Cyberwar: Enter the Trolls

Savushkina Street, St Petersburg

The great breach in the US government’s database is a classic case of informational smash and grab. But operations to plant misinformation are also worrying for states which care about truth.

Digital wars are being fought in many theatres around the world and in many forms. In the light of the Snowden revelations, citizens who guard their privacy may already feel that their privacy has already been eroded. But recently, the Obama administration conceded that the US federal government had itself fallen victim to a hack on an unprecedented scale, with the security of the details of up to four million former and present employees apparently breached.

The Chinese, who were initially considered the most likely suspects, hotly deny any responsibility for this data smash and grab. Nor is it immediately obvious what the perpetrators’ motives might be. It could be a fishing expedition to establish who has access to real secrets. It could be a more straightforward criminal enterprise, a prelude to identity theft. The initial hack probably happened months ago, for one of the distinguishing features of the digital age is its capacity to host the faceless along with the intimate. This is what lends a more sinister force to the familiar equation of information, truth and power. The ability to extract or insert information that may or may not be true is not new – but it is uniquely facilitated in a digital world.

The phenomenon of the troll factory is a particularly egregious example of its exploitation. A troll factory is not some happy Scandinavian workshop peopled by happy elves, but a profoundly nihilistic and disturbing use of the Internet. The Guardian newspapeer tracked down a building in Savushkina St. in St Petersburg and talked to some of the paid bloggers who work to establish an inoffensive online personality in the comment sections of media outlets, and on social media, and then seed their posts with pro-Putin or pro-government remarks. The Guardian has experienced this kind of organised assault on reports from Ukraine and, presumably because of implications for the Russian-hosted world cup in 2018, on corruption at Fifa.

This kind of trolling is the digital offspring of earlier practices like “astroturfing”, where American corporations would organise letter-writing campaigns to local papers in order to make a lobbying initiative appear to be something that came from the grassroots. It can be an effective way to subvert opinion, and it is almost certainly more effective in the apparently intimate corners of the Internet than in print. 

This is not just a matter for government in Moscow, Beijing or Pyongyang. Non-state movements such as Islamic State adopt them, too. The Internet is a new front in asymmetrical warfare. We’re so used to thinking of soft power as a benign weapon that it requires an effort of will and understanding to see that it can be used in entirely malign ways, domestically as well as externally. Governments need to be where people are listening. Presumably the west is out there trolling too. 

But the BBC World Service built its reputation with honesty and this should be the policy of any British presence on the Internet. It must be out there at least trying to defend the truth without subterfuge against the lies of dictators and extremists everywhere.

Ein News:  

« Top 6 Hacking Tools Security Teams Should Know About
FBI Unable to Monitor ISIS’s Encrypted Communications »

Infosecurity Europe
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

IT Governance

IT Governance

IT Governance is a leading global provider of information security solutions. Download our free guide and find out how ISO 27001 can help protect your organisation's information.

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

Resecurity

Resecurity

Resecurity is a cybersecurity company that delivers a unified platform for endpoint protection, risk management, and cyber threat intelligence.

CSI Consulting Services

CSI Consulting Services

Get Advice From The Experts: * Training * Penetration Testing * Data Governance * GDPR Compliance. Connecting you to the best in the business.

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) - Norway

National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) - Norway

NCSC is part of the Norwegian Security Authority, and is Norway's national cyber security hub and the national CERT.

Stott & May

Stott & May

Stott & May is a specialist cyber security recruitment agency.

Jamcracker

Jamcracker

Jamcracker is a cloud services management and cloud governance solutions company, with more than a decade of experience providing industry leading software and services.

Cortado Mobile Solutions

Cortado Mobile Solutions

Cortado Mobile Solutions creates enterprise mobility and file sharing solutions for companies, teams and freelancers.

Hunters.AI

Hunters.AI

Hunters is the world's first autonomous hunting solution that leverages top-tier cyber expertise and AI to uncover hidden cyber threats.

eCosCentric

eCosCentric

eCosCentric provides software development solutions for the IoT, M2M & embedded systems market.

PurpleSynapz

PurpleSynapz

PurpleSynapz provides hyper-realistic Cyber Security Training with a modern curriculum and Cyber Range.

Maritime Transportation System Information Sharing and Analysis Center (MTS-ISAC)

Maritime Transportation System Information Sharing and Analysis Center (MTS-ISAC)

MTS-ISAC promotes and facilitates maritime cybersecurity information sharing, awareness, training, and collaboration efforts between private and public sector stakeholders.

Redbot Security

Redbot Security

Redbot Security provides industry leading manual penetration testing. Protecting critical systems and data - red team attack and breach simulations, (OT) critical infrastructure testing.

Resolvo Systems

Resolvo Systems

Resolvo is provides comprehensive security assessment and testing services in Asia.

Campus cyber

Campus cyber

A project initiated by the President of the Republic, the Cyber Campus is the totem site of cybersecurity that brings together the main national and international players in the field.

Primary Guard

Primary Guard

Primary Guard provides IT solutions and computing technologies that help minimize impact from cyber threats, improve business efficiency and maintain essential functions during or after a disaster.

ATSG

ATSG

ATSG is a global leader in transformational technology solutions for today’s digital enterprise. Cybersecurity ranging from Advisory & Assessment to Fully Managed Detection and Response Services.

Praxis Security Labs

Praxis Security Labs

Praxis Security Labs is a research driven cybersecurity company that helps our customers to reduce risk and improve security.

Saidot

Saidot

Saidot is a Finnish AI governance and alignment company committed to helping businesses safely and transparently integrate AI into their operations.

Runtime Ventures

Runtime Ventures

Runtime Ventures focuses on seed and pre-seed stage cybersecurity investments. We love to work with ambitious founders building the future of the secure enterprise.