Balancing China’s Role In The UK’s AI Agenda

This week, the UK will convene world leaders, tech executives and a select group of civil society in a two-day summit to discuss Artificial Intelligence (AI) safety.

One of the topics that generated a great deal of controversy and speculation is China’s participation in the summit. The decision to extend an invitation to China has been met with criticism by many, including from the prime minister’s own party. Former prime minister Liz Truss wrote to Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, urging him to reconsider the invitation.

She emphasized the need to work with allies rather than ‘those seeking to subvert freedom and democracy’. Despite these controversies, the PM maintained his position asserting that there can be ‘no serious strategy for AI without at least trying to engage all of the world’s leading AI powers’.

This stance underlines the PM’s aspirations for the UK to take a leadership role in global AI governance, while acknowledging China’s pivotal position in this endeavour.

China’s Involvement In The Summit Remains Uncertain

Although China has accepted the invitation, its final attendance remains uncertain. China seems to be leaving the possibility open for a last minute withdrawal, particularly given the recent US tightening of controls on its access to AI technology. This adds to the event’s intrigue, leaving many pondering the potential implications and significance of China’s involvement or absence.

This prompts the question of whether the UK can navigate its approach to China, serving as a mediator that bridges China’s AI expertise with existing concerns.

This situation suggests that China is interested in contributing to the UK’s AI governance efforts, but not without conditions. It prompts the question of whether the UK can effectively navigate its approach to China, serving as a mediator that bridges China’s AI expertise with existing concerns. Achieving this objective necessitates a nuanced approach.

UK’s Approach To China

Over recent years, the UK government has maintained a clear narrative and approach about the acute threat that China poses to the UK. The Integrated Review Refresh, stated that China ‘poses an epoch-defining and systemic challenge with implications for almost every area of government policy and the everyday lives of British people’.

The National Cyber Strategy emphasized how ‘China’s technical development and evolution is likely to be the single biggest factor affecting the UK’s cyber security in the years to come’. The long debate around 5G, which led to the UK government preventing Huawei from participating in building the country’s 5G infrastructure due to its close association with the Chinese government, remains fresh in memory.

Furthermore, the UK has aligned itself with its allies, particularly the US, in warning against the various threats posed by China. In an unprecedented joint appearance, the heads of the UK and US security services came together in 2022 to warn about the Chinese growing technical capabilities, with the FBI head stating that China posed the ‘biggest long-term threat to our economic and national security’. Additionally, the UK along with its allies have also collectively attributed the 2021 Microsoft exchange, a global wave of cyberattacks and data breaches, to Chinese state-backed actors.

The UK’s invitation to China for the summit might appear contradictory to its stance, but there are reasons for it.

In parallel to all this, the ongoing US–China ‘tech war’ continues. In a recent move aimed at China, the Biden administration strengthened export controls on advanced AI chips, making it difficult for US companies to supply high-performance semiconductors to China. This will have significant implications for curtailing China’s AI ambitions.

While the US and the UK have distinct approaches to handling China, driven by their own foreign policy strategies and priorities, there is an underlying expectation for the UK to align more closely with the US approach. As such, the UK’s invitation to China for the summit might appear contradictory to its stance, but there are reasons for it.

A Cautious Approach

The UK has high ambitions, to not only become a global leader in AI regulation, but to also become a technology ‘superpower’. It recognizes that achieving this will require involving China in some regards.

China’s involvement is sought beyond the summit. The UK is likely inviting China to take part in a new global AI research body, which, if it materializes, would be a significant step and would make this body distinct from existing transatlantic or European AI initiatives.

Not only is China one of the leading countries on AI capabilities, it has developed detailed regulations on for emerging technology which will have a big impact on AI in China and globally. China has deployed AI tools that illustrate both the potential and some of the existing and future risks of these technologies. So, the UK’s decision to include China in the summit underscores its commitment to engage in a substantive dialogue with a key AI player.

The UK has high ambitions, to not only become a global leader in AI regulation, but to also become a tech superpower. Achieving this requires including China.

In the  2023 Integrated Review Refresh, the UK acknowledged the need to leave room for ‘open, constructive and predictable relations’ with China with a preference for ‘better cooperation and understanding, and predictability and stability for global public good’, caveated by adding that this cooperation ‘will depend on the choices China makes’. Inviting China to the summit is in line with this new approach.

China's Participation 

Ultimately, China’s participation at the table won’t be solely dictated by the UK’s preference. A day after the US updated its export policy, President Xi Jinping introduced the Global AI Governance Initiative at the opening ceremony of the Belt and Road Forum. The initiative emphasized the importance of collaboration between countries on AI governance while also explicitly opposing barriers and unilateral coercive measures, seemingly in a nod to the US efforts.

Recent news seems to confirm that several of the G7 leaders will be missing the summit, posing a challenge to the UK’s ambitions. Hence, if China participates in the summit, it would influence the dynamics and significance and, arguably, help the UK assert its role in global AI governance.

The UK should play the long game adopting a delicate approach and narrative that can persuade dissenting voices within the UK and its allies about the importance of involving China. This should be done while taking a cautious approach to the associated risks.

The benefit from this approach could have an impact well beyond the UK and demonstrate true global leadership on the part of UK government.

Joyce Hakmeh is Deputy Director, International Security Programme at Chatham House 

You Might Also Read: 

The AI Dilemma: Regulate, Monopolize, Or Liberate:

___________________________________________________________________________________________

If you like this website and use the comprehensive 6,500-plus service supplier Directory, you can get unrestricted access, including the exclusive in-depth Directors Report series, by signing up for a Premium Subscription.

  • Individual £5 per month or £50 per year. Sign Up
  • Multi-User, Corporate & Library Accounts Available on Request

Cyber Security Intelligence: Captured Organised & Accessible


 

« Prime Minister Sunak Identifies The Risks & Potential Of AI
Defenders Of The Cybersecurity Command Centre   »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

CYRIN

CYRIN

CYRIN® Cyber Range. Real Tools, Real Attacks, Real Scenarios. See why leading educational institutions and companies in the U.S. have begun to adopt the CYRIN® system.

MIRACL

MIRACL

MIRACL provides the world’s only single step Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) which can replace passwords on 100% of mobiles, desktops or even Smart TVs.

XYPRO Technology

XYPRO Technology

XYPRO is the market leader in HPE Non-Stop Security, Risk Management and Compliance.

Clayden Law

Clayden Law

Clayden Law advise global businesses that buy and sell technology products and services. We are experts in information technology, data privacy and cybersecurity law.

ZenGRC

ZenGRC

ZenGRC - the first, easy-to-use, enterprise-grade information security solution for compliance and risk management - offers businesses efficient control tracking, testing, and enforcement.

Protective Intelligence

Protective Intelligence

Protective Intelligence brings together a group of information security specialists with a passion for delivering high-quality solutions.

HackRead

HackRead

HackRead is a News Platform that centers on InfoSec, Cyber Crime, Privacy, Surveillance and Hacking News with full-scale reviews on Social Media Platforms & Technology trends.

Arista Networks

Arista Networks

Arista Networks is an industry leader in data-driven, client to cloud networking for large data center, campus and routing environments.

Infrascale

Infrascale

Infrascale specialise in providing cloud backup and disaster recovery services.

CyberESI

CyberESI

CyberESI is a Managed Security Service Provider providing 24x7 remote security monitoring and management of your mission-critical networks.

Communications Security Establishment (CSE)

Communications Security Establishment (CSE)

CSE is Canada's national cryptologic agency, providing the Government of Canada with IT Security and foreign signals intelligence (SIGINT) services.

BitRaser

BitRaser

BitRaser serves your needs for a managed & certified data erasure solution that can support internal & external corporate audit requirements with traceable reporting.

Maticmind

Maticmind

Maticmind is an ICT System Integrator providing solutions and specialized skills in Networking, Security, Unified Communications & Collaboration, Datacenter & Cloud and Application.

Early Birds

Early Birds

Early Birds is a Business to Business (B2B) marketplace for Innovators (Startups/Scaleups) and Early Adopters to exchange value early on.

Snowflake

Snowflake

Empower your cybersecurity and compliance teams with Snowflake. Gain full visibility into security logs, at massive scale, while reducing costs of Security Information and Event Management systems.

Psybersafe

Psybersafe

Psybersafe is a hands-on, behaviour-changing training system that keeps your people and your business cyber safe.

GoTo

GoTo

At GoTo we help people and businesses to connect and collaborate simply and securely – from anywhere. We’re the trusted partner for companies of all sizes.

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

Early Game Ventures (EGV)

Early Game Ventures (EGV)

Early Game Ventures invests in startups that jumpstart new industries in the emerging markets of Europe.

Mother Technologies

Mother Technologies

From Datacentre to Desktop, Mother Technologies has been delivering IT Support, Telecoms, Cybersecurity and Connectivity services to businesses across Scotland and beyond since 2002.

WIIT Group

WIIT Group

WIIT Group are focused on a single goal: securing our clients’ critical processes and enabling them for digital transformation.