Ethics of Drones, Remote Weapons and Robots

Remote weapons have been around at least since the bow and arrow, and were taken to new levels by missiles, artillery and aerial bombing.

However, the advent of pilotless drones able to stay in the air for long periods, and to be directed from thousands of miles away, and of precision- guided long-range missiles, has raised new questions about the boundaries between peace and war, and the nature of future conflicts.

Their advantages include the lack of direct risk to the operators, the ability to target relatively precisely and to have greater certainty about the identification of targets, and the opportunity to strike targets anywhere in the world without having boots on the ground.

The rapid elimination of known and apparently dangerous enemies has helped western opinion to turn a blind eye to the risks associated with such strikes. There are also precious few acceptable alternative means of action in large areas of ungovernable space. The long shadow of Iraq means little enthusiasm for sacrificing soldiers' lives to secure deserts.

However, the sense of action without direct consequences for the power using such weapons is seen by some as an illusion. The operators themselves may still suffer psychological stress from killing.

Moreover, however precise modern remote weapons may be in theory, the risk of associated civilian casualties is always present. Faulty intelligence can lead to serious mistakes. Even a completely accurate strike can set up a strong political reaction.

The resulting resentment by local communities may be toxic, and act as a recruiting sergeant for others supporting the cause of those hit, or seeking revenge. The government of the country on whose territory attacks are conducted by a third party can suffer political consequences for condoning or at least not preventing them (for example Pakistan).

More broadly, remote attacks may become a substitute for the kind of political strategy which alone can defeat over time groups using terrorist tactics.

The use of such weapons against individuals or groups in territories which have not been declared combat zones also raises difficult legal and ethical questions.

Can such attacks be justified under international law, especially when they are preventive in nature? Are the views of the government in control of such territories of no relevance? Does it make a difference if nationals of the country using the weapons are targeted in the kind of extra-judicial killing which would not be contemplated or condoned at home? How would countries using such weapons respond if another power used them to eliminate those considered enemies on their own territories, as the technology spreads and becomes cheaper? Are stricter controls needed on the sale of such technology?

Even more difficult long-term questions arise over weapons systems which could operate and kill autonomously, with no specific human decision involved. What are the moral and political issues if miniaturisation of weapons and guidance systems eventually allows delivery of bullet size payloads to kill single individuals at will?

Armed drones are designed for lethal action, but as terrorists have shown many times, machines of any kind can be hijacked or adapted to become weapons capable of inflicting significant casualties and severe damage on societies.

Commercial drones now being considered for many purposes would create new opportunities for this kind of attack. Vehicles and robots are increasingly operated by software which opens up the prospect of remote hijacking or ransom demands through offensive cyber-attacks.

Moreover, what would happen if robots or drones, or autonomous cars, had to choose between greater and lesser evils: crashing into a school or into a hospital for example. Who would bear the responsibility for the choice?

image: California Air National Guard unit is primarily involved in Predator unmanned aerial vehicle missions

Ditchley:

Technology, Multilateralism, War and Peace:

Tanks To Have Remote-Control:             A New Autonomous Tactical Drone:

Drone-Visuality: The Psychology Of Killing:

 

 

« Robots Will Repair Satellites In Space
Data Breaches Attack All Parts Of A Business »

ManageEngine
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Check Point

Directory of Suppliers

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

Authentic8

Authentic8

Authentic8 transforms how organizations secure and control the use of the web with Silo, its patented cloud browser.

Practice Labs

Practice Labs

Practice Labs is an IT competency hub, where live-lab environments give access to real equipment for hands-on practice of essential cybersecurity skills.

Tines

Tines

The Tines security automation platform helps security teams automate manual tasks, making them more effective and efficient.

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

JumpCloud

JumpCloud

JumpCloud's Directory-as-a-Service (DaaS) is the single point of authority to authenticate, authorize, and manage the identities of a business’s employees and the systems and IT resources they need.

Happiest Minds Technologies

Happiest Minds Technologies

Happiest Minds offers domain centric solutions in IT Services, Product Engineering, Infrastructure Management and Security.

Logscape

Logscape

Logscape provides a big data analytical tool for log file analysis and operational analytics.

GOVCERT.lu

GOVCERT.lu

GOVCERT.lu is responsible for the treatment of all computer related incidents jeopardising the information systems of the government and defined critical infrastructure operators in Luxembourg.

SevenShift

SevenShift

SevenShift is a security consulting firm with a wealth of experience in the worlds of Cybersecurity and Internet of Things (IoT).

National Accreditation Agency of Ukraine (NAAU)

National Accreditation Agency of Ukraine (NAAU)

NAAU is the national accreditation body for Ukraine. The directory of members provides details of organisations offering certification services for ISO 27001.

SEEK

SEEK

SEEK create world-class technology solutions to address the needs of job seekers and hirers across multiple sectors including cybersecurity.

ChainSecurity

ChainSecurity

ChainSecurity provides products and services for securing smart contracts and blockchain protocols and conducts R&D in the areas of security, program analysis, and machine learning.

Inceptus

Inceptus

Inceptus is a next generation Managed Security Service Provider (MSSP). We are dedicated to keeping our customers safe, secure and protected while doing business on the Internet.

Key Cyber Solutions

Key Cyber Solutions

Key Cyber is an IT consulting firm that specializes in agile software development services, program management and infrastructure services, cyber security and cloud and managed services.

Red River

Red River

Red River is a technology transformation company, bringing 25 years of experience and mission-critical expertise in analytics, cloud, collaboration, mobility, networking and security solutions.

MTI

MTI

MTI is a solutions and service provider, specialising in data & cyber security, datacentre modernisation, modern workplace, IT managed services and IT transformation services.

QAlified

QAlified

QAlified offer independent testing and quality assurance services for software projects including security testing.

Curatrix Technologies

Curatrix Technologies

Curatrix Technologies is a Managed IT Service provider based in Hampshire, UK, providing high quality and reliable Managed IT Services since 2015.

Wired Assurance

Wired Assurance

Wired Assurance is a testing and assurance company, specialized in software applications and blockchain smart contracts.

Information Security Society of Africa – Nigeria (ISSAN)

Information Security Society of Africa – Nigeria (ISSAN)

The Information Security Society of Africa – Nigeria (ISSAN) is a not-for-profit organization dedicated to the protection of Nigeria’s cyberspace.