A Cyber Attack On NATO Could Trigger Article 5

Few nations have sophisticated cyber capabilities and for operational security reasons, they are closely guarded, rarely shared, and carefully used.

The US Senate Intelligence Committee Chair Mark Warner warned Russian President  that waging a cyber attack against a NATO country could risk embroiling Moscow in a war against multiple Western governments, including the United States. 

In 2019 NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg said all 29 member countries would respond to a serious cyber-attack on one of them.

Recently a NATO official told Reuters that a cyber attack could be considered an armed attack and trigger "Article 5," it was a significant moment. How significant is harder to judge. "Article 5" is NATO's holy grail, the core of what NATO is about. It is part of the Washington Treaty, signed in 1949, that set up the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation, which started with 12 members and now has 30.

Article 5 states, "The Parties agree that an armed attack against one or more of them in Europe or North America shall be considered an attack against them all."

Mircea Geoană, Deputy Secretary General of NATO, says that when the alliance decided that cyber should be considered an “operational domain,” the bloc also made the call that a “massive cyber attack” on one member state could trigger Article 5 of NATO’s Washington Treaty. This strikes at the heart of the alliance’s defense clause, which states that an attack on one country is considered an attack on all allies.

So, for instance an attack on Poland is effectively the same as an attack on the United States, a powerful deterrent to a potential aggressor, but of course life is never that simple.

For decades it seemed simpler, as an armed attack would be obvious and NATO nations would respond with tanks, artillery, and warplanes. Now, in our new world, nations can be undermined through information warfare and infrastructure crippled by cyber attacks, often difficult to trace.

How NATO should respond to such attacks created much debate, first on the principles of whether a cyber attack could be considered an "armed attack," and secondly if it is, what to do about it.

So, if for instance Poland was attacked with tanks, individual nations are not obliged to respond with military force. Article 5 is powerful but how nations individually respond, with a lot or a little, is still up to them. Nevertheless, a conventional military attack on a NATO nation would get a massive response. Deterrence has worked.

But when we move into the grey zone of "hybrid warfare" that response is harder to predict.

This is one of the aims of Russian strategy towards NATO, to achieve its goals while operating below the threshold that will trigger Article 5. On cyber, those waters will be even muddier given how deniable activity is within cyberspace. In 2014, NATO's leaders made cyber defence a core part of collective defence but policy and activities to implement that decision are still evolving. To that end, for instance, it has a technical agreement with the European Union and a NATO Industry Cyber Partnership. At SHAPE, NATO's military headquarters, there is also a Cyberspace Operations Centre.

Currently, NATO is far more focused on defensive cyber, to secure its systems from attack, and the nature of that is a point of debate.

Some commentators say that passive cyber defence, where you simply build up your virtual walls, leaves the initiative with your adversary, enabling him to probe without consequence until he finds your weak point. Effective defence means also going after the attacker and forcing him onto the back foot, so-called offensive cyber. That is also what would be needed if NATO's responding to an Article 5 breach.

 NATO as an institution does not possess significant cyber capabilities. When it comes to activities, NATO is a command and control organisation using hardware and personnel loaned by members.

Few nations have sophisticated cyber capabilities and for operational security reasons, they are closely guarded, rarely shared, and carefully used. That means if a cyber attack did trigger NATO Article 5, then the actual use of cyber weapons would be outsourced to nations for use on behalf of the Alliance in a coordinated manner. However, as the NATO source told Reuters, a response does not have to be symmetrical, and could theoretically escalate to include a military one.

Persuading 30 nations to agree on this will be hard, and a further possibility is if NATO cannot agree there could be a so-called "coalition of the willing" operating separately. NATO has previously agreed cyber attacks could trigger Article 5, and that itself was a major decision and something of a deterrent to hostile actors. But the reality of having to act on it is now closer than ever before.

Reuters:      BBC:      Cyber Security Dive:     Daily Mail:       C-Span:      GZero

You Might Also Read: 

NATO & Ukraine Agree Deeper Cyber Co-operation:

 

« Making Sense Of The Edge
Twitter Joins Ukraine’s War Effort »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

Syxsense

Syxsense

Syxsense brings together endpoint management and security for greater efficiency and collaboration between IT management and security teams.

The PC Support Group

The PC Support Group

A partnership with The PC Support Group delivers improved productivity, reduced costs and protects your business through exceptional IT, telecoms and cybersecurity services.

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

Perimeter 81 / How to Select the Right ZTNA Solution

Perimeter 81 / How to Select the Right ZTNA Solution

Gartner insights into How to Select the Right ZTNA offering. Download this FREE report for a limited time only.

Authentic8

Authentic8

Authentic8 transforms how organizations secure and control the use of the web with Silo, its patented cloud browser.

Fortinet

Fortinet

Fortinet is a provider of network security systems. Our products provide protection against dynamic security threats while simplifying the IT security infrastructure.

Cyber Security Experts Association of Nigeria (CSEAN)

Cyber Security Experts Association of Nigeria (CSEAN)

Cyber Security Experts Association of Nigeria (CSEAN) is a not for profit group of professionals in the field of Information Security in Nigeria and Diaspora.

Verimuchme

Verimuchme

Verimuchme is a digital wallet and exchange platform to secure, verify and re-use personal information.

Roke Manor Research

Roke Manor Research

Roke is a world-class electronics engineering consultancy. Areas of expertise include cyber security, cyber assurance and cryptographic solutions.

ReSec Technologies

ReSec Technologies

ReSec provides total protection against all types of known and unknown malware threats including viruses, Trojans, ransomware and phishing, regardless of their delivery method.

Savanti Consulting

Savanti Consulting

Savanti provides practitioner-led cyber security services tailored to meet each organisation’s unique requirements.

KeyXentic

KeyXentic

KeyXentic Inc. is a professional mobile and data security service provider. We are devoted to design convenient and strong security for user’s data protection and privacy without any compromise.

SynerLeap

SynerLeap

SynerLeap is ABB's innovation growth hub. Our aim is to help startups accelerate and expand across industries, ranging from industrial automation and robotics to grid technologies and smart cities.

Slice

Slice

Slice offer subscription based Cyber Insurance for small businesses.

BLUECYFORCE

BLUECYFORCE

BLUECYFORCE is the leading professional training and cyber defense training organization in France.

ConnectSecure

ConnectSecure

ConnectSecure (formerly CyberCNS) is a global cybersecurity company that delivers tools to identify and address vulnerabilities and manage compliance requirements.

Vertex Cyber Security

Vertex Cyber Security

Vertex provide Cyber Security Services to small to large businesses including Advise, Consulting, Adding Security Partnership, Penetration Testing, ISO 27001-2 and Audits.

NETAND

NETAND

NETAND privileged access and identity management solutions will secure your business from cyber threats.

Indevtech

Indevtech

Indevtech has been serving Hawaii since 2001, providing end-to-end managed IT services to small- and medium-businesses.

NSW IT Support

NSW IT Support

NSW IT Support: Your exclusive hub for comprehensive Business IT services in Sydney. Our skilled team ensures seamless technology solutions nationwide, consistently delivering top-tier IT support.

QANplatform

QANplatform

QANplatform is a Quantum-resistant hybrid blockchain platform.