Cyber Warfare Takes A New Turn

The recent ransomware events have created headaches and headlines, but also masked a greater cyber-issue: chaos and disruption on the Internet as the new normal. Earlier this week, in fact, the Alliance for Securing Democracy, a new effort headed by former US national security officials, formed as a separate, nongovernmental program to investigate Russian cyber-meddling.

Previous cyber-incidents focused on information acquisition, network infiltration or precision strikes to sabotage the opposition. What are we seeing now are disruptive cyber-actions, with the apparent goals of signaling capability, disrupting normal systems and demonstrating the instability of Western democratic models.

Ransom is not the issue

A number of analysts described the Petya/NotPetya incident of June and the WannaCry event in May as ransom attacks, aimed at gaining as much bitcoin as possible. But our analysis of cyber-coercion highlights how ransomware events such as the Petya are often strategically motivated and less about gaining funds than they are about sending a signal. The primary goal instead appears to be limited destruction through malware wiping systems.

These events can be classified as cyber-disruptions: the use of malware and website defacements between rivals as a form of coercive bargaining. Rival states use cyber-operations to signal one another. Cyber-operations are a 21st-century form of political warfare.

North Korea and Russia are the likely originators of these attacks. What’s the motivation, beyond simply the chaos factor? For Russia, the Petya attack could be a means of encouraging the perception of Ukraine as a failed state, a view that aligns with Russian interests.

Cyber-operations amplify larger psychological warfare efforts. North Korea’s goal, most likely, could be to cause general chaos in Western systems, as a means of signaling strength, and its capacity to escalate in any future crisis.

This is a new era of cyber-conflict

This wave of cyber-disruptions highlights an evolving strategic logic. Competitive interactions in the digital domain evolved from an early period of cyber-probing and testing (1980-2001) to a more stable recent period of cyber-restraint (2001-2016). With Russia’s brazen attempts to undermine American electoral infrastructure and amplify conspiratorial themes through US media outlets, we entered a new era.

The strategic logic of cyber has now shifted from restraint to one of disruption and constant harassment designed to signal capability and the threat of escalation. Russian hackers targeted US institutions, most likely hoping to gain leverage before entering complex negotiations around sanctions, Ukraine and Syria.

While we have yet to witness the extremes of cyberwar, the more subtle danger since 2016 is the way states like Russia and North Korea use cyber-strategies as a form of political warfare. These attacks create chaos, which challenges the prevailing international order and major institutions, from commerce to hospitals to elections, that represent the foundations of Western societies.

Why cyber-warfare works

States have learned that cyber-operations offer a 21st-century vehicle to conduct old-fashioned covert action and psychological warfare without significant fear of rebuke. Russian cyber-meddling over the past two years went largely unpunished in public. Instead, the United States relied on covert coercion to prevent escalation.

Cyber-strategies have now become indirect forms of coercion designed to weaken adversary resolve and create uncertainty, as well as undermine alliances or create political wedges. A growing number of states are using cyber-intrusions to wage psychological warfare and leak information with propaganda value.

In addition to propaganda, states use cyber-operations to influence elections and conduct disruption operations. Russian interference in the elections of Western states has become so common it is now expected. But instead of just disrupting elections, Russia now seems to be leveraging cyberespionage and propaganda to generate larger crises.

Rival states are using cyberspace to wage political warfare campaigns. Here are recent examples:

1) A new group called Global Leaks, an offshoot of the Russian military-attributed group DC Leaks, released the emails of the United Arab Emirates ambassador to the United States in June, causing tensions among Persian Gulf allies by suggesting an alignment between UAE and Israel.

2) In May, Vietnam covertly released transcripts of Donald Trump’s discussions with Philippines President Rodrigo Duterte to disrupt the relationship. Closer ties among China, the Philippines and the United States are problematic for other members of the Association of Southeast Asian Countries hoping to operate by consensus and ward off encroachments by China. Cyber-operations thus became a useful tool to disrupt that developing relationship.

3) In the Middle East, cyber-operations undermine alliances and isolate actors. In June, a Russian hack on Qatar’s state news agency and fake information incorrectly attributing positive statements about Hamas and Iran to the Emir of Qatar may have provoked the first online international crisis. The moves re-sparked a long-standing dispute in the Middle East.

The embargo and ejection of Qatar from the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) demonstrates how cyber-operations can have heavy diplomatic ramifications. Russia manipulated the entire Gulf region to turn its back on Qatar by planting stories to be picked up by Saudi news agencies. This led to a cascading diplomatic crisis. Saudi Arabia severed relations with Qatar. Bahrain, Egypt, Jordan and the UAE quickly followed suit.

All of these examples suggest a different character of cyber-conflict, and any new efforts to monitor and curtail these efforts will face no shortage of challenges. To date, cyber-exchanges operated largely under relatively stable international norms, as suggested by Joseph Nye. Yes, China stole intellectual property and rivals probed each other’s networks, but these events didn’t create dangerous crises or seek to undermine faith in Western institutions.

Russia now appears to be using Ukraine as more than a testing ground for cyberwar, it is demonstrating its ability to disrupt faith in public institutions. While the resulting crises after a cyber-event risk inadvertent escalation, the real danger is the erosion of cyber norms. With each new cyber-disruption, the shock decreases, and we grow to expect disorder.

The resulting uncertainty and chaos undermines our trust in the open Internet architecture and risks upsetting stability inherent in cyber-exchanges to date.

Ein News

You Might Also Read: 

Cyberwar: A New Front For US Military:

NATO Could Go To War In Response To A Cyber Attack:

 

« The Impact Of AI On Employment Demands New Thinking
Dark Web Marketplaces Shut Down »

Infosecurity Europe
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

The PC Support Group

The PC Support Group

A partnership with The PC Support Group delivers improved productivity, reduced costs and protects your business through exceptional IT, telecoms and cybersecurity services.

Directory of Cyber Security Suppliers

Directory of Cyber Security Suppliers

Our Supplier Directory lists 7,000+ specialist cyber security service providers in 128 countries worldwide. IS YOUR ORGANISATION LISTED?

TÜV SÜD Academy UK

TÜV SÜD Academy UK

TÜV SÜD offers expert-led cybersecurity training to help organisations safeguard their operations and data.

XYPRO Technology

XYPRO Technology

XYPRO is the market leader in HPE Non-Stop Security, Risk Management and Compliance.

TrustedSec

TrustedSec

TrustedSec is an information security consulting services, providing tailored solutions and services for small, mid, and large businesses.

Jones Day

Jones Day

Jones Day is an international law firm based in the United States. Practice areas include Cybersecurity, Privacy & Data Protection.

Cyber adAPT

Cyber adAPT

Cyber adAPT offers a leading network threat detection platform (NTD) to the enterprise and ODM/OEM markets.

CyberInsureOne

CyberInsureOne

At CyberInsureOne, we break down the complex world of cyber insurance, and connect you with providers that can give you and your company peace of mind.

National CyberWatch Center - USA

National CyberWatch Center - USA

National CyberWatch Center is a cybersecurity consortium working to advance cybersecurity education and strengthen the national workforce.

WisePlant

WisePlant

WisePlant's portfolio of solutions and services includes process measurement, secure automation, industrial cybersecurity, functional safety and more.

Haven Group

Haven Group

Haven Group and its companies are a cyber security one-stop-shop for our clients offering a full range of cyber security services to our clients in a unified and united way.

ISMAC

ISMAC

ISMAC was founded to create a security solution that would work for smaller to medium as well as bigger corporations at an affordable price.

Etisalat and (e&)

Etisalat and (e&)

Etisalat Group is one of the world’s leading telecom groups in emerging markets.

Secuna Software Technologies

Secuna Software Technologies

Secuna is the most trusted Cybersecurity Testing Platform in the Philippines. Our pool of vetted security researchers will find and ethically report security vulnerabilities in your product.

Cybergroot

Cybergroot

Cybergroot provides Cybersecurity Assessment services and professional Information Security trainings.

Nitel

Nitel

Nitel is a leading next-generation technology services provider. We simplify the complex technology challenges of today’s enterprises to create seamless and integrated managed network solutions.

CloudWave

CloudWave

CloudWave, the expert in healthcare data security, provides cloud, cybersecurity, and managed services to healthcare organizations.

ZainTech

ZainTech

Zaintech is a regional digital & ICT solutions provider offering comprehensive digital solutions and services to enterprise and government customers in the MENA region.

Axians

Axians

Axians supports its customers in their digital transformation journey. We offer ICT solutions and services in areas including Enterprise Networks and Cybersecurity.

Complete Cyber

Complete Cyber

Complete Cyber provide professional cybersecurity services and products to help secure your infrastructure, systems and data.