Drones: The Looming Threat

Unmanned aircraft, otherwise known as drones, are becoming common. Many are familiar with America’s use of armed drones in Pakistan, Yemen and elsewhere but drones are also increasingly being used by other parts of government, by companies and individuals. 

Drones can be far cheaper to operate than anything that requires an on-board pilot, and they are handy for making maps and taking pictures and videos. The FBI uses a small fleet of drones for law-enforcement surveillance. Customs and Border Patrol uses them to monitor the American border with Mexico. Commercial drones are now regularly used for real-estate photography and to monitor oil and gas pipelines, among many other applications.

The proliferation of drones, which include both small fixed-wing aircraft and small rotorcraft with multiple propellers, raises some vexing public-policy questions. 

At issue is also the way some drones can loiter overhead for long stretches, engaging in what is called “persistent surveillance”. As drones—and other airborne surveillance platforms, such as circling manned aircraft and lighter-than-air craft—become cheaper and more effective, persistent aerial surveillance could become the norm, and no privacy or transparency measures currently exist in the law. 

The current state of the law, both legislation and court decisions, is poorly suited to deal with persistent surveillance. This is because privacy law is tailored to questions of whether one is in public, an open field, or in a space where one has a “reasonable expectation of privacy”. The Supreme Court has, at times, expanded such spaces, for instance finding in 1967 that the FBI cannot eavesdrop on conversations in telephone booths without a warrant. But in this era of “big data”, the line between public and private can no longer be delimited by physical boundaries.

Complicating matters, there is no clear line between episodic surveillance, a snapshot, and persistent surveillance even though the effects are profoundly different. It’s the difference between a snapshot and an overhead video that shows the comings and goings of everybody in a city over the course of a week. In such a video, a so-called “pattern-of-life” emerges. Any still frame from the video might be a defensible incursion on privacy, yet the whole video is something more than the sum of these parts.

Discussions about privacy often involve the question of why it is something worth protecting. People tend to invoke Louis Brandeis and Samuel Warren’s definition of privacy in 1890 as the “right to be let alone”. So persistent surveillance, whether through monitoring internet browsing habits or from a drone overhead, undermines the formation of liberal individuals in the way that an over-reliance on GPS undermines the formation of a sense of direction. 

It is worth noting that not all persistent drones are a threat to privacy, NASA’s Global Hawk Earth science missions, for instance, are exactly what they claim to be: new tools for studying hurricanes and other natural phenomena. But it is essential that these questions about drones and privacy are being asked now. 

Economist:

 

« Connected Cars: Risks for Automated Vehicles.
You Can Tell Which Emails are Being Tracked. »

ManageEngine
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Check Point

Directory of Suppliers

IT Governance

IT Governance

IT Governance is a leading global provider of information security solutions. Download our free guide and find out how ISO 27001 can help protect your organisation's information.

Clayden Law

Clayden Law

Clayden Law advise global businesses that buy and sell technology products and services. We are experts in information technology, data privacy and cybersecurity law.

CSI Consulting Services

CSI Consulting Services

Get Advice From The Experts: * Training * Penetration Testing * Data Governance * GDPR Compliance. Connecting you to the best in the business.

TÜV SÜD Academy UK

TÜV SÜD Academy UK

TÜV SÜD offers expert-led cybersecurity training to help organisations safeguard their operations and data.

LockLizard

LockLizard

Locklizard provides PDF DRM software that protects PDF documents from unauthorized access and misuse. Share and sell documents securely - prevent document leakage, sharing and piracy.

SI-CERT

SI-CERT

SI-CERT (Slovenian Computer Emergency Response Team) is the national cyber scurity incident response center for Slovenia.

BackBox Software

BackBox Software

BackBox is a leading provider of solutions for automated backup and recovery software for security and network devices.

Cyber Security Africa

Cyber Security Africa

Cyber Security Africa is a full-service Information Security Consulting firm offering a comprehensive range of Services and Products to help organizations protect their valuable assets.

Slice

Slice

Slice offer subscription based Cyber Insurance for small businesses.

Enclave Networks

Enclave Networks

Our mission is to give IT professionals a simple way to rapidly build secure connectivity between any application, computer system, device or infrastructure - regardless of the underlying network.

Pacific Cyber Security Operational Network (PaCSON)

Pacific Cyber Security Operational Network (PaCSON)

PaCSON is an operational cyber security network of regional working-level cyber security experts in the Pacific.

Prelude Research

Prelude Research

Prelude offer the first autonomous platform built to attack, defend and train critical assets through continuous red-teaming.

Protelion

Protelion

The Protelion Security Platform is uniquely architected to deliver security solutions that combine greater protection, flexibility, and performance.

Peris.ai

Peris.ai

Peris.ai is a cybersecurity as a service startup that protects businesses and organizations from online threats.

DC Two

DC Two

DC Two are a locally operated and supported Australian data centre, offering a suite of vertically integrated services covering every part of the data centre and cloud technology stack.

North Green Security

North Green Security

North Green Security is a UK-based cyber security training and consultancy company.

Karate Labs

Karate Labs

Karate is an open-source unified test automation platform combining API testing, API performance testing, API mocks & UI testing.

BARR Advisory

BARR Advisory

At BARR Advisory, we build trust through cyber resilience. We help protect the world’s data, people, and information networks through a human-first approach to cybersecurity and compliance.

SecondSight

SecondSight

SecondSight’s Vertical AI embodies a full-spectrum approach to cyber insurance, facilitating accurate digital risk profiling.

InstaSecure

InstaSecure

InstaSecure’s Preventive Cloud Controls accelerate alert remediation and strengthen cloud configurations. Set your controls once and prevent current and future risks.

Patero

Patero

Patero provides cybersecurity technology solutions that make your data indecipherable with quantum-safe encryption.