Facebook's Algorithm And Russian Ads

First, the company admitted a “fail” when its advertising algorithm allowed for the targeting of anti-Semitic users.

Then on  Mark Zuckerberg said he was handing over details of more than 3,000 advertisements bought by groups with links to the Kremlin, a move made possible by the advertising algorithms that have made Mr Zuckerberg a multi-billionaire.

Gross misconduct, you might say, but of course you can’t sack the algorithm. And besides, it was only doing what it was told.

“The algorithms are working exactly as they were designed to work,” says Siva Vaidhyanathan, professor of media studies at the University of Virginia.

Which is what makes this controversy so extremely difficult to solve, a crisis that is a direct hit to the core business of the world’s biggest social network and areas of the problem have also hit Google.

Google’s Response

Google has unveiled four measures it will use to tackle the spread of terror-related material online. Among the measures it is deploying will be smarter software that can spot extremist material and greater use of human experts to vet content.

It said terrorism was an "attack on open societies" and tackling its influence was a critical challenge.

It said it had worked hard to remove terrorist content for a long time but acknowledged that more had to be done.

Facebook ‘Fundamentally Flawed’

Facebook didn’t create a huge advertising service by getting contracts with big corporations.

No, its success lies in the little people. The florist who wants to spend a few pounds targeting local teens when the school prom is coming up, or a plumber who has just moved to a new area and needs to drum up work.

Facebook’s wild profits, $3.9bn (£2.9bn) between April and June this year, are due to that automated process. It finds out what users like, it finds advertisers that want to hit those interests, and it marries the two and takes the money. No humans necessary.

But unfortunately, that lack of oversight has left the company open to the kinds of abuse laid bare in ProPublica’s investigation into anti-Semitic targeting.

“Facebook’s algorithms created these categories of anti-Semitic terms,” says Prof Vaidhyanathan, author of Anti-Social Network, a book about Facebook due out later this year. “It’s a sign of how absurd a human-free system can be, and how dangerous a human-free system can be.”

That system will be slightly less human-free in future. In his nine-minute address, a visibly uncomfortable Mark Zuckerberg said his company would be bringing on human beings to help prevent political abuses. The day before, its chief operating officer said more humans would help solve the anti-Semitism issue as well.

“But Facebook can’t hire enough people to sell ads to other people at that scale,” Prof Vaidhyanathan argues.

“It’s the very idea of Facebook that is the problem."

Crazy Idea

Mark Zuckerberg is in choppy, uncharted waters. And as the “leader” (as he likes to sometimes say) of the largest community ever created, he has nowhere to turn for advice or precedent.

This was most evident on 10 November, the day after Donald Trump was elected president of the United States.

When asked if fake news had affected voting, Mr Zuckerberg, quick as a snap, dismissed the suggestion as a “crazy idea”. That turn of phrase has proven to be Mr Zuckerberg’s biggest blunder to date as chief executive.

His naivety about the power of his own company sparked an immense backlash, internally as well as externally, and an investigation into the impact of fake news and other abuses was launched.

On Thursday, the 33-year-old found himself conceding that not only was abuse affecting elections, but that he had done little to stop it happening.

"I wish I could tell you we're going to be able to stop all interference,” he said.

"But that wouldn't be realistic. There will always be bad people in the world, and we can't prevent all governments from all interference.”

A huge turnaround on his position just 10 months ago.

“It seems to me like he basically admits that he has no control over the system he has built,” Prof Vaidhyanathan says.

No wonder, then, that Mr Zuckerberg "had the look of an improbably young leader addressing his people at a moment of crisis”, as the New York Times put it.

Wolves at the Door

This isn’t the first time Facebook’s reliance on machines has landed it in trouble, and it would be totally unfair to characterise this as a problem just affecting Mr Zuckerberg’s firm.

Recently, a Channel Four investigation revealed that Amazon’s algorithm would helpfully suggest the components you needed to make a homemade bomb based on what other customers also bought.

Instances like that, and others, such as advertising funding terrorist material, has meant the political mood in the US taken a sharp turn: Big Tech’s algorithms are out of control.

At least two high-profile US senators are drumming up support for a new bill that would force social networks with a user base greater than one million to adhere to new transparency guidelines around campaign ads.

Mr Zuckerberg’s statement on Thursday 21st September, an earnest pledge to do better, is being seen as a way to keep the regulation wolves from the door. He, and all the other tech CEOs, would much prefer to deal with this his own way.

But Prof Vaidhyanathan warns he might not get that luxury, and might not find much in the way of sympathy or patience, either.

“All of these problems are the result of the fact Zuckerberg has created and profited from a system that has grown to encompass the world… and harvest information from more than two billion people."

BBC:      BBC

You Might Also Read: 

Facebook To Give Congress Thousands Of Election Ads Bought By Russians:

Bashing Facebook Is Not The Answer To Curbing Russian Influence Operations:
 

« Ransomware Analysis Suggests A Bleak Future
A Major UK Cyber Attack Will Happen Soon »

Infosecurity Europe
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

TÜV SÜD Academy UK

TÜV SÜD Academy UK

TÜV SÜD offers expert-led cybersecurity training to help organisations safeguard their operations and data.

Resecurity

Resecurity

Resecurity is a cybersecurity company that delivers a unified platform for endpoint protection, risk management, and cyber threat intelligence.

Infosecurity Europe, 3-5 June 2025, ExCel London

Infosecurity Europe, 3-5 June 2025, ExCel London

This year, Infosecurity Europe marks 30 years of bringing the global cybersecurity community together to further our joint mission of Building a Safer Cyber World.

Clayden Law

Clayden Law

Clayden Law advise global businesses that buy and sell technology products and services. We are experts in information technology, data privacy and cybersecurity law.

Assured Data Protection

Assured Data Protection

Assured Data Protection specialises in data protection and disaster recovery services for large SME and enterprise organisations.

Pradeo

Pradeo

Pradeo Security offers a complete, automatic and seamless protection to mobile devices and applications, aligned with your organization security policy while preserving business agility.

Trustlook

Trustlook

Trustlook's SECUREai engine delivers the performance and scalability needed to provide total threat protection against malware and other forms of attack.

Acuant

Acuant

Acuant is a leading global provider of identity verification, regulatory compliance (AML/KYC) and digital identity solutions.

Search Guard

Search Guard

Search Guard® is an Open Source security suite for #Elasticsearch and the entire #ELK stack that offers encryption, authentication, authorization, audit logging and multi tenancy.

Innova

Innova

Innova is Turkey's leading IT solutions company, providing platform independent solutions to organizations in telecommunication, finance, production, public and service sectors.

FraudWatch International

FraudWatch International

FraudWatch has been protecting client brands around the world since 2003, and are the leaders in online brand protection from phishing, malware, social media and mobile apps impersonation.

DDOS-Guard

DDOS-Guard

DDoS-GUARD is one of the leading service providers on the global DDoS protection and content delivery markets.

DataDog

DataDog

DataDog provides Cloud-native Security Monitoring. Real-time threat detection across your applications, network, and infrastructure.

ANSEC IA

ANSEC IA

ANSEC is a consultancy practice providing independent Information Assurance and IT Security focussed services to customers throughout the UK, Ireland and internationally.

InferSight

InferSight

InferSight can help you design an architecture that takes into account security, performance, availability, functionality, resiliency and future capacity to avoid technological lock in and limitations

Cyber Defense Networking Solutions (CDNS)

Cyber Defense Networking Solutions (CDNS)

CDNS is a global network infrastructure provider whose platforms are engineered for security, optimized for speed and designed for resiliency.

Cyber Crucible

Cyber Crucible

Cyber Crucible is a cybersecurity Software as a Service company definitively removing the risk of data extortion from customer environments.

Questex Asia Total Security Conference

Questex Asia Total Security Conference

Questex Asia’s Total Security Conferences is one of the industry’s most prestigious and engaging forums for the region's top information security leaders and business decision-makers.

coc00n

coc00n

coc00n secures the devices of high-value and high-interest individuals against cyber attacks.

TENEX

TENEX

TENEX is a cybersecurity company leveraging advanced artificial intelligence and human expertise to transform enterprise security.