Shutdown Is Doing Lasting Damage To US National Security

As the longest government shutdown in American history continues and we are beginning to see indicators of short-term national, and homeland-security vulnerabilities. 

The US government’s newest cybersecurity unit had barely launched before half its staff were furloughed. FBI agents are also on furlough and airports are short of screeners. Each of these lapses may cause specific problems: Dangerous weapons may slip through security, endangering the flying public; investigative leads may suffer from inattention, causing investigations of federal crimes to be delayed or go unfinished; and recent efforts to improve federal cybersecurity may be stopped before they ever really started. 

Moreover, given the importance this administration purports to place on immigration enforcement and border security, the irony of the Department of Homeland Security’s border agents and immigration officials not being compensated to perform their important work is hard to miss.

DHS, the agency charged with key civilian cybersecurity coordination and liaison work with state and local law-enforcement agencies, has been hit hard by the shutdown. Both the executive and legislative branches recognise cybersecurity threats as a top national-security priority. 

Halting cybersecurity work makes it easier for hostile nation-states to steal Americans’ personal information and corporate intellectual property, among other targets. 

DHS is responsible for thwarting those efforts, by sharing cybersecurity information with the private sector as well as with state and local governments. Moreover, DHS provides services to state and local governments that are working to improve their election security. 

But the longer-term costs to national security of this shutdown may be even greater than the short-term risks. One is the cost to the federal workforce itself. Experienced staff, such as foreign service officers are leaving. The government is losing talent that took years to recruit and train, and will take years to replace. 

Agencies are accustomed to training their workforces to competency and then having their best-trained and highest-performing employees take on management and leadership roles. Instead, they may now find their most competent and able agents, investigators, and analysts leaving for the private sector.

Federal employees in the national- and homeland-security fields, like their counterparts in the private sector or non-national-security government roles, have family responsibilities and financial commitments, such as mortgages and car payments. 

Public service is a calling, but the financial stress of an uncertain paycheck can cause mid-career national-security professionals to leave the federal workforce just when they are reaching the point where they have attained expert-level knowledge and substantial experience.

Second is the backlog of work that simply doesn’t get done. The law says government employees can work only on imminent threats to life or property during a shutdown. But mid- to long-term intelligence analysis and policy-option preparation is vital to protecting national security. 

Third, as national-security lawyers, we also know that a national-security workforce facing financial struggles creates a heightened counterintelligence risk. Debt and financial solvency have long been indicators in security background checks to determine whether an individual could be subject to blackmail or influence from a foreign power. 

We have no doubt that, as this shutdown continues, foreign-intelligence services are considering how they can exploit members of America’s national-security workforce who may be approaching severe financial strain.

The fourth and final concern may be the most worrisome of all: The United States is showing the world how utterly polarised, even paralysed, we’ve become. This plays directly into Moscow’s strategy to weaken us at home and abroad. The Kremlin seems to have wanted Donald Trump in the White House, but even in the campaign’s waning weeks, it didn’t expect him to win, hence Russia’s continued messaging that the election was “rigged,” a meme that disappeared after Trump’s surprising victory. 

More than Trump’s election, the Kremlin wanted the US to tear itself apart, leaving it unable to oppose Russian foreign policy or to push for democratic reforms. The first two years of this administration, with Trump at the helm, have weakened our ties to our global allies in favor of foreign policies more sympathetic to Russian strategic interests. Now, at home, this government shutdown further weakens our defenses with every passing day.

The president says our security requires the shutdown. But actually, the shutdown is the real national-security threat, and its damage will prove lasting.

DefenseOne

You Might Also Read:

Russians Are Confident Their Homeland Is Secure:

 

 

 

« Zimbabwe Orders Internet Disconnected
World Economic Forum Cyber Risks Report »

Infosecurity Europe
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

ZenGRC

ZenGRC

ZenGRC (formerly Reciprocity) is a leader in the GRC SaaS landscape, offering robust and intuitive products designed to make compliance straightforward and efficient.

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

IT Governance

IT Governance

IT Governance is a leading global provider of information security solutions. Download our free guide and find out how ISO 27001 can help protect your organisation's information.

LockLizard

LockLizard

Locklizard provides PDF DRM software that protects PDF documents from unauthorized access and misuse. Share and sell documents securely - prevent document leakage, sharing and piracy.

Jooble

Jooble

Jooble is a job search aggregator operating in 71 countries worldwide. We simplify the job search process by displaying active job ads from major job boards and career sites across the internet.

Irish Reporting & Information Security Service (IRISS)

Irish Reporting & Information Security Service (IRISS)

IRISS-CERT is Ireland's first CSIRT (Computer Security Incident Response Team) to provide services to all users within Ireland.

Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI)

Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI)

IAI offers a holistic approach that provides defense forces, governments, critical infrastructures and large enterprises with end-to-end cyber security & monitoring tools.

limes datentechnik

limes datentechnik

limes datentechnik is an authority in the fields of cryptography and data compression. The FLAM product family is an internationally accepted standard for efficient and safe handling of data.

Travelers

Travelers

Travelers is a leading writer of US commercial property casualty insurance and one of the world’s largest global insurers for cyber insurance.

Shieldfy

Shieldfy

Shieldfy is a cloud-based security shield for your website to protect it from cyber attacks and malwares.

UNIDIR Cyber Policy Portal

UNIDIR Cyber Policy Portal

The UNIDIR Cyber Policy Portal is an online reference tool that maps the cybersecurity and cybersecurity-related policy landscape.

Privacera

Privacera

Privacera enables consistent data governance, security, and compliance across all your data services - on-premises and in the cloud - so you can maximize the value of your data.

Mjenzi Cloud

Mjenzi Cloud

Mjenzi Cloud is a provider of cloud IaaS solutions including managed backup services, affordable & secure cloud virtual compute/storage/compute services, bare-metal services and cloud security.

Albania Lab

Albania Lab

Albania Lab is a consulting company focused on the development and delivery of digital solutions and IT services including cybersecurity.

Trisul Network Analytics

Trisul Network Analytics

Trisul helps organizations deploy full spectrum deep network monitoring which can serve as a single source of truth for performance monitoring, security analytics, threat detection and compliance.

EtherAuthority

EtherAuthority

EtherAuthority's engineering team has been helping blockchain businesses to secure their smart contract based assets since 2018.

FTx Identity

FTx Identity

FTx Identity is the world's most advanced age verification technology (AVT) and identity management system.

We Hack Purple

We Hack Purple

We Hack Purple is a Canadian company dedicated to helping anyone and everyone create secure software.

AKIPS

AKIPS

AKIPS develops the world's most scalable network and infrastructure monitoring software, delivered as a turn-key software appliance.

Cypheria

Cypheria

Cypheria harness the expertise of elite military units and combine it with extensive digital combat experience to deliver unparalleled security solutions for organizations.

Secher Security

Secher Security

Secher Security is a professional and secure partner with a high level of professional expertise in simplifying and optimizing complex IT infrastructures.