Is Predictive Policing The Future?

As big data transforms industries ranging from retailing to health care, it’s also becoming a more important tool for police departments, which are turning to data and analysis in an effort to boost their effectiveness.

Known as predictive policing, the practice involves analyzing data on the time, location and nature of past crimes, along with things such as geography and the weather, to gain insight into where and when future crime is most likely to occur and try to deter it before it happens.

Jennifer Bachner, director of the master of science in government analytics program at Johns Hopkins University, says giving police the ability to make data-driven decisions will help reduce biases that result in unfair discrimination, resulting in better relations between police and the communities they serve. Jennifer Lynch, senior staff attorney at the Electronic Frontier Foundation, says predictive policing is flawed and will only serve to focus more law-enforcement surveillance on communities that are already over-policed.

In an era of tight budgets, police departments across the country are being asked to do more with less. They must protect the public, but often have to do it with limited personnel, equipment and training resources.

To address this problem, law-enforcement agencies increasingly are turning to data and analytics to improve their ability to fight crime without substantial increases in operating costs. Known as predictive policing, these technologies and techniques empower police officers to take a more proactive approach to both preventing crime and solving open cases.

Predictive policing involves crunching data on past crimes, along with information such as the weather, the time of day and the presence of escape routes, to forecast where and when future crime is most likely to occur. In cities such as Santa Cruz, Calif., officers have access to maps outlining “hot spots,” or geographic areas most vulnerable to crime at a future point in time, and they are encouraged to use the information along with their knowledge of the community to decide where to allocate the most resources on a given shift.

The theory isn’t complicated—being in the right place at the right time deters crime, and the approach has proved effective, particularly in places such as Santa Cruz, where the population is dispersed over a large area.

Some in law enforcement say predictive policing is particularly helpful when it comes to identifying and halting repeat criminals.

The Baltimore County Police Department says it used predictive methods to halt a string of convenience-store robberies. Police had information about the locations of the robberies and a suspected model of car used by the elusive offender, but no obvious next target. By plotting the robbed locations on a map and employing an iterative algorithm, police identified a suspected point of origin. 

Police then analyzed the streets that would likely have been used to reach the crime locations and detected one specific street that the offender had likely used frequently (and would probably use again) to travel to crime scenes. Officers staked out that street, rather than patrolling numerous convenience stores, and were able to apprehend the suspect.

Some critics say that because not all crime is reported, predictive models based on past crime data might miss future crimes that don’t fit historical patterns. But today’s predictive models aren’t based solely on past crime data—they also take into account some of the same things potential criminals do when planning crimes, such as geographic information.

To achieve positive results with predictive policing, some upfront costs are required: Law-enforcement agencies must make an initial investment not only in software, but also in training officers to understand the proper scope and limitations of data-driven policing.

The use of data, like the use of any tool, leaves openings for misuse, but police departments can take steps to protect civil liberties. There is a big difference, for example, between predicting where crime is most likely to occur and developing lists of potential future offenders without probable cause, a practice that certainly raises serious ethical and legal concerns.

Policy makers also must grapple with the proper scope of data collection, retention and use and be able to explain to the community how data is being used to enhance public safety. That is why departments that adopt predictive-policing programs must at the same time re-emphasize their commitment to community policing. Officers won’t achieve substantial reductions in crime by holing up in patrol cars, generating real-time hot-spot maps. Effective policing still requires that officers build trust with the communities they serve.

With proper implementation, monitoring and transparency, the trend toward evidence-based policing should ultimately enhance the relationship between communities and police officers. That’s because data-driven decision-making is a step away from decisions based on biases that can result in unfair discrimination. Predictive models grounded in relevant data, including everything from past crime to the weather, limit the influence of prejudice or profiling by officers.

The stakes are high, but predictive policing offers an opportunity to make significant advances toward a safer and more just society.
WSJ: http://on.wsj.com/1SFpRs6

« Global Cyber Alliance To Tackle The Biggest Risks
Implementing EU Privacy Laws Requires 28,000 New Data Professionals »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

XYPRO Technology

XYPRO Technology

XYPRO is the market leader in HPE Non-Stop Security, Risk Management and Compliance.

The PC Support Group

The PC Support Group

A partnership with The PC Support Group delivers improved productivity, reduced costs and protects your business through exceptional IT, telecoms and cybersecurity services.

DigitalStakeout

DigitalStakeout

DigitalStakeout enables cyber security professionals to reduce cyber risk to their organization with proactive security solutions, providing immediate improvement in security posture and ROI.

ZenGRC

ZenGRC

ZenGRC - the first, easy-to-use, enterprise-grade information security solution for compliance and risk management - offers businesses efficient control tracking, testing, and enforcement.

Practice Labs

Practice Labs

Practice Labs is an IT competency hub, where live-lab environments give access to real equipment for hands-on practice of essential cybersecurity skills.

StoneFly

StoneFly

StoneFly offers High Availability, high performance cluster and scale out storage, and backup and disaster recovery appliances.

TEISS

TEISS

Teiss.co.uk is a website dedicated to providing information about cyber security. TEISS also provide a series of conferences and events focused on cyber security.

Saviynt

Saviynt

Saviynt is a leading provider of Cloud Security and Identity Governance solutions.

Seavus

Seavus

Seavus is a software development and consulting company with a proven track-record in providing successful enterprise-wide business solutions including Managed Security Services.

2Keys

2Keys

2Keys designs, deploys and operates Digital Identity Platforms and Cyber Security Platforms through Managed Service and Professional Service engagements.

CM Blockchain Security Center

CM Blockchain Security Center

We are dedicated to building a healthier blockchain ecosystem, providing solutions to security technology, and helping those who practice in the area of blockchain to get insight into industry trends.

Cyber Security Courses

Cyber Security Courses

Cyber Security Courses was formed to help students in the UK find cyber security courses online.

Falcongaze

Falcongaze

Falcongaze SecureTower is a comprehensive DLP solution for the protection of business against internal threats.

Axitea

Axitea

Axitea designs, implements and develops the solutions best suited to its customers’ needs and their physical and cyber security requirements.

Rolls-Royce Cybersecurity Technology Research Network

Rolls-Royce Cybersecurity Technology Research Network

Rolls-Royce has partnered with Purdue University and Carnegie Mellon University to create the Rolls-Royce Cybersecurity Technology Research Network.

Hubify

Hubify

Hubify is an experienced, service-driven technology company specialising in business connectivity across mobile, data, voice, cloud, & cyber security solutions.

TheGreenBow

TheGreenBow

TheGreenBow is a trusted VPN software company. We help organizations and individuals become cyber-responsible. For this, we design and develop reliable and easy-to-use solutions.

Infiot

Infiot

Infiot is a pioneer in enabling secure, reliable access with zero trust security, network optimization, edge-intelligence and AI driven operations for all remote users, devices, sites and cloud.

Topsec Cloud Solutions

Topsec Cloud Solutions

The Topsec Managed Email Security Platform eliminates Spam, Viruses, Malware, and Phishing.

Fletch

Fletch

Fletch’s AI tracks the evolving cybersecurity threat landscape by reading and interpreting every threat article every day and matching those threats to a company’s exposure.

IndoSec

IndoSec

IndoSec is an annual cybersecurity summit that powers an in-person gathering of cybersecurity leaders from Indonesia’s major corporations, leading businesses and key government entities.