Theft & Subsequent Re-Use of Cyber Weapons

Almost exactly one year ago, the world experienced two destructive cyber-attacks in which offensive cyber tools developed by the National Security Agency were stolen and shared with the public. 

In May 2017, the WannaCry ransom-ware hit over 300,000 computers in 150 countries. One month later, the NotPetya attack hit the computer systems of companies and governmental entities across the globe causing millions of dollars in damages. 

These attacks exploited numerous vulnerabilities, and have subsequently exposed the slow response time of targeted countries and the lack of effective information sharing mechanisms between responsible agencies, something which could have mitigated the severe damage caused by the attacks.

The interesting feature of these attacks is that those responsible, North Korea and Russia, used the leaked offensive tools originally developed by the NSA. 

The investigation into WannaCry ultimately revealed that the attackers had exploited a security vulnerability called EternalBlue, originally developed by the NSA. NotPetya used a variant of the same vulnerability, which is still wreaking havoc a year later. For example, in February 2018, security researchers at Symantec reported that an Iran-based hacking group had used EternalBlue as part of its operations.

This situation whereby technologically advanced countries are investing efforts in developing offensive cyber capabilities only to have these very tools stolen and reused raises three critical questions of urgent policy relevance.

First, are states going to start reusing each other’s leaked cyber tools as a matter of course? The ability to reuse stolen cyber tools may signal the beginning of a shift in the distribution of international cyber power, as weaker actors (including non-state actors) become increasingly able to use sophisticated malware to cause global damage and possibly target the cyber weapons’ original designers. 

Countries that are less technologically advanced and less vulnerable to cyberattacks might find the reuse of stolen vulnerabilities appealing for their own offensive activity.

Second, is it possible to prevent the leaking of cyber tools from occurring in the first place? There aren’t many reasons to be optimistic. Firstly , there’s the insider threat problem, a particularly thorny issue given the extensive use of contractors and the risk that they steal or mishandle sensitive information that they were exposed to during their service. A second and possibly more problematic reason is that it is cheaper to use stolen vulnerabilities than finding new ones. As new vulnerabilities like EternalBlue get exposed, the costs of using stolen cyber vulnerabilities and conducting attacks are being consistently lowered while benefits remain high. 

States with offensive capabilities know that putting their hands on unique vulnerabilities developed by their adversaries will enable them to more easily launch sophisticated attacks without the need pursue a lengthy and costly R&D process. 
This makes the reuse of cyber tools especially appealing and may motivate different actors to concentrate their efforts in this direction. As long as the benefits of using the stolen vulnerabilities are higher than the costs, these vulnerabilities will remain an attractive target.

A third question for policymakers is whether the theft and reuse of cyber vulnerabilities change the way states handle these vulnerabilities. States should be aware of the risk that vulnerabilities leak into the open and develop information-sharing mechanisms to address it. These information sharing mechanisms should exist between the intelligence agencies themselves and between the intelligence community and the tech industry. 

Once it has been recognised that a vulnerability, exploit or tool has been stolen, the relevant agency should immediately share the specific data with all the agencies and firms that might get affected by it, just like what the NSA is believed to have done. 
To minimise security concerns and to not expose sensitive sources and methods, there is no need to share the precise reasons for giving such warnings. Yet it is crucial to share this information in order to patch the vulnerabilities as soon as possible and lower future risks.

The US government has its own vulnerabilities equities process (VEP) policy which sets out how the US government discloses computer vulnerabilities it detects or acquires to other vendors. Countries across Europe have their own similar VEP mechanism, and an EU-wide VEP is being considered. 

But as so many countries around the globe are developing offensive cyber capabilities, and in light global damage costs of the WannaCry and NotPetya, there is an urgent need to create an international mechanism for vulnerability disclosures akin to a global VEP.

Formulating an effective response to this growing type of cyber weapon proliferation is clearly the responsibility of national governments. 

Alongside the development of these offensive capabilities, and in light of the success of recent attacks, the theft and leak of offensive cyber weapons and their subsequent use is only likely to increase, potentially creating new international tensions between governments and between them and the tech industry.

Defense One:

You Might Also Read: 

Prices For Stolen NSA Exploits Go Higher:

When Terrorists Learn How to Hack:
 

« Using AI To Reduce Business Risks
China Escalates Hacks On The US »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Check Point

Directory of Suppliers

The PC Support Group

The PC Support Group

A partnership with The PC Support Group delivers improved productivity, reduced costs and protects your business through exceptional IT, telecoms and cybersecurity services.

Authentic8

Authentic8

Authentic8 transforms how organizations secure and control the use of the web with Silo, its patented cloud browser.

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

LockLizard

LockLizard

Locklizard provides PDF DRM software that protects PDF documents from unauthorized access and misuse. Share and sell documents securely - prevent document leakage, sharing and piracy.

BackupVault

BackupVault

BackupVault is a leading provider of automatic cloud backup and critical data protection against ransomware, insider attacks and hackers for businesses and organisations worldwide.

Imperva

Imperva

Imperva is a leading provider of data and application security solutions including DDoS protection, Web application security, Data security and Cloud security.

KOBIL

KOBIL

KOBIL is a pioneer in the fields of smart card, one-time password, authentication and cryptography.

Unitrends

Unitrends

Unitrends helps IT pros do more with less by providing an all-in-one enterprise backup and continuity solution.

Indusface

Indusface

Indusface offers best website security, web application firewall and SSL certificate to keep your online business much safer.

Digital Arts

Digital Arts

Digital Arts provides internet security software and appliance products for companies and individuals.

infySEC

infySEC

InfySEC is an information security services organization offering Security Technology services, Security Consulting, Security Training, Research & Development.

AXA XL

AXA XL

AXA XL is the P&C and Specialty Risk Division of AXA. Professional insurance products include Cyber Insurance.

Mosaic 451

Mosaic 451

Mosaic451 is a bespoke IT managed services provider and consultancy specializing in information security, operations and design.

NewGens

NewGens

NewGens is a solution and service provider to banking institutions in the APAC region. Areas of expertise include cybersecurity, AML, fruad prevention, compliance and risk management.

CYBER.ORG

CYBER.ORG

CYBER.ORG's goal is to empower educators as they prepare the next generation to succeed in the cyber workforce of tomorrow.

TechForing

TechForing

TechForing Ltd. works for business organization's cyber security and cyber crime incident managements. We help business to secure their business online.

689cloud

689cloud

689Cloud is a cloud content collaboration platform that allows users to protect, track, and control files AFTER they have been shared.

Trisul Network Analytics

Trisul Network Analytics

Trisul helps organizations deploy full spectrum deep network monitoring which can serve as a single source of truth for performance monitoring, security analytics, threat detection and compliance.

Gomboc.ai

Gomboc.ai

Gomboc solve cloud infrastructure security policy deviations by providing tailored remediations to the IaC (Infrastructure as Code).

Umbrella Cyber

Umbrella Cyber

Umbrella Cyber specialises in Cyber Essentials and Cyber Essentials Plus Certification and penetration testing.

CirrusHQ

CirrusHQ

CirrusHQ are a Specialist AWS Advanced Consulting Partner with a focus on Cloud Management, DevOps, Migration and Consulting Services for the private and public sectors.