AI As A Standalone Cybersecurity Solution 

AI is a hot topic. Set to revolutionise the way we live, work and interact with technology, it is shaping our future extensively. In almost every industry sector AI is altering processes, driving innovation, and transforming business models, ushering in a new era of efficiency and opportunity. And the world of cybersecurity is no exception. 

Presenting somewhat of a double-edged sword, AI is tipped to make cybersecurity more challenging by empowering threat actors to be more sophisticated, effective and believable on the one hand, whilst also offering improvements in defence mechanisms, leading to huge accelerations in the capability of threat detection.

There’s a lot of noise about how we can leverage AI in security and, whilst I agree its use will be beneficial, what concerns me is the inference that AI, like some of the security products and services hailed before it, could become a standalone solution which will somehow negate the requirement for an effective Security Operations Center (SOC). 

In my opinion, this is what the threat actors want. For us to absolve ourselves of responsibility, accountability and judgement and put our trust in a tech solution. 

The reality is that the same reasons that make AI a compelling threat are the very reasons that should make us pause and proceed with a good deal of caution and scepticism when considering AI as a security solution.  
AI models are fed by data and their reliability is dependent on the quality of the data they ingest.  If the data is contaminated or unreliable, the results can be biased and can even create a new attack surface for threat actors to exploit. AI models also make decisions in ways that humans can't easily understand and are readily open to manipulation.

A potential attacker for example, could trick the machine learning model into misclassifying threats to enable them to make breaches undetected thus posing a significant risk to cybersecurity.  

Whilst not a cybersecurity issue, Amazon’s attempt to lead the world in AI driven recruitment is a great example of this. Trained to find applicants by following patterns in resumes/CVs that had been received over the preceding decade, the high numbers of men in tech meant that the AI ‘learned’ that males were a preference for the company and started to penalise any reference to women or female. Amazon thought it was giving the AI the responsibility, but it didn’t, it gave it the authority to act on its behalf. The result almost managed to set the company’s diversity objectives back decades and was a huge problem to fix.

AI’s inability to contextualise is another reason why it shouldn’t be relied upon as a sole cybersecurity solution. It doesn’t have human-like situational awareness, judgment, or prioritisation abilities. It doesn’t understand the nuances of the wider environment it’s being used in, the industry or market context. Human intuition is essential in cybersecurity, enabling threat levels to be assessed in context, prioritised based on risk, and adjusted accordingly. Without it, AI may misinterpret situations, leading to ineffective responses and increased vulnerability to evolving threats.

Behind every cyber attack is a human ready to adapt; to change their method and evolve their approach. Relying solely on AI tools and removing the human element risks facing adversaries that outpace the machine's capabilities.

That human expertise is also the reason why a SOC centre is essential. Yes, an AI security model may well be able to process massive amounts of data and flag threats with amazing speed. But then what? Most IT teams are already drowning in alarms and alerts, they need guidance and support from other human experts, not another data source without direction.

Just as threat actors try to rush, distract and manipulate their victims, we shouldn’t be distracted from our security goals by the shiny thing that is AI. The risk hasn’t changed. The threat is just faster, stronger and harder and a standalone AI cybersecurity solution won’t suffice in beating it.

Image: Ideogram

Chris Stouff is Chief Security Officer at Armor

You Might Also Read:

AI-Driven Cyber Security Is Booming:

___________________________________________________________________________________________

If you like this website and use the comprehensive 6,500-plus service supplier Directory, you can get unrestricted access, including the exclusive in-depth Directors Report series, by signing up for a Premium Subscription.

  • Individual £5 per month or £50 per year. Sign Up
  • Multi-User, Corporate & Library Accounts Available on Request

Cyber Security Intelligence: Captured Organised & Accessible


 

« A Deep Dive Into Deepfakes & The Threat To Digital Identity Verification
2024 & Beyond: Top Six Cloud Security Trends: »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

BackupVault

BackupVault

BackupVault is a leading provider of automatic cloud backup and critical data protection against ransomware, insider attacks and hackers for businesses and organisations worldwide.

Syxsense

Syxsense

Syxsense brings together endpoint management and security for greater efficiency and collaboration between IT management and security teams.

CYRIN

CYRIN

CYRIN® Cyber Range. Real Tools, Real Attacks, Real Scenarios. See why leading educational institutions and companies in the U.S. have begun to adopt the CYRIN® system.

Practice Labs

Practice Labs

Practice Labs is an IT competency hub, where live-lab environments give access to real equipment for hands-on practice of essential cybersecurity skills.

Resecurity, Inc.

Resecurity, Inc.

Resecurity is a cybersecurity company that delivers a unified platform for endpoint protection, risk management, and cyber threat intelligence.

ProfitBricks

ProfitBricks

ProfitBricks is a secure cloud computing infrastructure-as-a-service (IaaS) solution.

TestingXperts

TestingXperts

TestingXperts is a specialist software QA and testing company.

Veridify Security

Veridify Security

Veridify Security (formerly SecureRF), develops and licenses quantum-resistant, public-key security tools for the low-resource processors powering the Internet of Things.

TEISS

TEISS

Teiss.co.uk is a website dedicated to providing information about cyber security. TEISS also provide a series of conferences and events focused on cyber security.

Awake Security

Awake Security

Awake Security offer a security solution built on an AI platform that acts like the human brain to sense, detect, and respond to threats you may not even know exist.

authUSB

authUSB

authUSB Safe Door is a tool that provides secure access to the content of USB devices that circulate in organizations.

Stage2Data

Stage2Data

Stage2Data is one of Canada’s most trusted cloud solution providers offering hosted Backup and Disaster Recovery Services.

Cyber Pathways

Cyber Pathways

Cyber Pathways brings together the next generation of Cyber professionals along with delegates who are looking to cross train and enter the cyber market.

Sayata Labs

Sayata Labs

Sayata delivers a streamlined solution for processing cyber policies. Increase profitability with an easy and intuitive platform.

Pentest360

Pentest360

Pentest360 is a 24x7x365 Penetration testing service offered through a feature-rich, centralised platform on the cloud that delivers instant visibility during security assessments.

Portshift

Portshift

Portshift leverages the power of Kubernetes and Service-Mesh to deliver a single source of truth for containers and cloud-native applications security.

International Association of Security Awareness Professionals (IASAP)

International Association of Security Awareness Professionals (IASAP)

IASAP provides a members-only virtual sharing platform where security awareness professionals engage in a lively, year-round exchange of information and ideas.

Digital Craftsmen Ltd

Digital Craftsmen Ltd

We're ISO27001 & Cyber Essentials Cybersecurity experts, delivering full cloud security and managed services. We take a bespoke approach for each client from hosting, optimising & securing them online

VLC Solutions

VLC Solutions

VLC Solutions is an independent solutions and technology service provider offering Cloud Services, Cybersecurity, ERP Services, Network Management Services, and Compliance Solutions.

Indevtech

Indevtech

Indevtech has been serving Hawaii since 2001, providing end-to-end managed IT services to small- and medium-businesses.

Acumenis

Acumenis

At Acumenis, we help organisations of all sizes to manage information security effectively. Our key services are penetration testing, ISO 27001 implementations, and security