Facebook & Google Are Killing Newspapers

The first newspapers were printed in the 17th century, and the methods of both their creation (movable type) and their distribution (on paper) remained broadly unchanged for three centuries.

When Marxism Today’s published its New Times issue in 1988, that system was unravelling. Computers had arrived and the print unions’ insistence on sharply delineated workplace roles was under threat.

This had already led to the Wapping dispute of 1986, in which Rupert Murdoch moved his newspapers to new headquarters to break the collective power of the printers. It took 13 months and 1,262 arrests, but it ended with thousands of men in effect accepting that their skills were obsolete.

That trend has merely continued.

Today’s journalism students are encouraged to become jacks of all trades, they learn how to make videos, record podcasts and use databases, they master Photoshop, they understand social media and, yes, they even write and edit stories.

On one level, the world of news now seems gloriously open: anyone can start a blog, anyone can publish on the Huffington Post (if you don’t mind not being paid) or Medium, and anyone can build a following on Twitter or Facebook. But there are new barriers to entry.

Local newspapers, once the training ground for young reporters, are dying out: there has been a net loss of 198 since 2005, according to the Press Gazette. Their classified adverts have gone online or gone altogether, and some of those titles that remain are consolidated into remote industrial parks, far from the communities they serve. So there is less reporting of court cases and of the petty corruption of councillors (Private Eye’s Rotten Boroughs, which still covers that ground, is never short of material).

In place of independent papers are glossy PR puffs produced by councils. In December, the editor of the Hackney Citizen complained that the local authority was producing its own fortnightly freesheet, Hackney Today. The latter sells advertising space, making it a direct competitor to independent newspapers, and the council pays for 108,000 copies to be printed by Trinity Mirror and distributed to households every fortnight. It is produced by a press office.

National newspapers are also struggling. Print circulations are falling and the returns on display advertising online can be pitiful.

Most online adverts are “programmatic”: sold in real-time auctions on a CPM (cost per mille, or thousand clicks) basis. Users hate them for slowing page loads or interrupting their reading. Unsurprisingly, the use of ad-blocking software has risen steadily.

The industry has tried to fight back by expanding the types of adverts it sells. That is why everyone became so excited about video a few years ago: publishers could place an un-skippable advert before a video clip and charge pounds, not pennies, using CPM.

The Internet-only news organisation BuzzFeed had another strategy: from the start, it didn’t sell display advertising, only “native ads”: what used to be called advertorial.

The theory was that users might be irritated by display ads but they wouldn’t object to a pet-food brand sponsoring a heart-warming video about life with a pet. In at least one case, this paid off handsomely, BuzzFeed’s 2015 collaboration with Purina led to a video called Puppyhood, which racked up four million views in two weeks. The challenge is to repeat that winning formula again and again.

Other publishers tried the start-up mantra: build it, scale it fast, hope the revenues turn up at some point. Medium, a cleanly designed blogging platform, was launched by the Twitter co-founder Ev Williams in 2012 and attracted big-name publications and writers.

But on 4 January Williams announced that he was “renewing Medium’s focus” by cutting a third of its staff, because it was not financially sustainable. “It’s clear that the broken system is ad-driven media on the Internet,” he wrote.

“The vast majority of articles, video and other ‘content’ we all consume on a daily basis is paid for, directly or indirectly, by corporations who are funding it in order to advance their goals. And it is measured, amplified and rewarded based on its ability to do that.”

If journalism is to survive, it needs either to cut costs (read: sack journalists), or build revenues. Hence the proliferation of sidelines: conferences, round-tables, business-to-business operations, events, sponsored supplements and the rest. Some companies are trying a more direct approach. The heavily loss-making Guardian is investing in a membership scheme, and the radical US magazine Mother Jones has a pledge to fund in-depth reporting. (Individual journalists are trying this, too: The Patreon website offers readers a chance to fund writers directly, at a set cost per month or per piece.)

Of course, someone is making money out of the great flowering of content on the web. Facebook has 1.86 billion monthly users, and in the third quarter of 2016 its net income was $2.38bn, up from $896m a year earlier. Along with Google, it controls two-thirds of the online advertising market.

“Facebook is the new town hall,” Mark Zuckerberg told investors. Unfortunately for him, that role in public life is what made Facebook the focus of the row about “fake news” after the US election. For millions of people, Facebook is where they get their news; its editorial decisions and inbuilt biases shape our common understanding of reality.

You might not have to get your words past the print unions any more, but you do have to pander to what Facebook’s and Google’s guiding algorithms deem important. Zuckerberg has more power than anyone who bought ink by the barrel ever did.

New Statesman

Hidden In Plain Site: Paedophiles Use Facebook Groups:

Facebook To Introduce Fake News Tools:

 

« Malvertising Targets Your Online Users
Google To Break Pirates Over Music Searches »

Infosecurity Europe
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

CSI Consulting Services

CSI Consulting Services

Get Advice From The Experts: * Training * Penetration Testing * Data Governance * GDPR Compliance. Connecting you to the best in the business.

Resecurity

Resecurity

Resecurity is a cybersecurity company that delivers a unified platform for endpoint protection, risk management, and cyber threat intelligence.

Infosecurity Europe, 3-5 June 2025, ExCel London

Infosecurity Europe, 3-5 June 2025, ExCel London

This year, Infosecurity Europe marks 30 years of bringing the global cybersecurity community together to further our joint mission of Building a Safer Cyber World.

Directory of Cyber Security Suppliers

Directory of Cyber Security Suppliers

Our Supplier Directory lists 7,000+ specialist cyber security service providers in 128 countries worldwide. IS YOUR ORGANISATION LISTED?

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

Messageware

Messageware

Messageware is the market leader in securing, enhancing, and customizing Microsoft Exchange and Outlook Web App.

OIC-CERT

OIC-CERT

OIC-CERT is the Computer Emergency Response Team for Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) member countries.

Centre for Cyber Security (CFCS) - Denmark

Centre for Cyber Security (CFCS) - Denmark

The Centre for Cyber Security is the Danish national IT security authority, Network Security Service and Centre for Excellence within cyber security.

Cyber Aware

Cyber Aware

Cyber Aware aims to drive behaviour change amongst small businesses and individuals, so that they adopt simple secure online behaviours.

CommuniTake

CommuniTake

CommuniTake builds security, enablement, and management solutions to provide people and organizations with better, and more secure mobile device use.

Cologix

Cologix

Cologix provides reliable, secure, scalable data center and interconnection solutions from 24 prime interconnection locations across 9 strategic North American edge markets.

ITC Secure Networking

ITC Secure Networking

ITC are a leading cloud-based MSSP delivering service innovation in cyber security analytics & cloud technology.

Cyber Security Malta

Cyber Security Malta

Cyber Security Malta is part of Malta's National Cyber Security Strategy which aims to combat cybercrime, strengthen national cyber defence and provide cyber security awareness and education.

CryptoSec.info

CryptoSec.info

CryptoSec.info is a web resource focused on educating the beginners in the cryptocurrency space on how to properly secure their online assets from hackers and scammers.

Chicago Quantum Exchange (CQE)

Chicago Quantum Exchange (CQE)

Chicago Quantum Exchange is an intellectual hub and community of researchers with the common goal of advancing academic and industrial efforts in the science and engineering of quantum information.

UK Cyber Security Association (UKCSA)

UK Cyber Security Association (UKCSA)

The UK Cyber Security Association (UKCSA) is a membership organisation for individuals and organisations who actively work in the cyber security industry.

Zeva

Zeva

Zeva solves complex identity and encryption challenges for the federal government and corporations around the globe.

Mage Data

Mage Data

Mage (formerly Mentis Software) is a leading solutions provider for data security and data privacy software for global enterprises.

North Green Security

North Green Security

North Green Security is a UK-based cyber security training and consultancy company.

Data Computer Services

Data Computer Services

Data Computer Services provides professional tailored IT Support and IT Services for businesses throughout Edinburgh and the Lothians.

Cyabra

Cyabra

Cyabra is leading the fight against disinformation. Our AI shields companies and the public sector by uncovering malicious actors, bot networks, and GenAI content.