Russia And US Offer Competing Visions Of Cyber Normality

It’s October and the United Nations General Assembly and subsidiary committees have started their work in earnest. 

As expected, Russia tabled a draft resolution seeking the General Assembly’s endorsement of an “international code of conduct for international information security,” and a resumption of the UN Group of Governmental Experts (GGE) process next year. 

Somewhat less expected, however, is that the United States tabled a competing resolution, setting up a clash between Russia, China, and their largely autocratic friends on one side, and the United States, the European Union, Canada, Japan, and Australia on the other. 

First, some Background 

Almost every year since 1998, Russia has sponsored a General Assembly resolution called “Developments in the field of information and telecommunications in the context of international security.” It’s the mechanism through which UN member states express concern that malicious activity in cyberspace can undermine international peace and security. 

It’s also the resolution that created the GGEs on cybersecurity. Three of those GGEs led to consensus reports that recommended states abide by a set of norms, including the applicability of international law to cyberspace, participate in confidence building measures, and support capacity building initiatives to reduce the risk that state actions in cyberspace threaten international peace and security.

The text of the resolution has not been made public, but it is likely to be a combination of existing cyber norms the GGE agreed to in 2013 and 2015 and previous iterations of another code of conduct members of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) proposed in 2011 and 2015. 

The inclusion of the SCO language will make the United States and like-minded countries balk given its negative human rights implications. 

Nevertheless, the proposed Russian resolution could probably be salvaged through negotiation that strips it of the SCO code’s worst elements, keeps the consensus GGE language, and mandates the creation of a new GGE to pick up where the last one fell apart.

The text of the proposed Russian resolution is now public, and it’s about as expected. It cherry picks some of the worst elements from the previous Codes (e.g. promotes concepts of “cyber sovereignty,” sidelines the role of the private sector, etc.), un-ironically bemoans the spread of disinformation online, and mis-characterises previous consensus GGE text. 

It also calls for a new GGE with the mandate of identifying ways to implement the new code of conduct, make changes as necessary, and to study the possibility of establishing an “institutional dialogue” on cyber issues within the United Nations. 

The United States must have deemed the Russian text unsalvageable because it proposed its own competing resolution, backed by EU countries, Canada, Australia, and a few others. It applauds the work of the previous GGEs, calls on member states to abide by the previous reports’ recommendations, and requests a new GGE be established with largely the same mandate as previous ones.

Contrary to previous iterations, however, the United States asks that whatever report comes from the new GGE should include an annex “containing national contributions of participating governmental experts on the subject of how international law applies to the use of information and communication technologies by States.” 

The United States started laying out its understanding of how international law applies online in the Obama administration (here and here), and has encouraged countries to do the same. Earlier this year, the UK Attorney General laid out his country’s views on the matter. 

By pushing for an annex in the GGE report, the United States is trying to get Russia, China, and others on the record, particularly salient for China as it has remained silent on whether international humanitarian law applies online. 

I’m not a UN process expert, so it’s hard to say how this will play out. But if I were a betting man, I’d put my money on the US approach coming out on top. As an institution, the United Nations prefers incrementalism over radical change. 

That makes it much harder for Russia, China and the rest of the SCO members to drum up support for a twenty-five paragraph code of conduct that contains vague language mostly unfamiliar to many states. 

By contrast, the US resolution has more similarities to Russia’s previous resolutions, an advantage given that they will be familiar to diplomats at the UN who prefer sticking to previously agreed text. 

No matter what happens as diplomats haggle over the particulars of the resolution, expect a new GGE next year. The only open question at this point is its mandate, and that should be made clear in the next few weeks. 

Defense One:

You Might Also Read:

Cyberattack Revelations Appear To Undercut Russia's UN Efforts:

Russia Will Build A Separate Internet Directory:

The US Is Losing the Information War To Russia

« IBM Spends $34B To Buy Red Hat
British Refuse To Co-operate With Belgian Hacking Inquiry »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

The PC Support Group

The PC Support Group

A partnership with The PC Support Group delivers improved productivity, reduced costs and protects your business through exceptional IT, telecoms and cybersecurity services.

LockLizard

LockLizard

Locklizard provides PDF DRM software that protects PDF documents from unauthorized access and misuse. Share and sell documents securely - prevent document leakage, sharing and piracy.

North Infosec Testing (North IT)

North Infosec Testing (North IT)

North IT (North Infosec Testing) are an award-winning provider of web, software, and application penetration testing.

ZenGRC

ZenGRC

ZenGRC (formerly Reciprocity) is a leader in the GRC SaaS landscape, offering robust and intuitive products designed to make compliance straightforward and efficient.

Syxsense

Syxsense

Syxsense brings together endpoint management and security for greater efficiency and collaboration between IT management and security teams.

Duane Morris LLP

Duane Morris LLP

Duane Morris is a global law firm with offices in the USA, UK and Asia. Practice areas include Cybersecurity.

Datto

Datto

Datto delivers a single toolbox of easy to use products and services designed specifically for managed service providers and the businesses they serve.

MailGuard

MailGuard

MailGuard delivers a full suite of security solutions across email and web to protect your business before threats reach your environment.

Potomac Institute for Policy Studies

Potomac Institute for Policy Studies

Potomac Institute undertakes research on key science, technology, and national security issues facing society, Study areas include cybersecurity.

ComTrue Technologies

ComTrue Technologies

ComTrue Technologies provides artificial intelligence solutions and information security solutions.

OneVisage

OneVisage

Our award-winning 3DAuth digital identity platform turns any consumer mobile device into a real-time 3D facial scanner that securely authenticates the user in seconds.

Post-Quantum

Post-Quantum

Post-Quantum offer a unique, patented quantum-resistant encryption algorithm that can be applied to existing products and networks.

CyberWarrior

CyberWarrior

CyberWarrior deliver training and consulting for some of the world’s top brands and also partner with national systems integrators to augment their teams with our expertise.

H3Secure

H3Secure

H3 Secure focuses on Secure Data Erasure Solutions, Mobile Device Diagnostics and Information Technology Security Consulting.

Strategic Cyber Ventures (SCV)

Strategic Cyber Ventures (SCV)

SCV grow cybersecurity companies that disrupt advanced cyber adversaries and revolutionize the cyber product marketplace.

ECS Ethiopia

ECS Ethiopia

ECS Ethiopia provides Ethiopia’s leading institutions with top cyber-security expertise and technology to enable them to overcome risks and market barriers enabling them to grow their business.

Metabase Q

Metabase Q

Metabase Q protects you from financial and reputational losses with more efficient and intelligent cybersecurity, using the best worldwide in technologies, processes and specialists.

The Cyber Guild

The Cyber Guild

The Cyber Guild is a not-for-profit organization working to improve the understanding and practice of cybersecurity, and to help raise awareness and education for all.

Cyberani Solutions

Cyberani Solutions

Cyberani Solutions was created to fulfill the cybersecurity needs of industry and government in Saudi Arabia, and across the Middle East and North Africa regions.

Rhymetec

Rhymetec

Rhymetec are an industry leader in cloud security, providing innovative cybersecurity and data privacy services to the modern-day SaaS business.

Cyber Guards

Cyber Guards

Cyber Guards provide comprehensive, turn-key cyber security programs for small and mid-size business for about the cost of one full-time cybersecurity hire.