New Tools To Fight Fake News

Many sites that generate fake news, or DisInfo-disinformation masquerading as truth, share characteristics that distinguish them from journalistic outlets, according to researchers from MIT and the Qatar Computing Research Institute, who incorporated several of those characteristics into a dataset and then trained an algorithm to identify them. 

Their work could help fight a growing problem that many government experts forecast will only get worse.

Facebook, Twitter, and other social media outlets are building teams of fact checkers and supporting nonprofit organisations like First Draft to spot disinformation. But fact checking and verification takes a lot more time than pushing out disinformation. 

Also, fake news doesn’t always match an expected pattern. Russia DisInfo watchers have long observed that a key Kremlin tactic is to validate conspiratorial ideas on both sides of a given political debate (with the exception of gun control, to which they catered exclusively to pro-gun perspectives.)

That’s why fighting DisInfo piece-by-piece is like bailing a boat that’s filling up faster than buckets can handle. What’s worse, research has shown that news readers of all political persuasions become defensive and resistant to the idea that news they’ve accepted is fake, especially if the act of accepting—and then sharing—that news item furthered their standing within a selected social group.

All of this is why fake news spreads faster than accurately sourced articles, including ones that debunk conspiracy theories and disinformation.

“Automatic fact-checking lags behind in terms of accuracy, and it is generally not trusted by human users. In fact, even when done by reputable fact-checking organisations, debunking does little to convince those who already believe in false information,” the researchers write.

Their study, “Predicting Factuality of Reporting and Bias of News Media Sources,” forthcoming in the Proceedings of the 2018 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language, reveals key features of false news web sites that might be less visible to human fact checkers but can tab a bad news source.

Among the features: specific patterns of so-called “function words” that give a more spoken feel to a news article, as opposed to the far more common “content words.” 

Mainstream news editors clamp down fast and hard on too many function words, but fake news sites may not be edited at all. The number and pattern of words that seem to express some sort of sentiment is another easy giveaway, as is the amount of user engagement and shares; linguistic indicators of bias around specific topics, (or bias generally), also work.

If a news site pumps out a lot of articles with a variety and high degree of these linguistic characteristics, you can safely infer that they’re more likely to be publishing “news” that, well, isn’t.

The researchers found that their algorithm, called the Support Vector Machine, could correctly deduce a high, low, or medium level of “factuality” about 65 percent of the time. It could predict right- or left-leaning bias about 70 percent of the time. While not perfect, it’s a big improvement over a raw guess (50 percent). The authors caution that the algorithm would work best with human fact checkers.

The next step, they write, is “characterising the factuality of reporting for media in other languages. Finally, we want to go beyond left vs. right bias that is typical of the Western world and to model other kinds of biases that are more relevant for other regions, e.g., Islamist vs. secular is one such example for the Muslim World.”

Defense One:                Image: Nick Youngson

You Might Also Read:

Google Is Building A Search Engine For Fact Checks

« Canada Says It Was Targeted By Russian Cyber Attacks
#PresidentialAlert: A US National Alert Test »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

The PC Support Group

The PC Support Group

A partnership with The PC Support Group delivers improved productivity, reduced costs and protects your business through exceptional IT, telecoms and cybersecurity services.

Syxsense

Syxsense

Syxsense brings together endpoint management and security for greater efficiency and collaboration between IT management and security teams.

CSI Consulting Services

CSI Consulting Services

Get Advice From The Experts: * Training * Penetration Testing * Data Governance * GDPR Compliance. Connecting you to the best in the business.

DigitalStakeout

DigitalStakeout

DigitalStakeout enables cyber security professionals to reduce cyber risk to their organization with proactive security solutions, providing immediate improvement in security posture and ROI.

CYRIN

CYRIN

CYRIN® Cyber Range. Real Tools, Real Attacks, Real Scenarios. See why leading educational institutions and companies in the U.S. have begun to adopt the CYRIN® system.

DriveLock

DriveLock

Our security solution is designed to prevent external attacks, which are evermore sophisticated as well as monitor, document and even prevent internal incidents.

iboss Network Security

iboss Network Security

The iboss cloud is designed to deliver Network Security as a Service, in the cloud, using the best malware engines, threat feeds and log analytics engines.

INSUREtrust

INSUREtrust

INSUREtrust is a pioneer in the industry, inventing the concept of cyber insurance.

National Authority Against Electronic Attacks (NAAEA) - Greece

National Authority Against Electronic Attacks (NAAEA) - Greece

The National Authority Against Electronic Attacks (NAAEA) is the national computer emergency response team of Greece.

Magal Security Systems (Magal S3)

Magal Security Systems (Magal S3)

Magal Security Systems is a leading international provider of integrated solutions and products for physical and cyber security, safety and site management.

Flexential

Flexential

Flexential helps organizations optimize their journey of IT transformation while simultaneously balancing cost, scalability, compliance and security.

Secure Innovations

Secure Innovations

Secure Innovations is a cybersecurity firm dedicated to providing top-tier cyber security solutions for the Defense and the Intelligence Community.

ATIA

ATIA

ATIA provides consulting services in the design and implementation of IT system, Information Security, ISO certification, and professional IT training and education.

Avertium

Avertium

Avertium is the managed security and consulting provider that companies turn to when they want more than check-the-box cybersecurity.

Safetech Innovations

Safetech Innovations

Safetech Innovations is a team of cyber security experts, always at your service. We use human and cyber intelligence to help your business in uncertain times.

HENSOLDT Cyber

HENSOLDT Cyber

HENSOLDT Cyber introduces a paradigm shift to cyber security. Our products have been designed to ensure the integrity of embedded systems at the core: the operating system and the processor.

FCI

FCI

FCI is a NIST-Based Managed Security Service Provider (MSSP) offering Cybersecurity Compliance Enablement Technologies & Services to Financial Services organizations.

BrainStorm

BrainStorm

BrainStorm Threat Defense takes a new human-focused approach to security awareness that traditional training lacks. It’s a cutting-edge platform to make your users more security savvy.

ICS

ICS

ICS is a leading provider of outsourced IT services, cybersecurity, communications, and distributed workforce solutions throughout the US.

GuardYoo

GuardYoo

GuardYoo's SaaS platform allows cybersecurity professionals to perform Compromise Assessment remotely from anywhere in the world.

Star Lab

Star Lab

Star Lab specializes in the development and productization of embedded security technologies.