Swedes Turn Against Cashlessness

Sweden’s central bank governor has called for public control over its payment system. Others say a fully digital system is vulnerable to fraud and attack

It is hard to argue that you cannot trust the government when the government isn’t really all that bad. This is the problem facing the small but growing number of Swedes anxious about their country’s rush to embrace a cash-free society.

Most consumers already say they manage without cash altogether, while shops and cafes increasingly refuse to accept notes and coins because of the costs and risk involved. Until recently, however, it has been hard for critics to find a hearing.

“The Swedish government is a rather nice one, we have been lucky enough to have mostly nice ones for the past 100 years,” says Christian Engström, a former MEP for the Pirate Party and an early opponent of the cashless economy.

“In other countries there is much more awareness that you cannot trust the government all the time. In Sweden it is hard to get people mobilised.”

There are signs this might be changing. In February, the head of Sweden’s central bank warned that Sweden could soon face a situation where all payments were controlled by private sector banks.

The Riksbank governor, Stefan Ingves, called for new legislation to secure public control over the payments system, arguing that being able to make and receive payments is a “collective good” like defence, the courts, or public statistics.

“Most citizens would feel uncomfortable to surrender these social functions to private companies,” he said.

“It should be obvious that Sweden’s preparedness would be weakened if, in a serious crisis or war, we had not decided in advance how households and companies would pay for fuel, supplies and other necessities.”

The central bank governor’s remarks are helping to bring other concerns about a cash-free society into the mainstream, says Björn Eriksson, 72, a former national police commissioner and the leader of a group called the Cash Rebellion, or Kontantupproret.

Until now, Kontantupproret has been dismissed as the voice of the elderly and the technologically backward, Eriksson says.

“When you have a fully digital system you have no weapon to defend yourself if someone turns it off,” he says.

“If Putin invades Gotland [Sweden’s largest island] it will be enough for him to turn off the payments system. No other country would even think about taking these sorts of risks, they would demand some sort of analogue system.”

In this sense, Sweden is far from its famous concept of lagom – “just the right amount”, but instead is “100% extreme”, Eriksson says, by investing so much faith in the banks. “This is a political question. We are leaving these decisions to four major banks who form a monopoly in Sweden.”

No system based on technology is invulnerable to glitches and fraud, says Mattias Skarec, 29, a digital security consultant. Yet Sweden is divided into two camps: the first says “we love the new technology”, while the other just can’t be bothered, Skarec says. “We are naive to think we can abandon cash completely and rely on technology instead.”

Skarec points to problems with card payments experienced by two Swedish banks just during the past year, and by Bank ID, the digital authorisation system that allows people to identify themselves for payment purposes using their phones.

Fraudsters have already learned to exploit the system’s idiosyncrasies to trick people out of large sums of money, even their pensions.

The best case scenario is that we are not as secure as we think, Skarec says, the worst is that IT infrastructure is systemically vulnerable.

“We are lucky that the people who know how to hack into them are on the good side, for now,” he says. “But we don’t know how things will progress. It’s not that easy to attack devices today, but maybe it will become easier to do so in the future.”

The banks recognise that digital payments can be vulnerable, just like cash.

“Of course there are people trying to abuse them, but they are no more vulnerable than any other method of payment,” says Per Ekwall, a spokesperson for Swish, the immensely popular mobile payments system owned by Sweden’s banks.

“From a macro perspective Swish has made it safer, and cheaper,” he says. There is little point in fighting a trend that customers themselves are driving, the banks argue.

But an opinion poll this month revealed unease among Swedes, with almost seven out of 10 saying they wanted to keep the option to use cash, while just 25% wanted a completely cashless society. MPs from left and right expressed concerns at a recent parliamentary hearing. Parliament is conducting a cross-party review of central bank legislation that will also investigate the issues surrounding cash.

The Pirate Party, which made its name in Sweden for its opposition to state and private sector surveillance, welcomes a higher political profile for these issues.

Look at Ireland, Christian Engström says, where abortion is illegal. It is much easier for authorities to identify Irish women who have had an abortion if the state can track all digital financial transactions, he says. And while Sweden’s government might be relatively benign, a quick look at Europe suggests there is no guarantee how things might develop in the future.

“If you have control of the servers belonging to Visa or MasterCard, you have control of Sweden,” Engström says.

“In the meantime, we will have to keep giving our money to the banks, and hope they don’t go bankrupt, or bananas.”

Guardian:

You Might Also Read:

The Future Of Cash (£):

Bill Gates Says Cryptocurrencies Are Deadly:

 

« NATO & EU Form Cybersecurity Partnership
How AI Will Define New Industries »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Check Point

Directory of Suppliers

IT Governance

IT Governance

IT Governance is a leading global provider of information security solutions. Download our free guide and find out how ISO 27001 can help protect your organisation's information.

MIRACL

MIRACL

MIRACL provides the world’s only single step Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) which can replace passwords on 100% of mobiles, desktops or even Smart TVs.

XYPRO Technology

XYPRO Technology

XYPRO is the market leader in HPE Non-Stop Security, Risk Management and Compliance.

TÜV SÜD Academy UK

TÜV SÜD Academy UK

TÜV SÜD offers expert-led cybersecurity training to help organisations safeguard their operations and data.

BackupVault

BackupVault

BackupVault is a leading provider of automatic cloud backup and critical data protection against ransomware, insider attacks and hackers for businesses and organisations worldwide.

Bulb Security

Bulb Security

Whether your internal red team or penetration testing team needs training, or you lack internal resources and need an outsourced penetration test, Bulb Security can help.

ESET

ESET

ESET provide security software for enterprises and consumers - Antivirus Software, Internet Security and Virus Protection.

CERT-MU

CERT-MU

CERT-MU is the Mauritian National Computer Security Incident Response Team.

GSMA - IoT Security Guidelines

GSMA - IoT Security Guidelines

GSMA has created a set of security guidelines for the benefit of service providers who are looking to develop new IoT products and services.

ThreatQuotient

ThreatQuotient

ThreatQuotient delivers an open and extensible threat intelligence platform to provide defenders the context, customization and collaboration needed for increased security effectiveness.

RHEA Group

RHEA Group

RHEA Group offers aerospace and security engineering services and solutions, system development, and technologies including cyber security.

PixelPlex

PixelPlex

PixelPlex is a blockchain and custom software development company with offices and developers in New York, Geneva, and Seoul.

Blackfoot Cybersecurity

Blackfoot Cybersecurity

At Blackfoot, we work in partnership with you to deliver on-demand cyber security expertise and assurance, keeping you one step ahead of threats & compliant with regulations.

Lionfish Cyber Security

Lionfish Cyber Security

Lionfish Cyber Evolution & Empowerment Model™ empowers SMBs to prepare and protect themselves against cyber threats using a unique combination of on-demand training, support and managed services.

Sentrium Security

Sentrium Security

Sentrium is committed to helping organisations protect their technology, information and people. Our range of bespoke services provide solutions to tackle a broad range of cyber security challenges.

Ermetic

Ermetic

Ermetic’s identity-first cloud infrastructure security platform provides holistic, multi-cloud protection in an easy-to-deploy SaaS solution.

Quatrro Business Support Services (QBSS)

Quatrro Business Support Services (QBSS)

QBSS is a tech-enabled outsourcing firm that’s changing the way companies think about finance, accounting, human resources and technology services.

Ampcus Cyber

Ampcus Cyber

Ampcus Cyber specialize in providing comprehensive security solutions and services that are tailored to safeguard our clients' networks, infrastructure, and valuable assets.

Axiotrop

Axiotrop

AXIOTROP is a Cybersecurity firm offering leading services in assessment, remediation, and validation to protect the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of regulated information.

Cybermindz

Cybermindz

Many cyber security professionals are under sustained and increasing stress. We set about providing direct support to restore and rebuild emotional and cognitive health.

Soteria LLC

Soteria LLC

Soteria LLC are a client-focused organization providing expert advisory, consulting services, and tailored solutions to prevent, detect, and respond to cybersecurity incidents.