Robots Take Over The World’s Work

For so many jobs, machines are faster, more consistent, smarter, and cheaper than you or I will ever be.

As advances in artificial intelligence accelerate, robots will spread into all corners of the labor market: blue collar and white collar, service work and knowledge work alike.

Along with their jobs, people will lose their incomes. When that happens, governments will also lose theirs. Where does the money come from without incomes to tax?

One San Francisco lawmaker is trying to get ahead of this likely revenue gap by going after the source of the problem: She wants to tax the robots.

Supervisor Jane Kim has been meeting with labor leaders, academics, and tech types to explore the radical plan, a natural fit for a city where billionaire tech bros and liberal politicians both hold sway. But there's at least one problem with Kim's plan: No one can really agree on what a robot is.

The concept of a robot tax isn’t new, Kim got the idea from Bill Gates’ instantly infamous interview with Quartzin.

Bill Gates said: “Right now, the human worker who does, say, $50,000 worth of work in a factory, that income is taxed and you get income tax, social security tax, all those things. If a robot comes in to do the same thing, you’d think that we’d tax the robot at a similar level.”

The reaction was swift and not exactly measured, in no small part because tech types appreciate regulation about as much as they appreciate not wearing hoodies and jeans with flip-flops.

But it’s hard to imagine a future in which the US economy loses a third of its jobs to automation and governments just sit on their hands. "I do think that government is going to have to regulate it," Kim says. "I mean, I know tech hates hearing that word, but we're all part of a larger community and society, and there are implications when 37 percent of the workforce isn't working anymore."

Kim is not a robot-tax evangelist. She’s a supervisor in a city with one of the starkest income inequalities in the world. Robots and AI promise to further concentrate wealth in the hands of the elite techie class. So for Kim, a robot tax is an idea at least worth exploring, not hurriedly enacting next week.

I, Robot?

Ask 10 roboticists what a robot actually is and you’ll get 10 different answers. But here’s one from Hanumant Singh, of Northeastern University: a system that exhibits “complex” behavior and includes sensing and actuation. That's a super broad answer, and shows just how complex a problem Kim may be up against.

A self-driving car is a robot by that definition. So is a 747 on autopilot. And that's to say nothing of AI, which will arguably replace far more jobs, even if it's only via algorithms running on smartphones. So would this be a robot/AI tax? Kim is still working through the definitions here.

The question is not just philosophical: If the idea is to make up for the fiscal gaps the robot takeover will inflict, politicians will have to decide what kinds of automation count.

Arguably, tax software has already replaced many tax professionals. So do you ding Inuit, the maker of TurboTax? And it's not hard to imagine a future where you order goods from a bot like the one in your Amazon Echo. The bot then dispatches a delivery robot to your home. So are both parties complicit in circumventing the UPS delivery worker's job?

Ambiguity in defining what a robot is will likely also open up accounting loopholes. "Maybe you have a robot with multiple arms, so that instead of having to get five robots, you get one robot but it does the work of five robots," Dean Baker, a cofounder of the Center for Economic and Policy Research. "You avoid the tax on the other four."

Ultimately, however, the question isn't how many robots but how much productive labor humans lose to them. A job lost is a job lost, whatever the reason, and the consequences are likely to be the same. In West Virginia, the coal industry has declined even without heavy robot infiltration, and mass unemployment has followed.

For every displaced worker, the state loses out on income tax. Losing your job means you stop spending money. "So there's no sales tax revenue because there's no sales," says Joseph Henchman, vice president of state projects at the Tax Foundation. "And then property values are depressed because nobody wants to buy property in those towns, so that reduces property tax revenue."

The ironic difference between a traditional economy in decline and an economy in which robots have come to dominate is that, in theory at least, robots spur greater overall wealth through increased productivity. But the tax system in the US is still people-centric, which in a roboticised future could lead to a revenue death spiral.

Cities and states get about 30 percent of their revenue from property taxes, 20 percent from sales tax, and another 20 from individual income taxes. When you've got mass unemployment, those revenue sources all tumble in unison. Taxes on corporations, which will benefit most from the lower costs and higher output of robot labor, won't make up the difference, they tally a mere 4 percent of revenue.

"If revenues drop by a third", the projected impact of automation, Henchman says, "that means services need to be cut back by a third, either through trying to be more focused or efficient with the services we do provide, or by actually having to pare back what government does." And those cuts will come at a time when, thanks to mass unemployment driven by automation, demand for those services will be soaring.

A robot tax isn't going to save jobs, but the idea is that it could help cushion the impact of mass automation by funding a universal basic income. Or it could fund job retraining, assuming jobs will still exist to be retrained for.

Or, say automation advocates, a robot tax could hurt the economy in the name of saving it.

Not too keen on a robot tax is, unsurprisingly, the Association for Advancing Automation. Namely, it’s a matter of staying competitive in an explosive young industry, China, in particular, is overflowing with robotics companies. Start taxing robots and you’re likely to step on capitalism’s toes.

Plus, the group says, automation helped return manufacturing jobs to the US in the first place. “This idea of bringing back manufacturing jobs in part is being enabled by the fact that we can compete if we automate here,” says Jeff Burnstein, the association’s president, “as opposed to doing the manufacturing in a low-wage nation, like we often did over the past two decades.”

As for Jane Kim, she's still exploring her options. Again, she’s no robot-tax evangelist. She’s a politician who, like most Americans, hasn’t yet been replaced by a robot. And bully for that: I for one would prefer not being turned into a battery.

Wired:

You Might Also Read:

Will The CIA Be Run By  Robots…?:

UK Thinks Robots And AI Will Lift Economic Growth:

 

« AI Is Streamlining Marketing & Sales
Local Government Computer Systems Are Soft Targets »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

Jooble

Jooble

Jooble is a job search aggregator operating in 71 countries worldwide. We simplify the job search process by displaying active job ads from major job boards and career sites across the internet.

Clayden Law

Clayden Law

Clayden Law advise global businesses that buy and sell technology products and services. We are experts in information technology, data privacy and cybersecurity law.

BackupVault

BackupVault

BackupVault is a leading provider of automatic cloud backup and critical data protection against ransomware, insider attacks and hackers for businesses and organisations worldwide.

Practice Labs

Practice Labs

Practice Labs is an IT competency hub, where live-lab environments give access to real equipment for hands-on practice of essential cybersecurity skills.

Lima Networks

Lima Networks

LIMA design and deliver IT Infrastructure solutions and services including managed Security Monitoring services.

Bulb Security

Bulb Security

Whether your internal red team or penetration testing team needs training, or you lack internal resources and need an outsourced penetration test, Bulb Security can help.

Cyber, Space, & Intelligence Association (CSIA)

Cyber, Space, & Intelligence Association (CSIA)

CSIA focuses on issues critical to Cyber Security, Military Space and Intelligence.

Preempt Security

Preempt Security

The Preempt Platform delivers adaptive threat prevention that continuously preempts threats based on identity, behavior and risk.

European Society of Criminology (ESC)

European Society of Criminology (ESC)

The ESC Working Group on Cybercrime is focused on cybercrime, its causes and offenders, impact on victims, and our response to it at the individual, corporate, and governmental levels.

CRI4DATA

CRI4DATA

CRI4DATA's mission is to help organizations build their resilience to cyber risk.

APERIO

APERIO

APERIO, the global leader in industrial data integrity, helps its customers drive profitability and sustainability while mitigating risk in their industrial operations.

NetSecurity

NetSecurity

NetSecurity is a Brazilian company specializing in Information Security. We provide Managed Security Services (MSS), network security solutions and other specialist services.

CPP Group UK

CPP Group UK

CPP Group UK develops products to help insurers add further value to their products and services through its innovative suite of new products in FinTech, InsurTech and cyber security.

SixThirty CYBER

SixThirty CYBER

SixThirty is a venture fund that invests in early-stage enterprise technology companies from around the world building FinTech, InsurTech, and Cybersecurity solutions.

Eaton

Eaton

Eaton provides comprehensive cybersecurity services for operational technology (OT) to help keep your operations and personnel safe.

ThriveDX

ThriveDX

ThriveDX, the world’s premier EdTech provider (formerly HackerU), champions digital transformation training as a means of empowering individuals to thrive in the age of digital disruption.

SecureStrux

SecureStrux

SecureStrux are a cybersecurity consulting firm providing specialized services in the areas of compliance, vulnerability assessment, computer network defense, and cybersecurity strategies.

Paradyn

Paradyn

Paradyn-managed security services can provide a holistic view of your business environment, no matter how simple or complex it is.

Laneden

Laneden

Laneden specialise in helping organisations identify security concerns and quantify the risks you may have across your assets, using Penetration Testing, Threat Simulation and Compliance Testing.

Cyber & Data Protection

Cyber & Data Protection

Cyber & Data Protection Limited supports Charities, Educational Trusts and Private Schools, Hospitality and Legal organisations by keeping their data secure and usable.