Claims That Google's Search Algorithm Spread False Information

Google’s search algorithm appears to be systematically promoting information that is either false or slanted with an extreme rightwing bias on subjects as varied as climate change and homosexuality.

Following a recent investigation by the UK=Published  Observer newspaper, which found that Google’s search engine prominently suggests neo-Nazi websites and anti-Semitic writing, the Guardian has uncovered a dozen additional examples of biased search results.

Google’s search algorithm and its autocomplete function prioritize websites that, for example, declare that climate change is a hoax, being gay is a sin, and the Sandy Hook mass shooting never happened.

The increased scrutiny on the algorithms of Google, which removed anti-Semitic and sexist autocomplete phrases after the recent Observer investigation, comes at a time of tense debate surrounding the role of fake news in building support for conservative political leaders, particularly US president-elect Donald Trump.

Facebook has faced significant backlash for its role in enabling widespread dissemination of misinformation, and data scientists and communication experts have argued that rightwing groups have found creative ways to manipulate social media trends and search algorithms.

The Guardian’s latest findings further suggest that Google’s searches are contributing to the problem.

In the past, when a journalist or academic exposes one of these algorithmic hiccups, humans at Google quietly make manual adjustments in a process that’s neither transparent nor accountable.

At the same time, politically motivated third parties including the “alt-right”, a far-right movement in the US, use a variety of techniques to trick the algorithm and push propaganda and misinformation higher up Google’s search rankings.

These insidious manipulations, both by Google and by third parties trying to game the system, impact how users of the search engine perceive the world, even influencing the way they vote. This has led some researchers to study Google’s role in the presidential election in the same way that they have scrutinized Facebook.

Robert Epstein from the American Institute for Behavioral Research and Technology has spent four years trying to reverse engineer Google’s search algorithms. He believes, based on systematic research, that Google has the power to rig elections through something he calls the search engine manipulation effect (SEME).

Epstein conducted five experiments in two countries to find that biased rankings in search results can shift the opinions of undecided voters. If Google tweaks its algorithm to show more positive search results for a candidate, the searcher may form a more positive opinion of that candidate.

In September 2016, Epstein released findings, published through Russian news agency Sputnik News, that indicated Google had suppressed negative autocomplete search results relating to Hillary Clinton.

Even changing the order in which certain search terms appear in the autocompleted list can make a huge impact, with the first result drawing the most clicks, he said.

At the time, Google said the autocomplete algorithm was designed to omit disparaging or offensive terms associated with individuals’ names but that it wasn’t an “exact science”.

Then there’s the secret recipe of factors that feed into the algorithm Google uses to determine a web page’s importance, embedded with the biases of the humans who programmed it. These factors include how many and which other websites link to a page, how much traffic it receives, and how often a page is updated. People who are very active politically are typically the most partisan, which means that extremist views peddled actively on blogs and fringe media sites get elevated in the search ranking.

“These platforms are structured in such a way that they are allowing and enabling, consciously or unconsciously, more extreme views to dominate,” said Martin Moore from Kings College London’s Centre for the Study of Media, Communication and Power.

Epstein wants Google to be more transparent about how and when it manually manipulates the algorithm.

“They are constantly making these adjustments. It’s absurd for them to say everything is automated,” he said. Manual removals from autocomplete include “are jews evil” and “are women evil”. Google has also altered its results so when someone searches for ways to kill themselves they are shown a suicide helpline.

Shortly after Epstein released his research indicating the suppression of negative autocomplete search results relating to Clinton, which he credits to close ties between the Clinton campaign and Google, the search engine appeared to pull back from such censorship, he said. This, he argued, allowed for a flood of pro-Trump, anti-Clinton content (including fake news), some of which was created in retaliation to bubble to the top.

“If I had to do it over again I would not have released those data. There is some indication that they had an impact that was detrimental to Hillary Clinton, which was never my intention.”

The problem has become particularly challenging for Google in a post-truth era, where white supremacist websites may have the same indicator of “trustworthiness” in the eyes of Google as other websites high in the page rank.

“What does Google do when the lies aren’t the outliers any-more?” Heller said. “Previously there was the assumption that everything on the internet had a glimmer of truth about it. With the phenomenon of fake news and media hacking, that may be changing.”

A Google spokeswoman said in a statement: “We’ve received a lot of questions about autocomplete, and we want to help people understand how it works: Autocomplete predictions are algorithmically generated based on users’ search activity and interests. Users search for such a wide range of material on the web, 15% of searches we see every day are new.

Because of this, terms that appear in Autocomplete may be unexpected or unpleasant. We do our best to prevent offensive terms, like porn and hate speech, from appearing, but we don’t always get it right. Autocomplete isn’t an exact science and we’re always working to improve our algorithms.”

Guardian:          On Facebook, Fake US Election News Was More Popular Than Real News:

 

« Cyber Deterrence: How To Curb Cyber Attacks
Smartwatch Technology For Police Forces »

Infosecurity Europe
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

Alvacomm

Alvacomm

Alvacomm offers holistic VIP cybersecurity services, providing comprehensive protection against cyber threats. Our solutions include risk assessment, threat detection, incident response.

The PC Support Group

The PC Support Group

A partnership with The PC Support Group delivers improved productivity, reduced costs and protects your business through exceptional IT, telecoms and cybersecurity services.

IT Governance

IT Governance

IT Governance is a leading global provider of information security solutions. Download our free guide and find out how ISO 27001 can help protect your organisation's information.

Practice Labs

Practice Labs

Practice Labs is an IT competency hub, where live-lab environments give access to real equipment for hands-on practice of essential cybersecurity skills.

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

CyberDef

CyberDef

CyberDef is a consulting company specialising in cyber defence services for small and medium enterprises.

File Centre

File Centre

File Centre is a leading specialist when it comes to data backup, we offer our clients a premium backup retrieval and delivery solution.

Living Security

Living Security

Living Security specializes in metric driven and engaging security awareness solutions that reduce risk by increasing security culture and changing employee behaviour.

Infortec

Infortec

Infortec provide consultancy and solutions for the protection of digital information and the management of computer resources.

CYQUEO

CYQUEO

CYQUEO is your professional partner and system integrator. We secure your organization against advanced cyber threats.

Center for Applied Cybersecurity Research (CACR) - University of Indiana

Center for Applied Cybersecurity Research (CACR) - University of Indiana

CACR serves Indiana and the nation by tackling cyber risk in research and other unusual environments through agile, holistic, principle-based cybersecurity.

R3I Ventures - House of DeepTech

R3I Ventures - House of DeepTech

The House of DeepTech is an incubator for deeptech entrepreneurs that are transforming global industries. Areas of interest include cybersecurity.

Protek International

Protek International

Protek International delivers world-class Digital Forensics, eDiscovery, Cyber Security, and related Advisory services.

CRI Group

CRI Group

CRI Group excels at deterring, detecting and investigating crimes against businesses using a global network of professionals specially trained in Anti-Corruption, Risk Management and Compliance.

CYMOTIVE Technologies

CYMOTIVE Technologies

Combining Israeli cyber innovation with a century of German automotive engineering. CYMOTIVE operates under the assumption that connectivity is a game changer for the automotive industry.

Aura

Aura

Aura is a mission driven technology company dedicated to creating a safer internet for everyone. We’re making comprehensive digital security that's simple to understand and easy to use.

ITSEC Asia

ITSEC Asia

ITSEC Asia works to effectively reduce exposure to information security threats and improve the effectiveness of its clients' information security management systems.

Silent Quadrant

Silent Quadrant

Silent Quadrant delivers incomparable cybersecurity consulting, digital transformation, and risk management within our purpose-driven clients - empowering them to be the most resilient entities.

Commonwealth Scientific & Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO)

Commonwealth Scientific & Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO)

CSIRO is Australia's national science agency. We solve the greatest challenges through innovative science and technology.

CyberSanctus

CyberSanctus

CyberSanctus provide clients with a variety of pentest plans from the entry level starter plan, which is tailored for personal websites, to enterprise level pentests, tailored for large scale business

42Crunch

42Crunch

42Crunch provides API security testing and threat protection. We proactively test, fix and protect your APIs from development to runtime.