Dallas Shooting: US Police Robot Kills Suspect

The ANDROS is a remote control military bomb disposal robot designed by REMOTEC and used by Dallas police to kill the sniper..

Police’s lethal use of bomb-disposal robot in ambush. This worries legal experts who say it creates gray area in use of deadly force by law enforcement

The Dallas police force used a bomb-defusing robot equipped with an explosive device to kill a shooting suspect, police chief David Brown revealed today at a press conference. An explosive was affixed to the extension arm on the robot, Brown said at the press conference, in order to neutralize the suspect, later identified as Micah Xavier Johnson, 25. The incident involved the shooting of 12 officers, five of whom were killed, during a protest in Dallas organized in response to the recent police shootings of Philando Castile and Alton Sterling.

For what experts are calling the first time in history, US police have used a robot in a show of lethal force. Dallas police used a bomb-disposal robot with an explosive device on its manipulator arm to kill a suspect after five police officers were murdered and seven others wounded.

“We saw no other option but to use our bomb robot and place a device on its extension for it to detonate where the suspect was,” Dallas police chief David Brown told reporters.

Peter Singer, a strategist and senior fellow at the New America Foundation who writes about the technology of warfare, said he believed this was a first. “There may be some story that comes along, but I’d think I’d have heard of it,” he said. Others concurred. “As far as I know, it appears to be the first intentional use of a lethally armed robot by the police in the United States,” said Elizabeth Joh, law professor at the University of California at Davis.

This is not the first time a robot designed with other functions in mind has been used as a weapon, but this kind of repurposing has until now been limited to the military. Singer said that in the early 2000s, a solider he interviewed repurposed a surveillance robot called a Marcbot with a bomb. These robots aren’t autonomous, Singer emphasized – the Marcbot “is like a toy truck with a sensor and camera mount they’d use to drive up to a checkpoint”. But this soldier had improvised: “They duct-taped an explosive and you can figure out the rest. You can see the parallels here”.

Singer also said that he was “in no way, shape or form condemning” the DPD’s decision. Brown said the decision protected police officers on a night when their lives were at greater risk than usual. “Other options would have exposed our officers in grave danger,” Singer said.

Joh said she was worried that the decision by police to use robots to end lives had been arrived at far too casually. “Lethally armed police robots raise all sorts of new legal, ethical, and technical questions we haven’t decided upon in any systematic way,” she said. “Under federal constitutional law, excessive-force claims against the police are governed by the fourth amendment. But we typically examine deadly force by the police in terms of an immediate threat to the officer or others. It’s not clear how we should apply that if the threat is to a robot – and the police may be far away.” 

That, Joh added, is only one condition for the use of lethal force. “In other words, I don’t think we have a framework for deciding objectively reasonable robotic force. And we need to develop regulations and policies now, because this surely won’t be the last instance we see police robots.”

The “bomb robot” used is assumed to be the DPD’s bomb-disposal unit, a wheeled, remote-controlled (as opposed to autonomous) robot with a manipulator arm on top. “When there’s a suspected explosive device, a suspected IED, you have this device with a robotic arm and a gripper on it,” Singer explained. “You might use the device to open up a bag and see if there’s a bomb in it. You might use the gripper to disassemble the device in the classic Hollywood movie cut-the-wire way; you might shoot high-pressure water into it, and you might do a controlled detonation.”

That, Singer said, is why the department had explosives handy – sometimes the preferred way to deal with a bomb is to evacuate the area around it and use another bomb to blow it up.

Similar robots were used in the DPD’s showdown with a gunman who assaulted the department’s headquarters with guns and bombs almost exactly a year ago.

On the military side, such improvisations are both the solution and, increasingly, the problem. “We’ve seen insurgents improvise,” Singer said. “Literally this week, the Joint Improvised-Threat Defeat Agency [an agency within the Department of Defense whose purpose is to develop better ways for the military to respond to IEDs] got a $20m grant to defeat drone IEDs, not for missiles but for small commercial drones that you and I could buy, which are used by Isis for both surveillance and for explosive delivery.

“Technology is a tool,” Singer said. “Tools are used the way they’re designed, and then people improvise and find new uses for them.”

Are armed police robots going to be a good thing? The answer depends on who you ask.

A police officer dies in in the line of duty every 61 hours. It is dangerous work. But every day, three people in the United States are killed by police. The American public tend to view police shooting statistics through one of two lenses, one that either minimizes the importance of police shootings or that ignores the real danger that police face every-day. In fact, these trends are mutually reinforcing. A police officer who feels under constant threat also poses a greater likelihood of harm to the individuals he encounters.

As military research pushes robotics prices down and Pentagon policies push battlefield gear to domestic law enforcement agencies, expect to see more armed robots on American streets.

DefenseOne:  Guardian:  Techcrunch

« Turkish Coup: Attempt To Block Internet Fails.
British Royal Navy Drone Ships Will Replace Sailors »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

North Infosec Testing (North IT)

North Infosec Testing (North IT)

North IT (North Infosec Testing) are an award-winning provider of web, software, and application penetration testing.

CSI Consulting Services

CSI Consulting Services

Get Advice From The Experts: * Training * Penetration Testing * Data Governance * GDPR Compliance. Connecting you to the best in the business.

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

ZenGRC

ZenGRC

ZenGRC - the first, easy-to-use, enterprise-grade information security solution for compliance and risk management - offers businesses efficient control tracking, testing, and enforcement.

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

NATO Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre (CCDCOE)

NATO Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre (CCDCOE)

NATO CCDCOE's mission is to enhance the capability, cooperation and information sharing among NATO, NATO nations and partners in cyber defence.

Foundation for Strategic Research (FRS)

Foundation for Strategic Research (FRS)

The Foundation for Strategic Research is France's main independent think tank on strategic, defense and security issues. Cyber security is covered as part of the study areas.

Rockwell Automation

Rockwell Automation

Rockwell Automation offer industrial security solutions to protect the integrity and availability of your complex automation solutions.

Cyphercor

Cyphercor

Cyphercor is a leading smartphone and desktop-based two-factor authentication (2FA) provider.

Ataya & Partners

Ataya & Partners

Ataya & Partners is a consulting company that delivers data protection, cybersecurity and IT & Digital governance services.

Cortado Mobile Solutions

Cortado Mobile Solutions

Cortado Mobile Solutions creates enterprise mobility and file sharing solutions for companies, teams and freelancers.

CyberNews

CyberNews

Cybernews.com is a research-based online publication that helps people navigate a safe path through their increasingly complex digital lives.

Sikich

Sikich

Sikich LLP is a leading professional services firm specializing in accounting, advisory, technology and managed services.

Cyberani Solutions

Cyberani Solutions

Cyberani Solutions was created to fulfill the cybersecurity needs of industry and government in Saudi Arabia, and across the Middle East and North Africa regions.

Quatrro Business Support Services (QBSS)

Quatrro Business Support Services (QBSS)

QBSS is a tech-enabled outsourcing firm that’s changing the way companies think about finance, accounting, human resources and technology services.

Salus Cyber

Salus Cyber

Salus is a provider of world-class cyber security services, enabling our clients to identify and manage their cyber risks proactively and effectively.

ThreatNix

ThreatNix

ThreatNix is a tight knit group of experienced security professionals who are committed to providing competent cybersecurity solutions that adhere to international standards.

Reco AI

Reco AI

Reco is an identity-centric SaaS security solution that empowers organizations with full visibility into every app, identity, and their actions to control risk in their SaaS ecosystem.

Hiya

Hiya

Hiya's mission is to secure voice with trust, identity and intelligence. We're protecting people from spam and fraud calls, and helping carriers secure their networks for all.

Tanzania Industrial Research and Development Organization (TIRDO)

Tanzania Industrial Research and Development Organization (TIRDO)

TIRDO is a multi-disciplinary research and development organization.

Algoritha

Algoritha

Algoritha is a pioneering entity in the realm of security and forensic services.