Equifax Executives Resign Without Charge

After an estimated 143 million Americans' personal information was accessed by hackers targeting Equifax Inc., its chief information officer and chief security officer are stepping down.

Equifax said recently that Chief Information Officer David Webb and Chief Security Officer Susan Mauldin had departed. They've been replaced by current international IT chief Mark Rohrwasser as interim chief information officer and Russ Ayres, a vice president in Equifax's IT operation, as interim chief security officer.

Background

Picture a factory gushing pollution into a nearby waterway. Now, imagine the factory’s executives knew a giant leak was likely but did nothing to prevent it. Finally, think of those same executives waiting weeks to warn anyone of the spill, and then bungling the clean-up efforts, after first trying to profit from them.

If all this happened, the company responsible would face criminal fines and its executives would likely end up in prison.

That's why Equifax and its leadership team can count themselves lucky they’re in the data business. Even though their incompetence and foot-dragging compromised the security of over 140 million Americans, they're beyond the reach of criminal law.

Equifax may face class action suits and a FTC investigation, but the worst that can happen to individual executives is they will have to resign (two already have), probably with a tidy payout on their way out.

Executives should Catch-Up

It doesn’t have to be this way. According to Jesse Eisinger, author of a recent book about white collar crime, there’s ample precedent for corporate executives going to jail for negligence. In an interview with Fortune, Eisinger pointed to a rule called the “responsible corporate officer” doctrine, which prosecutors can use to charge executives whose lack of oversight endangers the public welfare.

The catch, though, is the “responsible officer” rule has only been deployed in cases involving food, drugs or the environment. Examples include executives who received criminal penalties over mislabeled oxycontin shipments, and whose negligence led to salmonella-tainted eggs.

According to David Frulla, a regulatory lawyer at Kelley Drye, prosecutors can only bring responsible officer charges in respect to a specific law, such as the FDCA, that provides criminal penalties for violators. They can't simply charge Equifax executives for general incompetence.

Right now, there's no such federal law when it comes to personal data. But there probably should be given the clear public harm that occurs after major data breaches, including the Equifax hack, which has been widely described as the worst in history.

In the case of Equifax, hackers plundered not only the name and Social Security numbers of more than 100 million people but, in many cases, their phone numbers and home addresses (past and present) as well. Those who paid for Equifax’s credit monitoring service also had their credit card information stolen.

All of that data is already for sale in dark corners of the Internet, and is going to lead to a spate of scams and identity thefts that will haunt people for years. Meanwhile, the website Equifax set up to help consumers find out if they had been breached has also been found vulnerable to hackers, and critics are accusing the company of using the breach to tout paid ID Theft products. Some sort of punishment is clearly in order.

Many people in cyber-security circles caution that shaming corporate hacking victims is not a good idea because companies will be less forthcoming about data breaches. This reasoning is not convincing in the case of Equifax, however. The company’s whole business revolves around personal data, their failure to protect it should mean public disgrace.

Equifax executives behaved with brazen carelessness, storing the data in a way that made it easy for hackers to try and steal it. Eventually, the hackers broke in because Equifax failed to update a critical piece of software, even though a patch had been available for months.

It’s poor practice, these days, for consumers not to update the software on their home devices. For a giant corporation to ignore software updates is simply reckless, and even more so when that corporation’s core business involves consumer data.

Equifax executives will nonetheless face no legal consequences for this debacle (other than three officers who could face charges for selling stock before the breach was disclosed). The US right now just doesn’t have the laws to hold them accountable. Meanwhile, CEO Richard Smith will probably keep the $68.9 million he's made from selling the company's shares since 2016.

This could change, however, if US Senators Orrin Hatch and Ron Wyden are serious about getting to the bottom of the Equinox breach. Their proposed investigation should seek to identify who at Equifax was responsible for the breach, and also propose ways for this not to happen again.

According to Sam Buell, who teaches corporate criminal law at Duke University School of Law, scandals like the Equifax affair often trigger public conversations that lead to new regulatory oversight.

"There's a good argument this is one of those industries where there’s a need for a higher standard or the pain of criminal punishment. When you’re in a business that has the potential to do this scale of harm, you have a duty of care for your product that could be covered by criminal law."

Consumers would no doubt agree. The time is rapidly coming when executives should be held to the same standard for protecting personal data as they do for the environment or the food supply.

Fortune:      The Street:

You MIght Also Read:

Disastrous Equifax Breach Exposes 44% Of The US Population:

Threat Lessons from Sony and Anthem:

 

« Transforming Your Database
Preventing The Hacked AI Apocalypse »

Infosecurity Europe
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

CYRIN

CYRIN

CYRIN® Cyber Range. Real Tools, Real Attacks, Real Scenarios. See why leading educational institutions and companies in the U.S. have begun to adopt the CYRIN® system.

LockLizard

LockLizard

Locklizard provides PDF DRM software that protects PDF documents from unauthorized access and misuse. Share and sell documents securely - prevent document leakage, sharing and piracy.

The PC Support Group

The PC Support Group

A partnership with The PC Support Group delivers improved productivity, reduced costs and protects your business through exceptional IT, telecoms and cybersecurity services.

Alvacomm

Alvacomm

Alvacomm offers holistic VIP cybersecurity services, providing comprehensive protection against cyber threats. Our solutions include risk assessment, threat detection, incident response.

TÜV SÜD Academy UK

TÜV SÜD Academy UK

TÜV SÜD offers expert-led cybersecurity training to help organisations safeguard their operations and data.

Irish Reporting & Information Security Service (IRISS)

Irish Reporting & Information Security Service (IRISS)

IRISS-CERT is Ireland's first CSIRT (Computer Security Incident Response Team) to provide services to all users within Ireland.

PortSwigger

PortSwigger

PortSwigger's Burp Suite is an integrated platform for performing security testing of web applications.

MixMode

MixMode

MixMode's PacketSled platform delivers network monitoring, deep forensic analysis and incident response.

VNCERT

VNCERT

VNCERT is the national Computer Emergency Response Team for Vietnam.

vdiscovery

vdiscovery

vdiscovery is a provider of proprietary and best-in-breed solutions in computer forensics, document review, and electronic discovery.

Eclypsium

Eclypsium

Eclypsium protects organizations from the foundation of their computing infrastructure upward, controlling the risk and stopping threats inside firmware of laptops, servers, and networks.

InterGuard

InterGuard

As the pioneer for Unified Insider Threat Prevention and productivity monitoring tools, InterGuard offers on premise and SaaS-based services that are easily available and affordable.

oneclick

oneclick

oneclick is a central access and distribution platform in the cloud, enabling the management of the entire technology stack for application provisioning.

Foundries.io

Foundries.io

Foundries.io have built a secure, open source platform for the world's connected devices, and a cloud service to configure this to any hardware and any cloud.

Sixteenth Air Force (Air Forces Cyber)

Sixteenth Air Force (Air Forces Cyber)

Air Forces Cyber provides mission integration of Information Warfare at operational and tactical levels, creating dilemmas for adversaries in competition and, if necessary, future conflicts.

McDonald Hopkins

McDonald Hopkins

McDonald Hopkins is a business advisory and advocacy law firm. We focus on insightful legal solutions that help our clients strategically plan for an increasingly competitive future.

Valimail

Valimail

Valimail delivers the only complete, cloud-native platform for validating and authenticating sender identity to stop phishing, protect and amplify brands, and ensure compliance.

Banyax

Banyax

Banyax provides 24×7 real-time Cyber Defense Center Services using the latest technology tools to provide state-of-the-art defense.

Insight Enterprises

Insight Enterprises

Insight is a leading solutions integrator, helping you navigate today’s ever-changing business environment with teams of technical experts and decades of industry experience.

Techmentum

Techmentum

At Techmentum, our mission is to utilize technology to help companies succeed. Our expertise includes fully managed IT services, cybersecurity, cloud, and custom technology solutions.

Reken

Reken

Reken are building a new type of AI platform and products to protect against generative AI threats.