Facebook Users To Rank The News They Trust

Facebook has unveiled major changes recently to the News Feed of its 2 billion users, announcing it will rank news organisations by credibility based on user feedback and diminish its role as an arbiter of the news people see.

The move comes after the company endured harsh criticism for allowing disinformation to spread on its social network and for favoring liberal outlets over conservative ones. 

In a blog post accompanying the announcement, chief executive Mark Zuckerberg wrote Facebook is not “comfortable” deciding which news sources are the most trustworthy in a “world with so much division." "We decided that having the community determine which sources are broadly trusted would be most objective," he wrote.

The new trust rankings will emerge from surveys the company is conducting. "Broadly trusted" outlets that are affirmed by a significant cross-section of users may see a boost in readership, while less known organisations or start-ups receiving poor ratings could see their web traffic decline significantly on the social network. 

The company's changes include an effort to boost the content of local news outlets, which have suffered sizable subscription and readership declines as news consumption migrated online.

The changes follow another major News Feed redesign, announced last week, in which Facebook said users would begin to see less content from news organisations and brands in favor of "meaningful" posts from friends and family. Currently, 5 percent of Facebook posts are generated by news organisations; that number is expected to drop to 4 percent after the redesign, Zuckerberg said.

Facebook and other Silicon Valley giants are grappling with their roles as dominant distributors of information in an era of foreign manipulation of social media platforms and dwindling revenues for many media outlets. Google has announced it would cancel a two-month-old experiment, called Knowledge Panel, that informed its users that a news article had been disputed by independent fact-checking organisations. Conservatives had complained the feature unfairly targeted a right-leaning outlet.

More than two-thirds of Americans now get some of their news from social media, according to Pew Research Center. That shift has empowered Facebook and Google, putting them in an uncomfortable position of deciding what news they should distribute to their global audiences. But it also has led to questions about whether these corporations should be considered media companies.

Daniel Kreiss, a professor at the school of media and journalism at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, said Facebook was now “offloading” its responsibilities for accuracy and quality onto its users. "Just by putting things out to a vote in terms of what the community would find trustworthy undermines the role for any serious institutionalized process to determine what’s quality and what’s not,” he said.

Facebook has also been the target of accusations of political partisanship. In the summer of 2016, Facebook was charged with excluding conservative media outlets from Trending Topics, a list of top stories that runs on the upper right hand side of Facebook pages. After conducting an investigation, the company discovered it had left the ranking decisions up to low-level contractors.

Ultimately, Zuckerberg ended up inviting conservative media figures to Facebook headquarters in Menlo Park to apologise for the misunderstanding.

He also made the decision to fire the contractors who served as editors of Trending Topics, opting instead for a more technological approach. But outsourcing the decision to software algorithms led to further criticism that the social network had become vulnerable to bad actors seeking to spread disinformation.

The issue exploded during the presidential campaign, as false content, such as the Pope endorsing Trump for president, generated more traffic than stories from mainstream news outlets, and investigators discovered that Russian operatives were using the social network to spread disinformation and divisive content.

Jay Rosen, a journalism professor at New York University, said that Facebook learned the wrong lesson from Trending Topics, which was to try to avoid politics at all costs. “One of the things that can happen if you are determined to avoid politics at all costs is you are driven to illusory solutions,” he said. “I don’t think there is any alternative to using your judgement. But Facebook is convinced that there is. This idea that they can avoid judgement is part of their problem.” Surveys of media credibility have varied widely over the years, partly because political persuasion appears to shape how Americans view news organisations. 

A poll conducted last year by the Missouri School of Journalism found Buzzfeed and Breitbart to be among the least credible sources, while The Economist and "public television" was the most trusted.

Facebook revealed few details about how it is conducting its trust surveys, declining to share copies with The Washington Post. But Zuckerberg wrote that the decision came after substantial internal debate. "The hard question we've struggled with is how to decide what news sources are broadly trusted," Zuckerberg wrote. "We could try to make that decision ourselves, but that's not something we're comfortable with. We considered asking outside experts, which would take the decision out of our hands but would likely not solve the objectivity problem. Or we could ask you, the community, and have your feedback determine the ranking."

Facebook's previous efforts to ask its users to determine the accuracy of news have not always turned out well. Last year, the company launched a feature that allowed users to flag news stories they felt were inaccurate. The experiment was shuttered after a nine months.

Some experts wondered whether Facebook's latest effort could be gamed. Renee DiResta, head of public policy at the non-profit organisation Data for Democracy, applauded efforts by technology companies to come up with innovative ways to measure quality and weed out disinformation. But she raised concerns over whether Facebook's survey could be manipulated, for example, if certain media organisations encouraged their users to flood the surveys with identical responses.
"This seems like a positive step toward improving the news environment on Facebook," Diresta said. "That said, the potential downside is that the survey approach unfairly penalises emerging publications."

Washington Post

You Might Also Read: 

Fake News & Botnets: Russia Has Weaponised The Web:

Solutions To Combat ‘Fake News’:

Algorithms: An Unseen Influence On The UK Election:

« Insiders Are Behind Most Business Cybersecurity Incidents
Army Chief Urges UK To Increase Cyber Defence & Attack Capabilities »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

The PC Support Group

The PC Support Group

A partnership with The PC Support Group delivers improved productivity, reduced costs and protects your business through exceptional IT, telecoms and cybersecurity services.

XYPRO Technology

XYPRO Technology

XYPRO is the market leader in HPE Non-Stop Security, Risk Management and Compliance.

CSI Consulting Services

CSI Consulting Services

Get Advice From The Experts: * Training * Penetration Testing * Data Governance * GDPR Compliance. Connecting you to the best in the business.

IT Governance

IT Governance

IT Governance is a leading global provider of information security solutions. Download our free guide and find out how ISO 27001 can help protect your organisation's information.

securitycurrent

securitycurrent

Security Current's proprietary content and events provide insight, actionable advice and analysis giving executives the latest information to make knowledgeable decisions.

Lawley Insurance

Lawley Insurance

Lawley is a full-service, independent insurance agency. Specialty insurance products include Cyber Security.

Array Networks

Array Networks

Array Networks, the network functions platform company, develops purpose-built systems for hosting virtual networking and security functions with guaranteed performance.

ID Agent

ID Agent

ID Agent provides a comprehensive set of threat intelligence and identity monitoring solutions.

SIGA

SIGA

SIGA provides cyber security solutions for Industrial Control Systems SCADA systems used in critical infrastructures and industrial processes.

Cyber Security Audit Corp (C3SA)

Cyber Security Audit Corp (C3SA)

C3SA specializes in architecting, operating, managing and improving defensible and resilient IT infrastructures for Canada's public and private sectors.

CSIRT-CY

CSIRT-CY

CSIRT-CY is the National Computer Security Incident Response Team for Cyprus.

ACM-CCAS

ACM-CCAS

ACM is a UKAS-accredited certification body helping businesses around the world perform to a higher standard. Our certifications include ISO 27001 and ISO 22301.

Indeed

Indeed

Indeed is a worldwide employment-related search engine for job listings covering job types in all industries, including cybersecurity.

Optimum Speciality Risks

Optimum Speciality Risks

Optimum Speciality Risks are an experienced team of cyber insurance experts, backed by Lloyds of London.

Cyber Polygon

Cyber Polygon

Cyber Polygon is an annual online exercise which connects various global organisations to train their competencies and exchange best practices.

Riskonnect

Riskonnect

Riskonnect technology empowers organizations with the ability to anticipate, manage, and respond in real-time to strategic, operational, and digital risks across the extended enterprise.

Modern Networks

Modern Networks

Modern Networks is a leading provider of IT managed services to the UK’s commercial property sector and medium sized enterprises.

Prompt Security

Prompt Security

Prompt Security provides an LLM agnostic approach to ensure security, data privacy and safety across all aspects of Generative AI.

UltraViolet Cyber

UltraViolet Cyber

UltraViolet is an industry leading tech-enabled managed security services company.

Verosint

Verosint

Verosint (formerly 443ID) provides real-time account fraud prevention that reveals fraudsters hiding in user accounts and proactively blocks them before their attacks can cause harm.

ClearSale (CLSA3)

ClearSale (CLSA3)

Clearsale’s innovative fraud solutions combine advanced technology with a passionate team of seasoned experts that understand every client’s unique needs.