A New Front in Obama’s War on Whistleblowers

Fired Pentagon assistant inspector general John Crane is going public with allegations senior officials retaliated against whistleblowers, destroyed permanent records and altered audits under political pressure.

A cashiered senior official in the Pentagon’s inspector general office ended years of anonymous complaints this weekend, giving interviews about his former employer’s handling of whistleblowers in key national security controversies, including the Edward Snowden and Thomas Drake cases.

John Crane, 60, who spent 25 years in government before he was fired as an assistant Defense Department inspector general in 2013, went public with a series of accusations that key officials in the watchdog’s office retaliated against whistleblowers, destroyed permanent records and altered audits under political pressure.

He has filed those charges with the Office of Special Counsel, which so far has referred one to the Justice Department for detailed investigation, though others may soon follow.

Crane’s name and case appear in a new book, Bravehearts: Whistle-Blowing in the Age of Snowden (Hot Books, 2016), by Mark Hertsgaard, excerpted in the British newspaper The Guardian and the German magazine Der Spiegel.

In an interview with Government Executive recently, Crane challenged the criticism by many top US officials who say Edward Snowden, the former Booz Allen Hamilton employee who worked as a National Security Agency contractor, could have taken his complaint through official channels. In 2013, Snowden flew to Hong Kong, leaked classified documents exposing U.S. surveillance programs and ultimately took refuge in Russia.

“Edward Snowden and his decision not to go through the whistleblower process indicate a larger failure within DoD IG,” Crane said. “Snowden did not go through the IG because he saw what had happened to Thomas Drake,” he added.

The Drake case, also a hallmark in the whistleblower community, involved the Justice Department’s prosecution of an NSA senior executive in 2010 under the Espionage Act for speaking to the Baltimore Sun about wasteful NSA programs going back a decade. The government eventually dropped the case after public outcry and skepticism from a federal judge, and Drake pleaded guilty to a lesser charge.

Crane, in the meantime, thought he had witnessed retaliation against Drake by DoD IG officials Lynne Halbrooks (now a private attorney) and General Counsel Henry C. Shelley Jr., along with the destruction of documents relevant to the case more than a decade ago when Crane was handling Drake’s disclosures to the IG’s office. Crane reported that to the Office of Special Counsel, which in March referred the case to Justice for possible prosecution.

Crane is now a stay-at-home father living in McLean, Va., while fighting to get his job back. He continues to meet with the Office of Special Counsel as it reviews several other complaints against the DoD IG.

Crane and his attorney have spent hours testifying to lawmakers, one result being language in the pending National Defense Authorization Act that would clarify whistleblower protections against retaliation and require a Government Accountability Office review of the Defense IG’s conduct.

The Senate version, said Tom Devine, the legal director of the Government Accountability Project who is representing Crane, calls for GAO to perform “a systematic review of the Pentagon IG’s whistleblower program.” That’s based in part on “Crane’s disclosures of contradictory approaches to law enforcement by Obama administration leaders,” Devine said. “Mr. Crane blew the whistle because he perceived a systematic mission breakdown in the Pentagon OIG system.”

The Senate bill calls for a “systematic makeover of the military whistleblower protection act for members of the armed services,” Divine said. “It is landmark free speech legislation if it survives the [House-Senate] conference.” The House version contains a more limited provision, he added, that would modernize legal burdens of proof to give soldiers the same whistleblower rights as civilian employees.

Other disclosures Crane has filed with OSC include allegations Halbooks and Shelley made “false statements under oath, using a fictional narrative to have me removed,” he said. Halbrooks is also accused of softening a report on the Pentagon IG’s handling of arrangements in the investigation of whether then-CIA Director Leon Panetta and Defense Undersecretary for Intelligence Michael Vickers broke classification rules by revealing the name of the Navy Seal Team 6 leader to Hollywood filmmakers making the movie “Zero Dark Thirty.”

Among the other charges being considered by the OSC is whether Crane was thwarted by superiors during an investigation related to the 2010 disclosures by Col. Mark Fassl of patient neglect at a US-funded military hospital in Afghanistan, which became the subject of Capitol Hill hearings.

Staff serving under current acting Defense IG Glenn Fine have been meeting with the OSC on Crane’s issues. “We are reviewing the language and directives in” the Senate NDAA bill, Kathie Scarrah, director of legislative affairs and communications at DoD IG, told Government Executive. As for Crane’s allegations, her office has asked the Justice Department’s Office of Inspector General “to initiate‎ an independent investigation into the allegations. [The IG’s office] will cooperate fully and looks forward to the results of that investigation.”

Former acting DoD IG Halbrooks, now a partner at the law firm of Holland & Knight, told Government Executive in an email, “During my time at DoD OIG I strongly supported the rights of whistleblowers throughout the Department of Defense. I welcome the opportunity to cooperate with any government investigation into these false allegations.”

What are Crane’s goals in continuing these disclosures? “The whistleblower program that I set up at DoD IG has been characterized as the gold standard for the federal government,” he said. “But in light of GAO investigations, in light of the current language in the NDAA, that is no longer the case. Outside advocacy groups and Congress recognized serious problems at DoD IG,” Crane added. “Should Mr. Fine want to return it to the gold standard, I would be willing to help him.”

DefenseOne: http://bit.ly/20RkuZn

« Google Implements Neural Network Computing For Machine Learning
Growing Skepticism Over Drone Attacks »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

ON-DEMAND WEBINAR: What Is A Next-Generation Firewall (and why does it matter)?

ON-DEMAND WEBINAR: What Is A Next-Generation Firewall (and why does it matter)?

Watch this webinar to hear security experts from Amazon Web Services (AWS) and SANS break down the myths and realities of what an NGFW is, how to use one, and what it can do for your security posture.

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

The PC Support Group

The PC Support Group

A partnership with The PC Support Group delivers improved productivity, reduced costs and protects your business through exceptional IT, telecoms and cybersecurity services.

Practice Labs

Practice Labs

Practice Labs is an IT competency hub, where live-lab environments give access to real equipment for hands-on practice of essential cybersecurity skills.

Jooble

Jooble

Jooble is a job search aggregator operating in 71 countries worldwide. We simplify the job search process by displaying active job ads from major job boards and career sites across the internet.

Blueliv

Blueliv

Blueliv is a leading provider of targeted cyber threat information and intelligence. We deliver automated and actionable threat intelligence to protect the enterprise and manage your digital risk.

Digital DNA

Digital DNA

Digital DNA provides Law-Enforcement-Grade Computer Forensics, Cyber Security and E-Discovery Investigations.

Cybersecurity Philippines CERT (CSP-CERT)

Cybersecurity Philippines CERT (CSP-CERT)

Cybersecurity Philippines CERT is the national Computer Emergency Response Team for the Philippines.

FraudHunt

FraudHunt

FraudHunt protects your website from account fraud, ad fraud, fraud clicks, and malicious bots.

Marvell Technology Group

Marvell Technology Group

Marvell is a semiconductor company providing solutions for storage, processing, networking, security and connectivity.

IoT M2M Council (IMC)

IoT M2M Council (IMC)

The IMC is the largest and fastest-growing trade organisation in the IoT/M2M sector.

Sky Republic

Sky Republic

Sky Republic offers a Smart Contract Platform to integrate and synchronize business networks beyond EDI and API.

Insight Partners

Insight Partners

Insight Partners is a leading global private equity and venture capital firm investing in growth-stage technology, software and Internet businesses.

Take Five

Take Five

Take Five is a national campaign offering straight-forward, impartial advice that helps prevent email, phone-based and online fraud – particularly where criminals impersonate trusted organisations.

BlockAPT

BlockAPT

BlockAPT, empowering you with an advanced, intelligent cyber defence platform. We protect our customers digital assets by unifying operational technologies against advanced persistent threats.

Rayzone Group

Rayzone Group

Rayzone Group offers a wide range of Cyber Security solutions and services, providing hollistic protection suitable for both enterprises and National cyber security centers.

Cyber7

Cyber7

CYBER7 is a National Cyber Security Innovation community initiated by Israel National Cyber Directorate, Ministry of Economy and Israel Innovation Authority led by Tech7 – Venture Studio.

Balance Theory

Balance Theory

Balance Theory provides the knowledge infrastructure and collaboration center for the cybersecurity community. A networked community to build better cybersecurity outcomes.

NetRise

NetRise

NetRise was founded as a direct result of the many shortcomings currently in the device security market, specifically targeting the firmware of devices.

Omantel Innovation Labs

Omantel Innovation Labs

The Omantel Innovation Labs is a platform to enable startups and innovators to develop and commercialize solutions within selected technology verticals including cybersecurity.

SyberFort

SyberFort

SyberFort offers a suite of SAAS-based platforms designed to fortify your digital defenses including Threat Intelligence and Brand Protection.