independent expert in assurance and risk management. We deliver world-renowned testing, certification and technical advisory services.

Sentropi

Sentropi

Sentropi is an online protection solution against charge backs, account takeovers, identity thefts and online scams.

SentryBay

SentryBay

SentryBay is the global leader in preventative endpoint isolation protection. We protect remote, BYOD and corporate endpoints so they can safely and securely connect with your corporate network.

SIGA

SIGA

SIGA provides cyber security solutions for Industrial Control Systems SCADA systems used in critical infrastructures and industrial processes.

National Cybersecurity Student Association (NCSA) - USA

National Cybersecurity Student Association (NCSA) - USA

The National Cybersecurity Student Association is a one-stop-shop to enhance the educational and professional development of cybersecurity students through activities, networking and collaboration.

Ntirety

Ntirety

Ntirety Managed Security Services offer enterprise businesses the advanced tools, processes, and support to ensure your infrastructure, networks, and mission-critical applications are secure.

eCosCentric

eCosCentric

eCosCentric provides software development solutions for the IoT, M2M & embedded systems market.

Romanian Tech Startup Association (ROTSA)

Romanian Tech Startup Association (ROTSA)

Romanian Tech Startups Association is an umbrella organization that aims to promote, support and represent the interests of tech startups in Romania.

Dimension Data

Dimension Data

Dimension Data is a leading African born technology provider operating in the Middle East and Africa, offering a portfolio of services including intelligent security solutions.

Socura

Socura

Socura helps make the digital world a safer place; changing the way organisations think about cyber security through a dynamic, innovative, and human approach.

Cyclops

Cyclops

Cyclops is the first Contextual Search Platform for cybersecurity.

Loccus AI

Loccus AI

Loccus are developers of AI solutions in the voice safety space. We build identity verification solutions, deepfake detection systems and fraud protection products for companies and end-users.

SITS Group

SITS Group

SITS Group excel in delivering a comprehensive range of Cyber Security consulting and managed services, from cloud transformation to risk management.

Ryan Financial Lines

Ryan Financial Lines

Ryan Financial Lines Cyber provides risk transfer solutions for complex cyber and technology exposures, globally.