Germany Develops Offensive Cyber Capabilities Without A Coherent Strategy

There is a reoccurring debate in German national security and foreign policy whether Germany suffers from “Strategieunfähigkeit”, an inability to develop and implement strategy. 

The historic trauma of two lost World Wars created a pacifist culture that always struggled with formulating national security interests and defining strategy. 

The so-called “culture of reluctance” regarding the use of hard power has bled into Berlin’s thinking about cyber issues, especially as it rushes to develop capabilities without an overarching strategy on how to use them. Until recently, Germany has prioritised defense over offense in cyberspace. 

The Federal Office for Information Security (BSI), Germany’s cybersecurity agency, has a strictly non-military defensive mandate and is a vigilant advocate of strong encryption and full disclosure of zero-day vulnerabilities to vendors. 

Germany’s foreign intelligence agency (BND) has historically had a relatively small cyber espionage budget.

Germany’s defensive posture began to shift in 2015, after the internal network of the German Bundestag was successfully compromised by Russian state-backed operators. That led the country to revise its cybersecurity strategy, issuing a more offensive-minded document in 2016. It called for the development of cyber teams in the intelligence agencies. 

It also might have been a contributing factor to the creation of a specialised agency, called the Central Office for Information Technology in the Security Sphere (ZITiS), to develop innovative techniques to break into encrypted devices, develop exploits and malware for real time interception and accessing data at rest, as well as identify or purchase zero-days to support offensive capabilities.

As Germany rolled out its 2016 strategy, the German military (Bundeswehr) centralised its cyber capacity by consolidating around 14,000 soldiers and IT personnel into a unified cyber command (CIR), loosely modelled on US Cyber Command. CIR wants to achieve full operational capacity by the early 2020s and plans to perform strategic and tactical cyber operations against enemy assets. 
Usage scenarios include disrupting enemy military assets, battlefield support and reconnaissance on adversary IT assets.

Through the new strategy, the meaning of cybersecurity in Germany shifted from strengthening IT-security to improving public safety through the use of offensive cyber operations.

Berlin’s latest move favoring offensive cyber activity is the creation of a cyber innovation agency, akin to the United States’ DARPA, announced in August 2018. Its mandate is to conduct market research and sponsor promising projects with potential value for cyber offense and cybersecurity. 

Over the next five years, the agency is supposed to be equipped with a budget of €200 million (roughly $227 million), 80 percent of which will fund research projects, a substantial sum considering that the entire budget of the BSI is only €120 million per year.

These developments over the last three years point to a build-up of Germany’s offensive cyber capability. Interestingly, these new capabilities have been created without having a clearly defined strategic purpose, a problem that has plagued German national security policy in the past. 

For example, during the 2001 NATO mission in Afghanistan, Bundeswehr capabilities, designed for territorial defense from invasion, was not well adapted or flexible enough for an expeditionary mission.

This mismatch between strategy and capabilities plagues Berlin’s approach to cyberspace. There is currently no strategic debate about what German policymakers want to achieve with its new offensive capabilities. Questions about attribution and appropriate responses have apparently not yet been discussed. 

It is further unclear whether the political will exists to use these offensive capabilities in a time of crisis. For example, if deterring cyberattacks by punishment is a goal, strategy should make clear what means, including non-cyber options, would be most suitable. Is offensive cyber activity more useful in deterring adversarial cyber operations as say indictments or economic sanctions? 

Currently government officials seem to simply assume that cyber capabilities alone have a deterrent effect without taking into consideration the strategic requirements that come with deterrence by punishment, namely credibly holding assets at risk and signaling desired behavior while being willing to face consequences in case of an escalation. 

Will Germany indeed launch a retaliatory cyberattack against adversaries that provoke it and in turn face the potential consequences of entering an escalation cycle with, say, Russia or China?

As Germany tries to flex its muscles in cyberspace, allies and adversaries alike will be left to wonder what to expect absent an overall strategy. 

German policymakers should start a strategic discussion about the country’s role in a contested cyberspace. It needs to explain to its allies how its new offensive tools will work to support multilateral frameworks like NATO, the EU and the UN. 

Germany also needs to signal to hostile cyber actors what behavior it deems inappropriate, and how it will likely respond if certain red-lines are crossed.

Council on Foreign Relations:

You Might Also Read:

Germany Wants A Legal Framework For Cyberwar

« Review Your Cybersecurity Awareness
Cybercrime Is The Biggest Evolving Source Of Crime In The UK »

Infosecurity Europe
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

Directory of Cyber Security Suppliers

Directory of Cyber Security Suppliers

Our Supplier Directory lists 7,000+ specialist cyber security service providers in 128 countries worldwide. IS YOUR ORGANISATION LISTED?

ZenGRC

ZenGRC

ZenGRC (formerly Reciprocity) is a leader in the GRC SaaS landscape, offering robust and intuitive products designed to make compliance straightforward and efficient.

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

The PC Support Group

The PC Support Group

A partnership with The PC Support Group delivers improved productivity, reduced costs and protects your business through exceptional IT, telecoms and cybersecurity services.

North Infosec Testing (North IT)

North Infosec Testing (North IT)

North IT (North Infosec Testing) are an award-winning provider of web, software, and application penetration testing.

CIO

CIO

CIO provides technology and business leaders with insight and analysis on information technology trends

ProPay

ProPay

ProPay provides secure payment solutions for organizations ranging from small businesses to large enterprises requiring complex payment solutions.

ClickDatos

ClickDatos

ClickDatos specializes in consulting, auditing, data protection training, accredited by ISO/IEC 27001 certification.

Malomatia

Malomatia

Malomatia is a leading provider of technology services and solutions in Qatar including information security.

Oneconsult

Oneconsult

Oneconsult provides cyber security services focusing on penetration tests / ethical hacking, ISO 27001 security audits and incident response & IT forensics.

ITRecycla

ITRecycla

ITRecycla are specialists in the protection of sensitive computer data by data destruction, re-marketing of reusable computer equipment, computer recycling and disposing of electronic e-waste.

Expel

Expel

Expel provide transparent managed security services, 24x7 detection, response and resilience.

Sovereign Intelligence

Sovereign Intelligence

Sovereign Intelligence provides automated insight into the relative intensity of hidden Cyber, Brand, and Financial Risks to your company.

Carve Systems

Carve Systems

Carve Systems was founded to bring enterprise level information security, training, and risk management services to organizations of any size and industry.

VLATACOM Institute

VLATACOM Institute

Vlatacom Institute is privately owned accredited research and development institute, system integrator and turn-key solution provider. Areas of expertise include encryption and authentication.

JupiterOne

JupiterOne

JupiterOne is the security product that is changing how organizations manage and secure their software defined assets.

Cybermerc

Cybermerc

Cybermerc's services, training programmes and cyber security solutions are designed to forge collaborations across industry, government and academia, for collective defence of our digital borders.

Atlas Cloud

Atlas Cloud

Atlas Cloud is a UK-wide provider of managed services based in Newcastle. Our ‘research-led’ approach to IT services helps leaders make better decisions about IT for their businesses.

ZILLIONe

ZILLIONe

ZILLIONe is one of Sri Lanka´s top enterprise technology solutions providers.

Daisy Corporate Services

Daisy Corporate Services

Daisy is one of the largest providers of communications and IT solutions across the UK, with a portfolio spanning unified communications, cloud, cyber security and resilience.

VPNBlade

VPNBlade

VPNBlade is your go-to resource for expert reviews and advice on VPN services.