The EU’s Copyright Directive Risks Creating Two Internets

The European Parliament’s approval of the Copyright Directive is the end of the internet as we know it. This new regulation creates substantial new controls on what we can share online which threaten freedom of expression, undermine creativity, and cement the dominance of technology giants.

The Copyright Directive will create two internets. The first, a heavily censored version for European users, including filters to prevent you from uploading content. The second, a free internet where creativity is encouraged, for everyone else.  By Matthew Lesh

The directive represents everything that’s wrong with the EU’s policymaking process. It was written at a substantial distance from Europeans, heavily influenced by lobbyists and national compromises. There is a serious lack of accountability.
The opposition to the directive was substantial, but it didn’t seem to matter. Over 200 intellectual property academics have warned that the directive serves “narrow sectional interests”. Even substantial parts of the European music industry have raised concerns about the scheme. The Change.org petition opposing the directive has reached over 5.1 million signatories, the most in the website’s history. 

Recently, while some Brits were marching to stay in the EU, thousands of Europeans took to the street in Save the Internet marches.

There are two particularly concerning sections of the law.

Article 11 prevents news aggregators, such as search engines and social media companies, from linking and providing snippets of news articles without paying a “link tax”. 

This is clearly absurd. There is no reason why websites should have to pay for what is, in fact, doing news organisations a favour by linking people to their content. It is the responsibility of news organisations to monetise their content through advertisements or paywalls, not attempt to siphon revenues from more successful technology companies.

In practice, this will concentrate power in the hands of large news sites, who are most likely to reach deals to licence the right to link to each other and other sites. A German study found almost two-thirds of revenue will go to a single publisher, and just 1 per cent to smaller publishers. It’s therefore no surprise that the multinational publishing industry lobbyists pushed the directive.

The internet was supposed to democratise access to information. This article will decrease access to online news. It will be much simpler for most websites to block links than go through the effort and expense of reaching licence deals. In 2014, Google shut down Google News in Spain to avoid legal liability in response to a similar domestic law. It was not worth operating a free service that brings in little revenue at the cost of paying for links.

Article 13 makes platforms (like Google, Facebook, Twitter, Tumblr, and web forums) proactively liable for breaking copyright. It reverses the onus, assuming user-generated content breaks copyright unless proven otherwise. This undermines the essential internet principle that platforms should not be legally responsible for the content produced by their users. 
Platforms are like libraries. When a book breaks copyright or is defamatory it is removed. But you do not sue a library for what authors write, you go straight to the source. While they must remove content on request if it breaks the law, internet platforms should not be liable for everything people say.

Copyright is often unclear and contested. Because they will be legally liable, Facebook, YouTube and other platforms will need to use automated systems to prevent users posting swaths of content from images, videos, and music through to humorous GIFs and memes. In practice, this means new, complex upload filters. 

This is a serious threat to freedom of expression and online creativity, which often involves mixing together various creative sources. It’ll also often result in false positives and, to avoid paying fines, substantial limiting of content where copyright is uncertain.

CapX:             Image: Nick Youngson

You Might Also Read: 

Get Ready For ePrivacy Regulation:

 

 

« Five Tech Trends Driving Cyber Security
Identity Management Fundamentals »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

ON-DEMAND WEBINAR: What Is A Next-Generation Firewall (and why does it matter)?

ON-DEMAND WEBINAR: What Is A Next-Generation Firewall (and why does it matter)?

Watch this webinar to hear security experts from Amazon Web Services (AWS) and SANS break down the myths and realities of what an NGFW is, how to use one, and what it can do for your security posture.

Syxsense

Syxsense

Syxsense brings together endpoint management and security for greater efficiency and collaboration between IT management and security teams.

IT Governance

IT Governance

IT Governance is a leading global provider of information security solutions. Download our free guide and find out how ISO 27001 can help protect your organisation's information.

Practice Labs

Practice Labs

Practice Labs is an IT competency hub, where live-lab environments give access to real equipment for hands-on practice of essential cybersecurity skills.

Jooble

Jooble

Jooble is a job search aggregator operating in 71 countries worldwide. We simplify the job search process by displaying active job ads from major job boards and career sites across the internet.

Direct Recruiters Inc

Direct Recruiters Inc

Direct Recruiters is a relationship-focused search firm that assists IT Security and Cybersecurity companies with recruiting high-impact talent.

Japan Network Security Association (JNSA)

Japan Network Security Association (JNSA)

JNSA's goal is to promote standardization related to network security and to contribute to greater technological standards in the field.

ThreatBook

ThreatBook

ThreatBook is dedicated to providing real-time, accurate and actionable threat intelligence to block, detect and prevent attacks.

Information System Security Directorate (ISSD) - Afghanistan

Information System Security Directorate (ISSD) - Afghanistan

Information System Security Directorate (ISSD) is the Directorate of MCIT responsible for the security of critical information infrastructures in Afghanistan.

LaoCERT

LaoCERT

LaoCERT is the national Computer Incident Response Team for Laos.

mPrest

mPrest

mPrest is a global provider of mission-critical monitoring and control solutions for the defense, security, utility and Industrial Internet of Things (IoT) sectors.

AppTec

AppTec

AppTec is a leading software vendor in the field of Unified Endpoint Management and Mobile Security.

The Security Company (TSC)

The Security Company (TSC)

The Security Company is a leading provider of creative employee security awareness programmes.

BAE Systems

BAE Systems

BAE Systems develop, engineer, manufacture, and support products and systems to deliver military capability, protect national security, and keep critical information and infrastructure secure.

Descope

Descope

Descope is a service that helps every developer build secure, frictionless authentication and user journeys for any application.

Casepoint

Casepoint

Casepoint is the legal technology platform of choice for corporations, government agencies, and law firms to meet their complex eDiscovery, investigations, and compliance needs.

S2W

S2W

S2W is a data intelligence company specialized in cyber threat intelligence, brand/digital abuse, and blockchain.

Smarsh

Smarsh

Smarsh products are designed for user-friendly, efficient compliance. From archiving, supervision, and discovery to cybersecurity – Smarsh has you covered.

Ark Technology Consultants

Ark Technology Consultants

Ark Technology Consultants is a unique IT Services Firm which blends technology solutions with consultative insight around governance and process management.

BlazeGuard

BlazeGuard

At BlazeGuard, we understand that navigating the complex world of cybersecurity can be challenging. That’s why we make it our mission to simplify the process for you.

UltraViolet Cyber

UltraViolet Cyber

UltraViolet is an industry leading tech-enabled managed security services company.